Bay Village Pizza

V good pizza, took 20 minutes to get a 18inch classic cheese but there were plenty of places to window shop at while we waited.

Bay Village Pizza is a local treasure! Their pizzas are a slice of perfection, with a thin crust that's perfectly crispy. The sauce is flavorful, and the toppings are fresh and abundant. The menu boasts a variety of pizza options, catering to all tastes. The friendly staff and cozy ambiance make dining here a pleasure. Whether you're grabbing a quick lunch or having a family dinner, Bay Village Pizza is a must-try. It's evident that they put love into their craft, and I can't wait to return for more delectable pizza experiences! 🍕😍

First time going to to Bay Village Pizza after usually eating at panzones. Living full time in North Jersey where pizza is an art, I can tell you the pizza here is simply amazing. Flavorful, large slices that fold perfectly. We had pepperoni, mushroom, and plain and all 3 were amazing. Slightly more expensive than at home ($25 for a L pie) but it’s cheap for a place on the Island. I highly recommend!

Very good Pizza, Even with it being a Friday night around 6pm, ordered and was served my Pizza within 15 mins. Crust was very good, and pepperoni was not greasy. A little pricey but your at the shore, and it's actually very good so I don't mind. Definitely going back.

Pizza was fantastic! My favorite on the island! Line was long, so definitely recommend calling ahead. They had a pick up window so was easy to grab and go. Slice's are big!

Quick!
Clean!
Good food!
Be patient as this is a hot spot to grab a quick bite in the hot town !
But food is very good! Been coming here for 15 years!

Best pizza on LBI. Pies and slices are HUGE and fries are cooked perfectly every time.

Damn it's expensive and you'll wait a while, but it is totally worth it. I've been getting pizza here since the 90s and it is just as good now as it was then. The fries aren't bad either.

Glad to be down in New Jersey again to experience real NY style pizza. This place sits across from the water park and is delicious and only serves pizza or fries from a pickup window and both are excellent!! I ordered a slice here and it was gigantic and so greasy and good I loved it! The fries were equally great, skins on and long and large and tasty. Prices are right and they serve old style sodas from Birch beer to 7up. Loved it!

Great pizza to go with the brewery right around the corner. The slices hit the spot

My favorite pizza place on the island hands down, you'll get a quality thin-crust that you won't forget anytime soon (my favorite absolutely has to be the fresh garlic topping). I consistently always go back and I brag about this place to my friends, so genuinely I don't think you'll have any problems having a good time, not to mention it's located in a fantastic spot, with an area to eat right next to it outdoors, it's a great spot to order to your home for dinner, or a casual lunch while you're visiting beach haven.

Always great pizza

BUT _ you need to get after the borough to fix the potholes. I stepped off the curb into what looked like a shallow puddle and stepped into a fairly deep pothole. That caused me to take a nasty header and getting road rash on my hand

Again, that is no fault of Bay Village Pizza, but maybe you can wake the borough up to fix those potholes

There are some decent pizza joints (Slice of Heaven, The Shack) But If you want best of the best (on the island), Bay Village Pizza is the place. No other pizza shop on LBI compares.

Note: To me, Individual slices are a little better than if you get the pie

Family favorite when we visit LBI; never disappoints. The flavor is great, crust is on point, cheese is great, and it's not disgustingly greasy. Top tier pizza for a beach day.

Great pizza, great food, a little pricey but worth it.

Best pizza on the island! The pay per slice is HUGE! It's nice to sit outside and people watch. It is a one stop shop, play, eat, relax, place for sure. Bring your sweet tooth, there is a great bakery, fudge, and candy shop nearby!

Best pizza!!! Have been going there since I was a kid 😁

Can only comment on the fries - they are delicious and worth the wait!

Best pizza on the Island. #lbi

Best pizza on the island! So flavorful. Great thin chewy crust. And definitely don't pass on the fries. They're addicting