Luigi's Pizzeria

Unique briar-hill type homemade pizza is a staple and legend of Hermitage. It's been around as long as I remember, and hasn't changed. They only accept cash, so be careful about that. The pizza here never seems to disappoint

Now this is old school pizza!!!! It tasted like Angela T's pizza from Sharpsville back in the day.Staff was polite, crust was perfect, crisp with a little pull. Ratio of toppings was exactly right. This was our first time here but we will definitely be back.

I’ve eaten pizza all over this continent and this is some of the best. Appears to be a family run business. The dough is a bit crispy with ample amount of chew. The sauce is neither sweet, nor acidic, but flavorful nonetheless. The toppings are adequate and of good quality. Order was ready in 20 minutes on a Friday night.

A unique pizza place that is only takeout, their default pizza size is a 6 cut, and every pizza also comes with diced green peppers unless you say otherwise while ordering. They are a non credit/debit establishment so cash is the best medium here. But the flavor of the pizza is amazing, the quality is always spot on, and the crust really does bring it all home!

This place and scottos are the only pizza worth trying in 50 mile Radius

Diane and staff never disappoint. Their pizza rocks! There is a reason they have been around for so many years! Consistently delicious!

Easily the most expensive pizza around here (by the square inch), but ABSOLUTELY the best. East Coast Transplants rejoice. It may not be quite like home but this place is damned good. There's cheaper pizza on every block, but it just isn't worth it if you care about what you're eating - it's Luigi's or nothing.

Amazing as Always $11 each great price. Cash only please 😆

One of the best pizza places in Mercer County and that's saying something as there are numerous good pizza options.

Delicious pizza, great service. Best in the area! Fresh ground blended cheese, homemade dough made daily, awesome crust, delicious sauce. The sausage is the real deal. Soooooo good! Reasonably priced. Would definitely recommend.

I've had pizza all over the country and the four corners of the world, and I''ve never had as good a pizza as what you get here. An utterly amazing slice, and made with assembly line consistency. I couldn't recommend enough.

This is the best place in Hermitage for pizza!

This is the best pizza I've ever had. It's by far my favorite pizzeria of just about anywhere. I understand Jeff Benders frustration in his review, but Luigi's is open from 4-9 with a set amount of pizza dough for the night and when the run out they are done which is usually between 8:15 - 8:45.

BEST pizza in the valley - NO competition. (and by far my favorite pizza on the planet) The sauce contains green peppers- and the toppings are "REAL". For example: sausage- large pieces of seasoned sausage, as opposed to those strange little pebbles found on every other pizza in the area. Ordering is simple: They only sell ONE size, a medium-round. Price is reasonable, especially when compared to chains like Pizza Hut. My sole complaint is they're CASH ONLY.
If you're looking for a delicious pizza in the valley, you can't go wrong with Luigis- just make sure you hit up an ATM beforehand.

Best pizza in the area, GREAT prices, friendly staff

One of the oldest pizzerias in the area and it's easy to see why. Absolutely delicious! Easily my top pick when it comes to pizza!

I remember this pizza shop when I was a teenager and lived back in Hermitage and I still love it to this day when I ever get back there

Absolutely the best pizza I've had in years.

Their pizza is a fat guys paradise however wish the hours would be normal like 12-8:30.....

Been getting pizza at Luigi's for 40 years. Best pies I've had anywhere. Sausage is excellent (not that crumbled processed junk)