Pietro's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

I’m rating the pizza. Personally it’s my favorite pizza place. The Pizza is just the way I like it. Atmosphere is classic. Other things I’ve had have been very good as well. And it’s been around forever, check it out

My wife is gluten sensitive so she ordered the gluten free stuffed shells with meat sauce.
It's two days later and she is still talking about how good it was.
I would recommend this place for everyone, great service, great food and a nice comfortable dining area.
Just make sure you are ready to hear how good the food was for a few days.

I went there yesterday afternoon with my granddaughter. I had a issue with digest ingredients my roll on my meatballs sandwich I started coughing an feeling bad. Billy our waiter came over am asked if I would like a glass of water which helped me he bought me out another sandwich with the roll not toasted . kind considerate . food was awesome I can't tank Billy our servicer enough.

Never had a bad meal here, beat pizza around for sure. Cheese isn't greasy and its cooked perfect each time. The dinners are top notch as well!

Just got to the manahawkin area about two weeks ago. I’ve been in Pietros every other day!! The food, staff and atmosphere is amazing. I love supporting businesses like this!! A must try if you’re in the LBI/manahawkin area!

We just ordered pizza for my daughter's birthday party from Pietro's and everyone was asking where it was from because they liked it. The staff was very friendly when I called to order and asked if I wanted it double cut for the kids.

First, I want to start off by saying these are the best meatballs I've ever had! Second, any party or event we have we always order trays of food from Pietros.
Today, I had to pick up a few trays for xmas this year, and I had my toddler with me and my hands full. They had me pull my car up and loaded the food in for me. It's a simple yet really meaningful and helpful gesture. Service, food, and atmosphere are amazing, and I can't recommend Pietros enough!

Been going there since ‘94.
Hands down, best pizza in Stafford Township and all of LBI.
Nick and his staff are the best and the pizza and food are delicious. Simply the best.

Pietro’s is my go-to pizzeria. The food is great, the prices are so much better than anything on the island, and the people are wonderful and professional. I usually don’t stay and eat, but occasionally I do, and they have a very nice restaurant - not just a pizza place with some seats. Can’t recommend them enough.

I do not get to visit often but when I do, I am never disappointed. The portions are large and very reasonably priced. Excellent pizza and Chicken Parm is my favorite go to dinner item. Try this restaurant, you will definitely return.

Our waiter was amazing they had amazing makeup and was so kind. Food was amazing and authentic, best place in town!

Food was great and the smile from the beautiful woman behind the counter was even better!!

The Eggplant and ricotta pizza is amazingly good! The best I’ve ever had! Did take out.

THIS PLACE WAS FANTASTIC!
From the service to the food .. can’t go wrong!!

I never find good Italian food in Jersey, but this place is heaven! Plus, the staff is super friendly

I tried the pizza, which was also amazing! I will come back

Food was excellent. Huge portions for price paid. Very friendly staff.

Place is awesome. Never had a bad meal at Pietros.

Great place & food with reasonable prices compared to Island restaurants.

First time there but it definitely won't be our last. The service was great, prices were very reasonable and the food was amazing! The staff were super friendly.

We have been going for years , best good even & Jennifer is great

I had my sisters birthday celebration here and it was perfect from start to finish! Nick and his amazing team members are professional and friendly. The food is amazing and our server Taylor was great! Thank you for a great night!! Highly recommended you won't be disappointed!!!