Brothers Pizza of Lamar

We came here late on a Friday night. Weren't many people at all. Food was AMAZING. Garlic bread was the best I've had in a long time, really soft bread, yet crisp. Salad was good aswell. And the chicken parm was awesome. Would definitely recommend

As I pulled in I noticed it was a family restaurant. I didn't know what to order but ask for a menu. I seen on the menu they have calzone so I got a small regular and a regular drink. I notice a small child I ask if he was working and he pointed at his sister no she is which made me laugh 😂. He was just there in the midst of it all. The calzone was very delicious and cheesy. Just the way it should be prepared. The food was not overpriced and the service was great. Anyone from out of town should check this place out and enjoy a great lunch at brother's pizza. Let them know you seen my review.

Roadtrip from Boston to Chicago, searching for a good dinner place as traditional fast food wasn’t appetizing. Looked up places near the area we were passing by and Brothers Pizza of Lamar came up. Reviews were great & took the chance. SOOO GLAD WE DID!! Ordered sausage pizza and order of cheese fries. Some of the best NY style pizza I’ve had. Sauce - homemade, fresh and flavorful but not overwhelming. Crust- not thick nor thin, perfect chewiness with a good bite and crisp on the edges. Fries were heavenly… crispy outside with tender/mash potato inside. Received some garlic knots— pillowy soft and freshly made. Staff was super friendly, homey vibe made us feel comfortable while eating. Will be our must-go stop on our next road trip to NE. Thank you for a great meal and awesome experience.

Classic new York style slices, I'd recommend the pepperoni over plain.

This place rocks!! Superb cheesesteaks and slices. Fresh. Their staff is very friendly, the brothers know pizza! 5/5! Best in the garden cosmo’d cheesesteak I’ve had in quite some time.

My husband and I drive in a semi truck, so stopping for anything other than fast food is a treat. This pizza, is some of the best I've had outside NY. The crust is thin, but holds it's own, there is so much delicious garlic. I ate almost the whole thing in one sitting and was sad I couldn't eat more. I am already praying that we will pass by here again.

A group of us came in, the young man Owen is a wonderful waiter in training. All of our food was very good, as fresh as it can be, we got a few things on the house which was very kind. Very, very please with our visit here.

Well, OK, 5 is a bit much - however, the lasagna was really good, the service was friendly, the atmosphere was fine inside and they have a nice outdoor seating area. There's a great big parking lot and even the customers were super friendly. This gets a 5 star bc I appreciate hard-working people, and they provide a service that many take for granted. Running a food service business is not easy! We were visiting from out of town and it's a beautiful land cared for by real people.

This business is very good. Me and my family just got their pizza, and they were very polite and generous by giving us a free thing of Cinnabon bites. I strongly recommend this place to others.

My son ordered over phone for me to pick up.. he said the young boy there wasn't very nice on the phone but I been going there for years and love there food

Delicious, local eatery with an extensive menu. We ate the broccoli and chicken, chicken fettuccini Alfredo and veal parmigiana. Dinner portions are large—enough for lighter eaters to split. Service is friendly and restaurant is clean and cool. I highly recommend.

My fiancé and I were traveling for work and had been on the road for 10 hrs already. Starving and looking for anything other than fast food, I found this place and it was so good! We got a medium pepperoni pizza and the bacon/cheese breadsticks. It was hot and ready to go when we got there. Everything was cooked perfectly. My fiancé said the young man at the register was so friendly. 10/10 experience.

I called in my order and received a call back minutes later with questions to make sure they got it correct. I have gotten a grilled chicken salad at 5 different Brothers pizza in the past 2 months, and this was one of the best (possibly the absolute best). I will be stopping here more frequently.

I frequently travel by car from the Midwest to New England and this place, Brothers Pizza, is the reason I stop in Lamar for the night every time. I've had only their eggplant Parm, but because it is so good, I've never deviated from it. If the rest of their food is even half as good as the eggplant, go there. It's that good.

This place is amazing my husband and I are over the road truck drivers we broke down in this little town called Lamar,PA we r staying at a hotel here in town and the clerk up front told us about this place. We ordered dinner it was almost $70 but we ordered a lot of food. The lady comes to deliver our food and for some reason our card would not work she tried 3 different ways(and there is plenty of money in the bank) any way she just told me she'd take care of it not to worry about it. And thank thanks us for what we do everyday driving trump!! What an amazing place and amazing people!! Thank u so very much😊

Everything from the food to the staff is absolutely wonderful!!

Wow! What an incredible, authentic and delicious pizza place. My wife and are at a nearby hotel and decided to drop by. We were greeted very warmly and liked the cozy, mom-n-pop atmosphere. We got pizza, wings, garlic bread and a salad. I'm not exaggerating when I say that we were blown away by how amazing everything tasted. The pizza was perfectly cooked and the wings were seasoned nicely and came with a sweet bbq sauce. The girls even gave us some cinnamon bites for free! 10/10 would recommend to anyone looking for a great place, serving generous portions of delicious food. Thanks Mami!

This place is amazingly good best chicken parm dinner I've had in a long time and I go all over as a truck driver. Thanks guys

This is a dinner stop on our way to Penn State basketball games. We have always had a wonderful dining experience, with plenty of menu items to choose from. The pre-meal garlic knots are the best!

My partner and I stopped by Brothers Pizza while driving from northeast to midwest. We found it from a random google search of food nearby and we're so lucky we did. The pizza was SO DELICIOUS! We initially were just going to order slices, but wanted to try their specialty pizzas so ended up with a half and half medium pizza. As a lifelong NYer, I'm still thinking about this pizza many days later. It was AMAZING. The cannolis were so delicious too :)