Toni's 24 Hour Restaurant

Love Toni's. It is a charming unique restaurant full of locals who love it and a staff who care about making solid comfort food. You order at the counter, from the extensive menu on the wall, and then sit wherever you want in the many different comfortable spots. The atmosphere is so inviting, everyone seems to know each and yet, many included us in their conversations. On top of the "you are already family" feel, the food was outstanding too. Lots of typical diner food choices to pick from and breakfast all day. The milkshakes are all the rave and live up to the hype. I tried the "chicken pot pie soup" and it was literally like having gramma's chicken pot pie in a bowl. Delicious. The cheese loaded tater tots, suggested by a local, were perfectly crispy while also covered in warm real cheese. How they achieved this without soggy tater tots is surely magic. The turkey club was massive and the rye bread delicious. The homemade pies and gorgeous baked-goods are super tempting beckoning from their attractive displays. The service was prompt and friendly. Definitely glad we stopped at Toni's and discovered this gem of a local restaurant.

The food is worth the wait. We ordered the combo fish platter and BLAT with Garlic fries. All of it was delicious. The sticky bun was also very good.

This place a must stop if you're taking the Pacific highway. Price wise it's on the higher side but quality is worth it. Their daily specials are worth a look. Baked goods go crazy!

If you are in Arcata this is the place to eat. They have a full service restaurant, bakery, coffees and teas. They even have sweet potato fries with Thai peanut sauce a culinary favorite. Its right off 101 easy off easy on. Its an extensive menu so get what you're in the mood for. Enjoy

Great homemade burgers and fries and amazing milk shakes! The pastries and pies are absolutely delicious and fresh. This is not fast food, so it might be a little wait, but worth it. Try it out!

Loved this locals place. We were staying at a nearby hotel and are glad we picked this place to grab a bite. We got the fish basket and country burger. The basket had a ton of food and the burger was juicy and had great flavor. We added a couple of slices of homemade apple and cherry pie for dessert. We wish we lived nearby to come back again and again!

I really look forward to coming here! The menu is huge! Everything that I've ordered has been perfect. After I've had lunch, or breakfast, I can buy a few items from the bakery to take home with me.
I recommend coming here anytime that you're in Arcata!

Went for a late breakfast on Sunday, they had a lot of business. Everyone was friendly and smiling. They kept the coffee cups full. A little slow on bringing the food out but they were busy and the food was definitely worth the wait.

Toni’s is a gem. I’ve enjoyed coming here since I was a child and now take my kids here. The cold case recently has been looking so stupendous! Cheers

This was the first breakfast spot we came across as we headed towards McKinleyville. We stopped for a bite before spending the rest of the day exploring the redwoods. As soon as you walk through the door, you see fresh pastries and the complete menu so you can place your order before finding your table. The food was hot and ready very quickly. The staff was kind and courteous. They did an excellent job checking in on us and refilling our drinks. There’s a good portion of food here so you will be sure to dill up before a big day!

Like it says!! Open 24/hr!! The selection of food is very good as well as the baked goods!!! Pies and bread pudding look like they're made from scratch!!! So many delicious looking goodies!!! I'm sure the kids that come it just drool over the available pastries!!

The food is delicious, so many choices, if you leave hungry that's on you. They make pies fresh daily I had the rhubarb and strawberry pie a la mode and it was amazing.

Really love Toni's and try to always visit at least once when I'm in town. Always there for you when you got those late night munchies. Usually go for a double or triple bacon cheeseburger w a side of onion rings. I crave those onion rings all the way from the east coast.

Milkshakes are always great as well.

Been going there for 10 years every time we drive through town!!! Great burgers. Their pies are pretty good to. Best breakfast for Miles!

It's a guilty pleasure but I love the food here. Diner food done right. Staff is great but lots of Trumpy in your face dimwits kinda offset the otherwise killer vibe. Maybe tampons in their ears will mellow them out?

SUPERB PLACE for quick yet great food!
Anytime I'm near Eureka I HAVE TO STOP HERE and I've not had all they offer!
Food is always freshly prepared in minimal time to delightful tasting!
I LOVE MALTS & these are top notch.
Today I had BACON BLUE BURGER which likely is a repeat as it is fantastic
ONION RINGS are really uniquely tops (see photo) and one order will serve at least two people so my wife gets to finish them when I get home!
The staff are very helpful, friendly & work very hard!
I've had breakfast, lunch & dinner here BUT SADLY I DO NOT travel here often enough... then again might be why I ONLY STOP here as much as I doubt possible if I lived here "could I tire" of it? With such a huge diverse menu I think may not be possible!
AND I STILL HAVE NOT YET TRIED ANY OF their great looking deserts! The meal with a side & malt is so filling I guess is one benefit my doctor is happy that I've not yet dived into desserts! Lol!
You GOTTA TRY THIS PLACE!

great spot for breakfast/brunch before heading out for some hikes. ordered a classic complete breakfast, and they were some of the best hashbrowns I've ever had. service was very friendly as well. we will be back in a bit for dessert!

Great food. Very nice counter help and servers. Generally large portions. Rustic atmosphere. Great pastries! A bit on the expensive side, but then isn't everything these days?

Really good. Greats milkshake, burgers, and fries. About $38 for 2x 1/2 burgers, small shakes (plenty) and a large fry. Really great price.

Toni's 24 hour restaurant is a great place to eat, any time of the day. The restaurant is clean and updated inside. I wasn't expecting much from a 24 hour place, but Toni's delivers on the food. They have an extensive menu offering breakfast, lunch, dinner, shakes, and a large bakery display, full of muffins, pies, cakes and scones. Table service is limited, they bring your food, and top off water/coffee. Food is usually pretty quick to arrive.