Renna's West & Mio Gelato Cafe

New owners very courteous, very pleasant to deal with lot of good ideas on how to fix a place up ! Excellent pizza will continue to visit both establishments

Very clean, open floor, easy seating. Food is excellent.
Get a number, seat they will call when food is ready.

It's fast and give vet discount.
Pizza Slice is Hugh.

Stopped here for pizza with the kids. The pizza was awesome! Great toppings and crust. Called ahead and had the pizza ready for us so it was cooled down (highly recommend). They also had a nice dessert selection for the kids after pizza. Staff was very friendly. Will be back for sure.

I'm definitely a fan of everything they have to offer here. From the pizza, chicken wings, and dessert options it's hard to make a decision it's all so delicious. I would without a doubt recommend anyone and everyone. Easy 5 stars on food alone.

In my opinion, this place has the best pizza I've ever had in my 48 years of life. I've been all over up and down the east coast, NYC, Chicago, California, Florida......I've never had a pizza better than Renna's. 🤷‍♂

Love their pizza fresh from the oven! Cheese melted and delicious sauce...I let it sit for about 2 minutes and then add garlic powder and red pepper flakes and am in heaven 😋 😍

Pizza is amazing and so were the desserts!

Quick pick-up for lunch. Pizza is de-lish!

One of our family favorites. Classic pizza, delecious and large portions. And many, many amazing options for desert or take-home. Prices are also fair, and you can expect this to be a great family friendly environment with polite and helpful staff! Also very clean during our visits!

I've been going here for years. I love the food. New York thin style pizza.... 😎 subs are amazing also

Great food and friendly staff. Renna's is known for its pizza, but they also have excellent subs and even dinners. They have a great fish fry on Fridays. And of course their gelato and baked goods for dessert are very tasty too. The restaurant has plenty of room for people to be spaced apart too.

The 🍕 pizza is always delicious. Consequently, we always make it a point to stop, when we are in Olean. And, the food comes out quicker than the Fast Food Restaurants!

Was in town to buy a car (100 miles from home in the Rochester area). I asked the salesman to recommend a pizza place and he sent me here. I had my son and our German exchange student with me. The pizza was excellent and the service fast and friendly. The restaurant is open and airy and clean, with lots of tables. Two thumbs up from the two teenage boys as well. I don't know if I'll ever be in Olean again (it's quite remote), but if I am, I'll try my best to eat here again.

Great customer service, clean, excellent pizza and rigatoni

I'm never disappointed when I visit, my pizza is always perfect. The employees are bery polite, I've never had the feeling of being unwanted from them. So kudos to Rennas. I will return there the next time my family and I are craving pizza.

Love rennas and mio gelatos very much however they could be making A LOT more money if they waited to clean the lemonade machine till AFTER the close!!! Love their lemonade however it's 6pm and I can't get lemonade due to them taking care of it for the night they close at 6:45 pm sooo it seems ridiculous to me that they would do that especially because it's a pretty popular drink there !!! Highly recommend it when and if you can get it!

The crust... Mmmmmmm.... It's so.... Good... Their sauce is perfect too. I mean perfect... Friendly folks, local, super clean inside, and I haven't had the deserts yet - but whoa! They have a long display filled with pastries and cookies and brownies and GELATO!!! So the name fits too 😁. I highly recommend for folks from Buffalo and Rochester who are in the area to stop by here and grabs slice. If you're local it's a nice place to bring the whole family for dinner. And if you're picky about your pizza and don't like the other options in town - you found your gem. Bon appetit.

From the moment you walk in and see the pizza makers tossing the dough the old fashioned way, you know you are in for a treat! The entire staff is friendly and goes above and beyond to make sure you have everything that you need. The menu is extensive! Literally something for everyone from their FAMOUS pizza (available tons of different ways) to salads to fish frys and even gelato! Oh, and don't get me started on the bakery case and specialty cakes and cookies. It really is a hidden gem in Olean, NY. Try it, you'll see!

Great food & great prices. The gelato and desserts are sooooooo good. My kids absolutely love everything we’ve had. O yea, the wings are great too!

Friendly atmosphere! The gelato is awesome, they even let you try it first. The pizza is great and is way better when your dining in.