Oh What A Bagel

I’m surprised to see any negative reviews at all. I’ve lived in Bayville for the last 6 years and oh what a bagel has been the staple bagel place for my husband and I. Bagels and sandwiches are delicious. Service is always great. I always recommend this shop to anyone new to the area.

Great counter service with huge and tasty bagels. Small but adequate dining space. Quality ingredients with a no frills atmosphere.
I had a great experience even with multiple food allergies that do not include wheat so if bagels are made in a traditional way they are safe for me. Staff answered all my questions and I had a plain bagel with scallion cream cheese without issues. Thank you so much!

My favorite bagel shop!!! They are one of the few places that make a French toast bagel, sooo good!!!! Toasted w butter. I’m not a morning person but in the rare case my son misses his bus and I drive him I will stop here and grab my bagel. I wish they were open later into the afternoon but It makes sense they close early since they open very early.

They have great bagels but they are always burnt. If you don’t want a burnt bagel just ask them for a lightly cooked one and they have a stash in the back. They must have a new cook because they were never like this. Still a great bagel shop.

These are best bagels I’ve ever eaten! The cream cheese has perfect taste and texture. I’m a loyal customer of Oh What a Bagel, right here in Bayville NJ. My hope is that this family owned and operated business will be around for a long time! Thank you for your service to our family and to our community, keep up the good work!

We go here every Sunday and they even donate bagels to our Church. But I’m not giving them 5 stars for that, their bagels are really delicious and huge. I love this place. Would not go anywhere else. My hubby owned a bagel store many yrs ago, and he used to make them by hand every morning, he made the best bagels in his area, he KNOWS great bagels and if he said this bagel place is very good then u can bet it is. My hubby is a bagel expert. No joke.

This place never disappoints. Their bagels are huge and delicious. Sandwiches are amazing and they have a large selection of cream cheese spreads.

If you ain't never been there you need to go and try it they got the biggest freshest bagels you could possibly have and they're delicious they make great breakfast sandwiches too excellent coffee nice people try it you'll like it

This is the best bagel place we have visited in New Jersey! Their bagels are huge, delicious, and warm. They have a lot of variety of flavors, including chocolate chip and whole wheat everything.. Also, for the seasons, they have green bagels for St.Patricks day and red bagels for Valentine's day. I recommend calling ahead to place your order because the lines can get pretty long on the weekends.

Always great bagels. Don’t stop in too often but when I do everyone at work loves these. They are simply the best and the sandwiches are delicious. Great place and friendly staff.

I pick up a few bagels almost every Sunday with my two girls, and they love going! All the employees are always very friendly to us, no matter how busy they are. We absolutely love their bagels, especially the double sided everything!

Fantastic service and I mean 6 stars out of 5 level fantastic service. The food is equally as magnificent and the overall experience is why I was inspired to acknowledge said awesomeness and put it in writing to publicly let people know that all the staff are immensely awesome and they all deserve mountains of credits. !

GREAT BAGELS.

If you know bagels, this place doesn't disapoint.

If you think Wawa has bagels... then I don't know what to say other than GET HERE AND HAVE A REAL BAGEL!!!!!

Supports their community, owned locally and a staple of the town for years!

I love this place. Everyone here is Super friendly and very outgoing. The bagels are amazing, super soft. They run out of the good ones fast so you need to get there early.

Absolutley love this bagel shop! The fact that there bagels are always fresh is just the icing on the cake. Amazing service is a lack for better words,great vibes,and delicious food make for an overal 5 out of 5 experience for me! I would refer any 1 to give this shop a try,you wont go back to any other place!

Only bagel shop I've gone to for 15 years. Best around

BEST PLACE TO GET BAGELS ON THE ENTIRE EAST COAST!! They have these huge sandwiches that are amazing!!! They have a bunch of different kinds of bagels and they really are that good! I will always go to this place!

We were craving a REAL bagel and we found it! Super fresh! Super friendly! Super delicious! We were going go pick up sandwiches for our canoe trip later on in the afternoon and guess what? They make sandwiches, too! They sliced the turkey fresh for our sandwich. We now have our go to place for breakfast and lunch when we're camping! Well done Michelle and Michelle! Thank you!

Great local bagel shop with quick service, great selection, amazing prices, and friendly staff. Been coming here for over a decade. Highly recommended, a must visit place if you're a Berkeley resident.

This place has the best bagels and breakfast sandwiches. I come here at least a few times a week. This place has been here for a long time which is nice.