Mystic Blue Aquarium

Absolutely love this place. So long story short we’ve been here in years past with the old owner. And we got some fish from them, but their cichlid selection wasn’t great. So we started to go to another local bigger shop. However recently in months last, most fish we got from them never made it past a month or two. And I’ve been keeping fish for over 15 years so the experience is there. So a few weeks ago I wanted to stop by mystic and see if their inventory has changed. Well that’s when we found out they have a new owner and he is absolutely fantastic. He is very knowledgeable and does not hesitate to share his knowledge and you can tell how the tanks are kept and the shop, he cares very much for the hobby and his store/fish. All the tanks are in very good shape, along with the fish. The first day we went we left with 3 fish, and they all acclimated very well and were very active. He let us know he was getting a shipment in that week and to stop back, so we did today. Again we were greeted very nicely and weren’t pressured. When we found the fish we’d like he got them and we chatted for a bit. When we’re ready to do a salt water tank we will definitely be spending the money with him. Absolutely great place and great owner. Very strongly suggest stopping in! We will be back!

Very cool Fish Aquarium to visit and they have an amazing fish selection not to mention a great coral selection also. Staff is extremely friendly and the owner is always fair with his prices. If you cant find what you are looking for ownership will do their best to find it somewhere and have it available for you. I'm extremely pleased with all my purchases from Mystic Blue Aquarium they totally take care of their fish so when you purchase them you know they have been taken cared for.

Amazing. Amazing selection, assistance, and the owners seriously care about their fish and so many more. Corals are beautiful displays! Check out these photos:) 🐟 🐠 very relaxing no matter what

My friend and I stopped in to look for some pea puffers this past Sunday. We were greeted warmly, and browsed the shop to see the great selection of fresh and saltwater fish.

The owner answered all of our questions thoroughly, informed us of when he receives new shipments, and was an absolute pleasure to work with!

I’ve recommended Mystic Blue to so many people already, and can’t wait to keep coming back!

Amazing prices! Great customer service!
Tons of selection, and great deals.
I got two fish for half off each!
And they look great!
I’ll be returning😆🙃!

Loving the new ownership! You can really see how he is trying to repair the damage left by the previous owners. Tanks are clean, and livestock is looking so much better!

Definitely worth a visit, if they don’t have what you want, Fareed is more than happy to special order it for you, and what they do have in stock, will surprise you.

Rome wasn’t built in a day, and change of ownership always brings about new tides. It’s a fact that they are going in the right direction, and I see it changing every time I go in. Great job guys, keep up the great work.

New owners, lovely guy. He has a dream and I can't wait to see that as a reality. It just switched recently. So prices may change and selection than what you are typically used to. He will definitely have a more variety of plants and more freshwater fish for sale.

Also now a POC owned business, support local!

Mystic Blue Aqaurium is one of the best aqaurium shops in the WNY area if not the best. The owner is one of the most down to earth people you will ever meet. He has to be one of the most experienced aqaurium shop owners I have ever seen work, he always ensures the best prices. He is is always working super hard to make sure everyone that steps foot into the store has a beyond delightful experience. His tanks are always crystal clear, has all the supplies and fish you could ever want and he always has a answer to any aqaurium inquiries! He always makes sure you find the fish of your dreams! I would give this aqaurium shop 100 stars if I could! Thank you Mystic Blue Owner that I do not know the name of😂. I will be back very soon! Thank you for all the hard work you put into this incredible aqaurium shop!

Very helpful staff who have great knowledge and very clean tanks. The prices are better than any other local pet shop and felt welcomed and the store is very clean I will be back again for more fish and shrimp! Keep up the great work guys

Spectacular service, spotless displays, experienced staff, huge range, competitive pricing. I cant sing enough praise to this aquarium. The filtration quality and cleanliness of the displays are very great! I am more than happy to travel over an hour to visit these guys when I get the free time.

Awesome shop! Beautiful selection of fish both freshwater and salt. Tanks are clean, lots of corals, huge selection of equipment and top of the line products. Very nice owner too! Would definitely recommend!

I'm just starting out keeping fish for the last year or two and Mystic Blue has always been helpful. Their staff are friendly and knowledgeable and have helped me through a number of issues I've run into. I have bought a number of fish here and they have always been healthy and successful. They have a nice set up and a good variety to choose from and have even offered to do special orders if I'm looking for something specific.

Beautiful fish tanks, salt and fresh water. Staff very friendly and knowledgeable especially Chris( I believe his name was). I can't thank him enough...he saved my fish. My tank is now beautiful! They also have very unique types of fish. I am used to the ordinary swordtails but the have green, black, red velvet, yellow, etc. Crazy Cool!!! Excellent place a must visit if you love fish.

Super friendly and knowledgeable staff. The place is super clean compared to other lfs' in the area. Not the biggest store, but still has pretty much everything you'd be looking for. Prices are tad higher than local competitor, but not enough to drive you away. Fish all look very healthy and lively. Excellent selection of both freshwater & salt water equipment and livestock. Will be coming back again when I'm ready to add more fish.

I went there with a friend and was in awe of the knowledge. It is clean and the customer service was incredible. They answered every question for the curious mind of mines. My friend stated she has bought a variety of fish and they were always healthy. They are the go to place if you want to purchase a fish or supplies. Highly recommended.

My first time in was a great experience! I meet the friendly owners. The Store is clean, a good selection of fish. Fish and plants seemed priced fairly. Supplies I found were priced very competitively even to online prices. Will definitely be back.

A friend needed to come here for fish. I visited this place with him. The staff working immediately greeted us. They were very willing and able to assist us. They were very knowledgeable on everything they have in the store. One of the gentleman actually educated me on everything needed/required to start and maintain a salt water aquarium. I would recommend this place to anyone in the market for fish or supplies.

I adopted a couple fish when my brother moved out of town. I went to Mystic Blue Aquarium because they are very close to my house and I try to shop from local businesses as much as possible. I was pleasantly surprised by the vast selection of fish and accessories. Being a new fish owner, I had many questions that the friendly and helpful staff happily answered. I have found everything I needed and at fair prices.

Great selection of fishes and very knowledgeable staff. The store is neatly kept and all the fishes are healthy. The staff explained me in details about the lightning conditions, aquarium plants and tank selection. They were great help and I'd definitely return to this store in future.

Used to frequent this shop a couple years ago and decided to stop back in. It's under new ownership now and he's very friendly and helpful. Definitely recommend this shop!