Eli & Annie's Bakery

The most delicious donuts I’ve ever tasted! I felt it in my toes! Off the beaten track, just an open sign in the window and the smell of amazing things happening. Highly suggest a nice morning drive to this wonderful bakery.

Picked up one of their fry pies at a coffee shop in Meyersdale and then used the label to find the shop. Bought a large selection of fry pies. Don’t make me choose a favorite. Good doughnuts too.

Very good Amish owned and family bakery worth going out of your way for with Thursday through Saturday featuring homemade donuts, pies, cinnamon rolls, cookies and homemade bread,

Wonderful little shop -- smell of delicious fresh baked goods embraces you as soon as you pass through the door. Got cookies, donuts and fry pies which were all heavenly. Lovely conversation with the young lady at the register. Looking forward to returning whenever we're in the area.

We went there today on a whim. We are in Pennsylvania for a family reunion and decided to take a day trip down into Maryland. Soooo worth the drive in! The donuts were already sold out, but the hand pies were amazing! Warmed up for 30 seconds they were even better! We also got some wonderful yeasty rolls to put butter from High Country Creamery on - a perfect pairing! I wish we'd bought more. The woman in the bakery - Annie I'm assuming - was wonderful and sweet!

I went here over a year ago and got fry pies they was amazing!!! I'm going to be back there again soon does anyone know there hours? I'd love to stop by and get some more :) so yummy

Best little bakery this side of the Mississippi! Drove 1.5 hrs and was not disappointed. Fried little pies, coconut cream pie right out of the oven, yeast rolls , pecan maple frosted cookies etc!!! Prices can’t be beat. I will definitely make the trip again to the quaint little town of Grantsville.

The BEST baked goods ever... Especially the donuts and whoopie pies.

Fantastic Amish bakery! They didnt have much when we got there (late Saturday), but we did get some fried pies (awesome!) and maple syrup. They said Thursdays they have alot. Will go back when we are in the area for sure.

Bought two loaves of homemade bread and a cherry pie. Completely satisfied! The cherry pie and breads were delicious. Big thumbs up!

The doughnuts were amazing. The other stuff we got was also good, but the doughnuts were absurdly good. FYI if they run out of doughnuts, you can also find their doughnuts at the Kuntry Korner store about 2 miles from this location.

A wonderful little bakery run by happy and caring people. Be careful there, it all looks good and tastes better.

A small store front, but great donuts, great bread and a good selections of donuts, breads, pies, and different type of cinnamon rolls. Nice staff as well. Pretty sure it is cash only.

Amazing, amazing baked goods!!! I got homemade rolls, honey wheat oatmeal bread and a strawberry rhubarb fried pie and all were so very delicious!!

They have the best fry pies ever and I have tried alot of them. They have cookies, pies, cakes and more!!

Best doughnuts I've ever had. Loved the Apple dumplings. This place is a must try

Excellent iced sugar cookies.

Wonderful friendly women. We got frycakes, a doughnut and a cake. Every thing is amazing and good prices.

Unbelievable awesome !!
Taste like grandma's of yester years 😋

Best treats in Garrett county MD! Love the donuts 🍩