Tony's Restaurant & Pizzeria

Great wings. Loved the homemade tasting pizza sauce. Little slow getting food. Kitchen loud and rude. But the waitress was amazing. Over an hour for dine in 2 out of 3 times, so far. Pizza was so amazing but I don't see putting canned mushrooms on a pizza that taste so good.

We just moved to the area and we had a craving for pizza. So we randomly chose this place that was closest to us. We went to their website and it said if we ordered from the "Slice" app, we'd get 5% off the order. Hey; every dollar counts these days.
The online ordering process was very simple and there's a spot for notes on each item. You'd be surprised how often that's an issue with other places. My wife and I are lactose intolerant, but no place in the area has a vegan cheese option. So we usually order pizza with no cheese. This time, we ordered a 12" personal pizza with "light cheese" and decided to just take pills. You can't really taste how good or bad a pizza is going to be if you only taste them modified.
I ordered for pickup and got there exactly when the app said it would be ready. The girl at the counter was friendly and thorough. She put my social anxiety at ease right away by taking the reigns and walking through everything. "Here's your pizza." "Let me get the rest of your order." "This is what's in the bag." It's little things like this that make or break a situation when it comes to social anxiety and dealing with what to do if something is wrong or missing. She was great and I trusted that everything was in order. Thank you.
The pizza was great. The sauce has a really good flavor, the "light cheese" was perfectly "light", and the toppings were well spaced and plentiful. The crust was standout. (It also passed the cold pizza test in the morning.)
We also ordered garlic knots, falafel, fries, and zeppoles. The garlic knots were really good, the falafel was well cooked, the fries were crunchy and well seasoned, and there were so many fluffy zeppoles that had just thebright amount of powdered sugar. We'll definitely be ordering again.
If I had one suggestion, it would be to add a vegan cheese option, like Violife, to the menu. No one else does it, and there's a vegan and lactose intolerant population in town that would spread the word. It would definitely make this place stand out a little more.

Pizza was great, it’s always nice to get away from the chain pizzas out there. But I’ll give the place 5 stars just because of their signed picture with Gooden, Strawberry, and Tyson. So cool.

Omg I haven't had a gyro in such a long time when I tell you it was the best I've tasted in this whole area. Just the right amount of everything I will be back.

Mon Tues wed specials are incredible and for the specials price.... food is amazing, and portions are huge! Service is always quick, food is always hot.

Working near Tonys on Crystal street I stopped bye for their Chicken Parm with Vodka Sauce, the hoggie was excellent, flavorfull, delightfull, beyond words, I took the other half home for my wife to try and she was so complimentary….and thankful….. Feeling hungry … go to Tony’s .

Order at counter. Waitress delivered, but not very pleasant.
Puzza, cheese, mushrooms and pepperoni, was delicious! Would recommend 👌.

Anyone who says this isn't the best pizza they have ever had is just flat out lieing to you. This is by far the best pizza I have ever had! The quality of the ingredients is outstanding, the hospitality amazing and the perfect place to go! I came all the way from Michigan to come here to eat their food and will continue to do so. If your in town, do not miss the opportunity to stop in! You won't regret it 👍👍👍

Moved into the Stroudsburg area a few months ago and tried several pizza places in the area and Tony’s was by far the best. I ordered a medium mushroom/broccoli pizza well done and couldn’t have been more satisfied! I’ll happily take the 5 min drive to Tony’s over a 2 min walk to other spots.

They've always had great pizza and service. I've been going here for the past several years and it's definitely one of the best pizza joints around

If you want to get great tasting italian food for take out and quick, Tony's is fantastic...

pretty nice place to grab a slice. Friendly staff. The pizza taste good.

Had a great experience from the quality of the pizza from the customer service Taylor is amazing very attentive this place transport you to New York taste and atmosphere Love it we will definitely come again

Love their meatballs. Pizza is so good. Only downfall I see is they have no ice machine. The deco is fun to look at and reminisce

The pizza was amazing. True New York style. I haven't had a better pizza! Highly recommend!

After ordering from Tony's 3 times already since they opened. Let me just say it's absolutely AMAZING! tonight we ordered the chicken parm ans chicken vodka. OH MY GOODNESS! the vodka sauce was so creamy and literally perfection! We've ordered pizza before and it was like New York Pizza.
You need a "go-to" place, Tony's is it!
Will DEFINITELY be ordering from Tony's again and again!!!! Keep up the amazing work y'all!!!

Best meat lover's pizza in the area and amazing French fries. Service was great and staff was friendly.

Love them buy from them frequently. Looooo their funnel cake fries.

Pizza is awesome and service is even better!Young lady at the front desk is awesome!Always super polite every time I come in!Asked her to lightly heat up pizza for my 2 year old and she even cut it in tiny pieces for him!Brung our food to the table and even brung over a cup a straw for my little ones drink!really went above and beyond!

The wings are very crispy and the sweet chili sauce is very flavorful. Loved the wings! The pizza was OK - crunchy crust and sogging bottom - but lots of toppings.