Goodie Shoppe

Stopped in on a whim. Needed a birthday cake and wanted to avoid busy supermarket. The service was prompt, friendly and helpful. Got a scone and coffee which were also great. But the birthday cake was to die for.
A white cake with lemon filling and coconut frosting absolutely delicious and enjoyed by all. Nice selection. Highly recommended.

We attended my Aunty Barbara Westlake's funeral. We had one of your Westlake special cakes at the celebration. It's going to be on my list of all-time favorite cakes! Thank you so much for being a part of our celebration of life for my Aunty. Mary Ellen is my cousin's wife ... So she is my cousin too 😍

We got a cake for our wedding and have not stopped hearing about it. Following tradition we froze a piece for our first anniversary and it was still worth raving about. Definitely getting cakes from here in the future

Amazing little shop! I stopped by on a whim and bought half a dozen spritz and lace cookies. The person managing the shop was lovely and recommended her favorite options, and they were all delicious. I can't wait to come back and try more.

Plus, the plants in the garden box out front are gorgeous!

This shop is absolutely the cutest place. I was told about it by some colleagues as we just moved to the area and it stood up to the high praise. I love bakeries and this one is one of my new favorites. The cake had a wonderful flavor, the cream puff was delicious, and the breads are crusty and perfect. Will absolutely be visiting this bakery more often than I should.

Friendly bakery with pizza too.Purchased an excellent rye bread too.

Great place! Everything fresh and tasty! I enjoy the seeded Italian bread and their pizza which is avail at noon! Nice, friendly people

Edit: The below is still true, even during lockdown!

Original: I honestly will occasionally drive over an hour to grab me a slice of that raspberry crumb cake. It is unbelievable.

They have what I call a "Black Forest Cupcake" that is simply delectable!!! My husband gets one for me every week
😊😊 It's truly an absolute pleasure!
Along with the cupcake we get a variety of cookies.
Service is always friendly.
I HIGHLY recommend The Goodie Shoppe.

The Goodie Shoppe is fantastic! My Dad goes there every day.When we come down from Waterloo NY we meet him there for baked goods , coffee,pizza on Saturday. Great place!

The seeded rye bread is a staple for me. It is sooo good, and everyone that I have spoken to that has had it resoundingly agrees!

The bagels are unquestionably a cut WAY above the rest available in the area (and I speak from experience as I've tried them all...). My personal favorite are the poppy seed, and if you were to compare them to others you could honestly say "That's not a poppy seed bagel, THIS is a poppy seed bagel!" ;o) To my taste they're so good that I won't even consider getting one from anywhere else...

I'm not much of a sweets eater, so I cannot comment on that...

By far the best pizza in the area too! (Supplies limited, so come at noon if you want to get a slice...;o)

The owner/baker is a refreshingly down to earth guy, as are the staff and regular customers too, which is unfortunately increasing rare these days, so that makes for a very nice atmosphere as well.

This will sound petty, but their poppy seed rolls are the best I've ever had. Light, with just the right crunch, they are perfect, always. Any baker will tell you this is difficult to achieve, because of variations in humidity and barometric pressure. The owner achieves this, always.

ok..my cardiologist isn't happy with me consuming marks product , but he doesn't know!! my taste buds are sooooooo very happy...consistently an amazing baked good or specialty item...and you must talk w/ mark....he is the force behind the spectacular products...coffees, pizza, bagels, pastries, cookies and the most amazing breads!! he knows his way around a bakery...!!...

i think i may just have to run over there this weekend!!..keep up the incredible work and i will see you soon!!

Great place to get all your pastries and bread. Excellent Pizza and bagel's too👍

Bread is FAB! Limited Pizza just before noon! Goes FAST!
GREAT COFFEE!!!

Great coffee and tasty baked goods. Always get a nice greeting from Joann at the counter. A wonderful place to hangout with other veterans and friends.

Yumyum gimme some.
Goodie Shoppe is a classic bakery w outta this world muffins and Bronx bread. Wowza.

Everytime I go in this store, there are always people at the tables chatting, which I love to see. The bakery offers delicious breads, bagels, muffins, cookies, pastries and I forgot pies!!

My favorite place! I got a cake for a friend's birthday party. The cakes are wonderful . The bagels are the best I've ever had.

I’ve never had a bad experience there. They make the best cakes ever. They are very accommodating. Super happy with them.