Mueller's Bakery

Mueller’s Bakery gave us the wedding cake of our dreams. For our beach-themed cake, we wanted something unique, with a sense of humor, but still a bit romantic. So we sent them reference photos of my and my husband’s real-life bathing suits, and on top of our delicious two-tier cake, our toppers were two beach chairs and our little bathing suits made of fondant. (The joke was that our topper bride and groom ditched the cake and ran off skinny dipping.) They even put little footprints in the cookie-crumble sand on the top of the cake. We couldn’t have been more thrilled with how it turned out, and how it tasted!

Our family has been a big fan of Mueller's for years so decided to use them for our wedding last September. Katie was a joy to work with for the tasting, and they captured our request perfectly, not to mention delicious!

A visit to the Jersey shore isn’t complete without a visit to Mueller’s. Their crumb cake is to die for (that crumb to cake ratio!!) and everything else is excellent too. This trip we tried their blueberry tart and there must be a quart of blueberries on that bad boy. If you’re in the neighborhood, go. If it’s a Saturday or Sunday morning, be prepared to wait. Like an hour. But it will be worth it.

This little bakery was so quaint and cute. The display cases were beautifully laid out with many different breads, cakes, cookies, pastries and danishes, bagels. Bagels. It was very popular on the Saturday morning that we visited and we were waited on pretty quickly.
We went in for the crumb bun because we heard that it was a favorite and it did not disappoint! We ordered a whole box which had around 8 or 9 pieces and we had it covered in confectionary sugar. My daughter also got a frozen picture cookie. She had her choice from so many cute Easter cookies and cupcakes but chose Frozen lol.
We had actually gone to Baron's bagel shop as well and they had Mueller's crumb bun cream cheese there so we got to try that too! That cream cheese was so amazing and paired perfectly with our French toast bagel.
We will definitely be visiting them again in the future!

I love Muellers. The cakes and baked goods are excellent. The staff is always pleasant. Highly recommend. My literal only note would be to please get boxes that fit your custom cakes. I've ordered several a year for the past few years and they never fit in the box causing them almost always to get dinged up in transit. Other than that absolutely the best.

Always crowded but for a very good reason. The staff and product selection are extraordinary and awesome. There is always a large supply of bread, decorated cakes, cookies, cupcakes. Their crumb cakes are always a hit when we have them.

The staff goes above and beyond to make every specialty cake or cupcake perfect and beyond belief.

Mullers will be our only go-to for bakery goods. Anyone that doesn't already know how awesome this place is is surely missing out

Delicious! This place came recommended by friends who I was staying the weekend with. Well worth it! The crumb cake has the perfect amount of crumbs on the top and the cake is nice and moist. The donuts were just as good - everyone's favorite was the Boston Creme. Would definitely order again.

This is a great bakery with great desserts and pastries and very nice employees. It's very popular. Take a number and wait your turn--it's worth it. Our favorites are the apple fritters (you may not see them but be sure to ask anyway), crumb cake and any cake to celebrate any occasion.

The best bakery goods I've tasted in a long time
Especially the blueberry pastries. Fresh and awesome.

Highly recommend. I ordered a birthday cake from a bakery in brick called “Elisa’s Bakery” (stay away from) and they gave my daughter the wrong cake. We tried muellers for another cake and it was exactly what we wanted. The cake was very fresh and tasted delicious. I will definitely be back. Thank you for saving my daughters birthday !

My bread basket is amazing the rolls are super soft and smells great too

This is a great bakery they have a wide selection of cookies, cakes and all sorts of delicious baked goods. One of my favorite things to get here is there crumb cake.
So if your in the area and are looking for some tasty baked goods, this is the spot to check out.

There isn’t enough words to express how much I love this bakery! Their pastries are always so fresh and the crumb cake is THE BEST around and that is not a joke! Staff is always so friendly and even though they are always busy they always get you in and out fairly quickly

After hearing from my sorority sister who works there about it for 15 years I finally visited and damn was it worth the wait! For the crumb to cake ratio alone! They also sell the crumbs by themselves which I highly recommend you microwave and put on top of ice cream! I also got a petit four which tasted like a love match between marzipan and cake dipped in gorgeous icing. I also got a brownie which was similar to the petit four in how moist, light and flavorful it was! I would love to go back and try absolutely everything! Jersey has some of the best bakeries I've been to throughout the world and this one is the epitome of what makes them so great! Beautiful variety, lovely service and absolutely delicious treats!

Best bakery on the Jersey shore hands down
Got bday cake and everyone loved it … honestly can’t go wrong with anything here

WOW did they knock it out of the park! This cake for my fiancé’s 30th was incredible. I sent them the invitation and asked they model it after that, and they did, even down to making the Galaxy print darker like the invite. They were so easy to work with and the cake was delicious, too! I would recommend them to anyone!

Long long wait if you go at peak time but we’ll worth the wait - they never disappoint. Idea - have pre-packaged things that are always ordered and dedicate a cashier to simply check that out with coffee - might move people through a lot faster during peak times?

Excellent bakery, helpful workers. Outstanding coffee. Parking lot adjacent. A small suggestion, after you pickup your order, and as you walk back to your car, consider having your bounty overlooking the pond at the far end of the parking lot, benches are provided.

The Raspberry Crumb Cake is one of my favorite bake goods on the planet!!!! Try to order ahead just in case there is a line.

BLUEBERRY season and lots of blueberries decorating the desserts in the window. Passed up on usual faves to order the blueberry galette (see photo) which is a light phyllo type flaky crusted pastry filled with sweet cream and lots of berries. Oh so delish. Must try the peanut butter round cookie that tastes like a tastykake Tandy cake! It’s a must stop when near point pleasant, NJ.