Holtwood Supply

This spot is like the old SS store but your Amish buddy owns it. Great place for propane they just went up to 2 but still cheapest in 100 miles you can find anything from fence, gates, wire your place. Get a cold drink and a snack. Fair honest people with great prices just about anything you need

Convenient and local, they always have the small household hardware I need as well as a few more bonuses. Always good pricing and help when I’m looking for something.

Always extremely nice. Well stocked store for ALL your needs!

This is my favorite store for materials needed for any of my projects . Best place for hardware supplies and some bolts, washers,nuts ect. are sold by the pound saving you alot of money .If you have a large deck or construction project to build then this is the place to shop. Nice people to deal with!!

Screen door service. Everything farm related. Diy home projects such as plumbing etc.. available for purchase.

This place has everything. I’ve bought everything here from tools to railroad ties to lumber to pipes to grass seed.

Staff is friendly and helpful.

Also, they do accept credit card unlike some of the reviews say.

I appreciated that the cashier discouraged me from purchasing something because it would not be very effective. They lost a sale at that moment but have gained a long-term customer. They have a great variety of hardware to select from. It is fun just to stroll the aisles and look. You may just find solutions to problems like I have.

Quick service and wide availability of choices to pick from. They don't accept credit cards (amish owned), only cash or checks. Business hours vary slightly with the seasons (gets darker earlier in the fall; they don't use electricity here). Great competitive prices on propane and wood pellets

I could give these guys one star and they would never know they're Amish🤣 ..If you need hardware they have it

I've only been here a couple times since we've been down to the campground but the owners are always more than happy to help with any questions I have. Prices are more than reasonable and that's usually where I go to get my propane tanks filled up at a very reasonable price always call ahead of time to see what hours they are there and by the way they are closed on Sundays.

Great country hardware store. Very knowledgeable and friendly folks. They had exactly what we needed when camping nearby to fix our emergent issue before it became a disaster. I'm very glad I found this place.

Many things you wouldn't be able to find in your regular building supply stores. Plus help as soon as you ask.
ALWAYS BEST TO SUPPORT our own smaller stores first.
Plus the benefits of a smile and a greeting are priceless!!!!

Best place to find anything you need from livestock supplies to home improvement

Good place close to home to find what you need. They have a nice supply and fair prices.

Great amish owned store! Very friendly people! Variety of things from hardware to shoes to farming and animal products. Somethings are little over priced but a lot of it is great prices!

Great local hardware store that all carries a huge selection of fence supplies, pipe and everything in between. Prices are lower then Tractor Supply by a lot and the selection is superior in every way!

Holtwood Supply is always a first choice for us before going to the bigger home improvement stores. Prices are always fair and the people are always helpful and knowledgeable.

A good general supply store in Holtwood area. Many items for farm, home, & construction industry. Nice folks to deal with. Near Muddy Run Campground.

These people are fantastic. They know their stuff, very informative, and very kind good employees like Mary Fisher. A great place to go

Very clean and organized. Helpful and friendly. Good quality name brand products at below box store prices. I will be goimg back!