A Modo Mio Ristorante

10 STARS. Fabulous! Great atmosphere, great service, no complaints. The staff answered all of our questions about the menu. The meal was superb. I had the special Filet Mignon topped with crab meat and special sauces cooked to perfection.

This is a byob with amazing food and service. We ate outside by the sidewalk so I can't comment on the atmosphere inside.
Our meals were amazing. People around us were also commenting about how good it was.

This place is pricy but it is well worth it.

Excellent food and service. Cozy and comfortable seating, Servers very friendly and helpful

We never regret having dinner in this place. Spell AMAZING? Yes amazingly delicious. Special lobster ravioli was a great choice. Great food menu. Also the meatballs for starter, so good. Great service as well. Must visit this place again. Thank you and stay safe always!

We have discovered this gem last year. We came for a long weekend and ate here twice, the food and service was soooo amazing.
In 2021 we came for 4 days and we’ve had 3 out of 4 dinners at A Modo Mio.
If you’re looking for quality, creative, delicious food, fantastic service, nice ambiance, A Modo Mio is your place!
I’m not a huge Italian food lover (I know, I know, how I can even say such a thing, right?), pasta and red sauce is just not my thing. But here, pasta with “gravy” is not your only option.
You can get a short rib dish, amazing filet mignon, fish and sea food, their calamari is the 💣. Last night they had stuffed squash flowers (I think that’s what they called it) with prosciutto and cheese, lightly battered and fried…. OMG, if you can taste it, don’t hesitate!
If you’re in SIC, make sure you have at least one dinner at A Modo Mio!

Great BYOB. Perfect service. Never a bad meal no matter what we order.

Our group went for New Years Eve. They had a prix fix menu that was quite extensive. The food and service was excellent.

See update:

Why we haven’t been here before tonight, we don’t know. We had one of the best meals ever tonight and served by the sweetest server: Casey. If you eat no one else in Sea Isle….make a reservation today!

*2023 UPDATE* This place has ruined us for all other restaurants in Sea Isle. Don’t be surprised if we book here for the entire week next year. The food is amazing and the service great! We didn’t get to see our favorite server, Casey. We tried to book with her but the person thought we were asking for her b/c we were family. We aren’t. Although, our servers this year were great, too. See you next year!

Really tasty Italian food and extraordinary wait staff. The dining room has elegant high ceilings and it’s very well run. Attentive servers, a first class experience.

We couldn’t have been happier with our food and service. Four tired and hungry kids under 9. Fast and courteous delivery from apps and kids meals to dessert by Kelly and her support staff. Also the only restaurant near us who took reservations on Open Table for parties of more than eight on a Saturday night! Thanks so much! Highly recommend.

Absolutely AMAZING, we weren't sure about sitting outside on the sidewalk but with our family, some wine and the awesome food we didn't even care. You MUST go here!!

phenomenal service
great food
a bit crowded for space but great experience

Great place. Staff was very friendly and very welcoming. The dinner was delicious, but the dessert was the best part.
Edit: second time being here for vacation. I always have a plan going in but usually end up getting the special. The food was great and the dessert was superb.

Awesome food. Very small intimate atmosphere in a very good way. Head chef Eric is an amazing cook. Recommend for any date night. Especially if you wanna score some serious brownie points with you’re significant other

We went there two nights in a row, staying in Sea Isle city to celebrate my birthday weekend. Both nights the food was incredible. The specials were out of this world. . The servers, the manager, the ambulance, the location the decor: all of it is 100% five star- amazing restaurant. We definitely recommend this restaurant for any occasion

I would say a highly refined italian restaurant with amazing staff and fresh tasty italian speciality. This resaturant will offer you classical and some modified italian style food that will scent your mouth. Fresh pasta its also a choose in this restaurant. Staf its friendly and polite. Everyone that like italian food and good company will find this at "A MODO MIO"

We had an off season meal tonight - and it was delicious! All of the food for everyone in our party was incredible! Delicious fish, short ribs, octopus, salads. We wanted seconds of it all! We didn’t get our waiters name, unfortunately, be he was great! (And socially distant inside.)

The short version is highly recommend this place.

The long version is my wife and I had a failed trip to Cape May so we decided to find dinner near the beach house. This place had good reviews so we thought we would give it a shot. Everything we had was delicious and the service was fantastic. The only down side is it’s not the most kid friendly place. We decided to eat outside hoping that would distract the kids (5 & 1) and that worked. Plus the waitress (I think her name was Devon) was great with the kids and went out of her way to help. Probably better for a parents night out but I would bring the kids back again.

Amazing food and great service. It was just perfect for my family of 5. I am a tough critic, so a 5 star review isn’t easy to earn. I can’t reiterate how amazing the food was. Every single dish was amazing. The bread was amazing. The sauces were amazing. The deserts. Everything!

Go here… get the pasta a mood mio… and then tell me 5 stars is no warranted. Great spot, amazing food… go at 5 and there is no wait.