Prospect Pizza

Our first visit was awesome! 🍕 Interesting to read mixed reviews after having the best pizza in the area. Everything about this place, from the friendly service, fresh tasting pizza and cute outdoor seating area was a positive experience. Loved the cornmeal sprinkled crispy crust with a delicious chewy center. Perfect amount of sauce and cheese. Pepperoni and mushroom toppings were plentiful. Happy we did not read reviews before ordering or we would have missed out on a great pizza experience.❤🧡💛

Great place to eat and get a car wash while you wait for your order. Ran by great people.

Love the pizza! Homemade ranch too! The buffalo chicken rolls are also great! 10/10 would recommend

We’ve been ordering pizza here for years! We love the food & crew is friendly and treats you like FAMILY! Food is so good! Love the pizza! The crust is the best part… tender with that’s crusty edge!!
And if you’ve never had a Mac daddy, that’s where you should start Mac daddy pizzas are amazing!!

Great people. Excellent 🍕 pizza.
Like Goin back home !

I love supporting small businesses, and this place ranks high in all categories! The menu provides a wide variety of pizzas, from cheese to pickle to supreme and everything in between. The service is awesome!

prospect pizza will always have the vote as my #1 favorite! I recommend them to everyone!! I've never been disappointed with anything from these guys!! Always excellent/friendly service as well!

Best pizza around!! Love the Reich family and their support of our community! Support small, great quality food.

Prospect Pizza is the best pizza around! Not to mention the owners and employees are great! Highly recommended! Try it for yourself if you haven’t yet! You’re missing out!

This place was good and cost was no different than the garbage pizza chains. Thoroughly satisfied by this small business and will continue to only give money to small businesses in the area. Note to owners: try to source your goods locally and advertise locally sourced ingredients. At the end of the day pizza is pizza and this pizza was tasty. Note to customers: it's a small business that hires local, typically young people give them a break.

Best pizza around butler made with great products

Small family restaurant in my hometown that my family has ordered from for years. Good food, polite workers and just down to earth good people. Thank you for many years of service.

Some of the best pizza around. Let me correct that some of the best food around. Love the bacon cheddar fries and love the hoagies!

Always excellent pizza. The owners serve pizza and the community. Helping where and when they can. I cannot recommend highly enough.

The best pizza in Butler! Top quality ingredients. Definitely not your average chain store. Christian based business which we need more of. Fast friendly service. Blessing to this business!

Awesome food made from awesome people! I love supporting our hometown pizza place!

It's a great pizza and calazone shop ! The food is spectacular and the service is too.

I've been going here for years, food, excellent, people, excellent, owner, excellent. Only problem I can't eat it every day. Getting fat! Enjoy !!!

The pizza here is the best in the region! If you haven't tried the Prospect pizza you are missing out!

Cant get enough. Great small pizza shop. I am currently loving the Buffalo chicken salad. Their Sicilian is great. Its not the valley square pizza but it is thick and delicious (all the cheese is melted). The Dylan fries are excellent as well. If you like garlic parmesan then you will go crazy over these French fries.