Those Pizza Guys

I’d give 10 stars if I could! It was our first time at Those Pizza Guys, and we were very pleasantly surprised. We ordered their summer special Princess Peach pizza and the Sunny in St. Jacobs pizza, and they were both amazing! Super fresh ingredients, flavourful, and had a delicious thin crust. We also ordered the Pazzo Sticks which were fantastic too. The staff are super friendly, and the place is very cute and clean. Definitely coming back!

Has been on my list of must-try places for a long time now.
Finally got a chance to stop in yesterday for a late afternoon lunch, and so happy I did!

Amazing 👏
The service was amazing.
The food... I can't even tell you how delicious it was. Go try this for yourself, you can taste the good quality ingredients and the passion that is put into it.

Definitely a great little spot to sit and enjoy some good eats while shopping in the village.

Shared a Marg & BigMac Pizza. Both pizzas were perfectly made. One pizza would likely feed one adult.

Food took 10 minutes to reach the table.

Avg. price of a pizza was around $15. You are paying for a well-made, unique ingredient, thin pizza. Lots of pizza options to choose from.

Nice family friendly atmosphere.

Staff was friendly, food was quick to order and arrive.

Decided to have the big mac pizza, since it sounded interesting. Partner had ordered the Margherita pizza. Both were delicious!
Will definitely be coming again.

Those Pizza Guys in St Jacobs is a local gem that enhances the collective community experience of living here. Although pizza is in the name, go for the sandwich. There is a 15/10 sandwich called the “Guiseppe”. … get it “Barry style” with double the meat and melt the cheese. Buyer beware; it is quite likely that you will not eat a better sandwich ever again in your entire life. For what it’s worth, I give it my highest recommendation.

I was craving for wood fired pizza and this place came in my suggestions and thank god i went there it is a cozy place with good vibes and so many options to try the food was delicious. Also to mention their toilets were clean and they have parking too.

Love the pizza here!! The Sunny in St.Jacobs is my personal fave. The restaurant is cute and cozy and the patio is a great place to hang out when the weather is nice.

Those pizza guys in the heart of St. Jacobs is a wood fired oven kind of pizza place. The dough is tender but holds together well. They use good quality ingredients and make a pizza that you can get a little of each topping in each bite.

We had the Marg: tomato sauce, mozzarella, fiore di latte and fresh basil. We asked for arugula on top and they gladly provided some. All the ingredients were good quality.

We also had the featured pizza which on this day was called Mortadella Madness, which is pesto, mozzarella, fiore di latte, mortadella, onion, green olives, fresh parm and pistachios. All of the ingredients played well with the others. My only critique would be that it was a little bit salty because of all the different salty ingredients. It was delicious and the crust had just a little bit of char on some pieces. Char is flavour.

We actually chose to eat in at the restaurant. It’s very tiny, but very homey feeling. Lots of cookbooks about Italian ingredients and photographs of the area that they are located. It was my first time there, and I will definitely go back at some point in the future.

Best pizza I've had in years, hands down. Great vibes, attentive, delicious, nothing more to ask for.

Delicious thin crust pizza. We had both the margarita and the mushroom. Toppings are delicious and the cheese is very good quality. Good selection of non alcoholic beverages and craft beers. Very little seating and I saw most of their business was carry out. Friendly staff and clean environment.

Great spot for thin crust, wood oven pizzas. Their take on bruschetta is amazing - I could have had it as a meal in its own! Great selection of canned craft beers and love that that have the Collective Arts non-alcoholic as an option!

My wife and I frequent St. Jacobs and found this little gem yesterday. Who would ever think that a pizza in St. Jacobs could reach such epic proportions! I think even David Portnoy should make the trek. Killer thin crust with crispy edges, sauce tasted like they made it in house, authentic small circles of pepperoni, and mushrooms that actually have real flavor. My wife had a homemade Ciabatta bun/vegan sandwich with a homemade vinaigrette dressing and arugula that was excellent. Kudos guys for making yesterdays road trip a memorable one. See ya soon. Jeff -Thornhill, Ontario.

Best pizza in the region! Love the thin crust and a great amount of basil on the margherita. Fast service and only ever wait 10 minutes for our food.

Excellent wood fired pizza, perfectly cooked. We got the pepperoni and the mushroom, both phenomenal. Pepperoni great fresh tomato sauce and flavourful cheese, bit of dried Italian herbs, all nice. Mushrooms were delicious, complemented by a nice garlic confit, and fresh mozz, and pancetta. Crust perfectly cooked, slightly blackened, beautiful fermentation bubbles.
Chef Pete was very nice and clearly passionate about pizza, thank you very much and I'll be back soon.

Their pizza always delights! I got the Pep on your step and it’s the perfect amount of cup and char pepperoni. The crust is the best: chewy with a light putter crisp.
Every pizza I’ve ordered from here has been a hit. Do not forget to pick up some dips. I indulged in the peproncini and dilly ranch. Yum!

Thin crust pizza. Delicious. Really quick service (go to the counter, order and wait at your table - but not for long)

Nice selection of beverages and a pleasant patio

I heard this place had the pepperoni oil cups - and they delivered! Real Italian style, thin, wood-fired pizza. Pepperoni that curls so beautifully that it captures all that oil pep flavor. There is only one size which is personal pizza size. The pepperoni one was $13 and well worth it. In my opinion it’s the best pizza around. I can’t wait to go back!

Pizza is simply delicious. It has many flavors to choose from, individual size only, thin crust. The atmosphere is very intimate. There are not many tables to sit on, though. You have to order your pizza at the counter and the waitress will give it to you at the table.

I recently left a review for Block 3 since I had ordered a Those Pizza Guys pizza while I was enjoying a beer there. Of course I also need to give a shout out to Those Pizza Guys!

Their pizzas are thin crust, consistently cooked perfectly, and full of flavour. I often go for the Pep in Your Step and if I'm feeling like a bit of spice, I get the Giddy Up, which adds jalaps to the pepperoni pie.

They have a cool patio and parking is usually available on Front St (or in the lot at the end of the road). Once you've parked but before you're ready to shop, head in for a pizza and pint!

One other tip: if you have a pup with you, you can order Those Pizza Guys from Block 3 and they will deliver it right to you! I'm not sure if Those Pizza Guys patio is pup friendly - it might be!

Fantastic Wood fire pizza. Pies are cooked to perfection, toppings are fresh and plentiful. Lots of different unique variations to choose from but the kids always get a smores pizza to share for dessert.