Jay's Pizza

This is the second time I’ve ordered from Jay’s. The first time, I called in the order for pick up. I was given a super short wait time, and my interaction at the store took all of 2 minutes from when I was greeted to when I had the pizza in my hands. The second time, I found out they delivered to my address, so I took that route. Again, the wait time was tolerable, even with hunger making every minute drag on. Both times I got a 24 cut, 1/2 ham 1/2 meatball. I would say Jay’s is definitely in my top 10 for good pizza. The dough is the perfect thickness, the sauce is flavorful, and the cheese is the perfect amount of stringiness. It even reheats up nicely the next day, which is a big win for me. The garlic knots are drowned in butter, which was a little too much for me, but past that they were delicious.

This places pizza is INCREDIBLE not to thick but also not to to thin & their ranch has to be homemade it’s amazing witch makes me order from there even more!!

My husband picked up take out, med ham & mushroom pizza, hot wings (crispy) stuffed shells cordon Bleu bites & salad. This was our first experience with Jays Pizza & we will DEFINITELY be back! Everything was fantastic, the hot wings were the best wings we've had in a very long time!! Now I know why we always see this establishment busy. Thank you Jay's, we will certainly be back!! 🥰🥰

Love this thin crust, NY city style pizza. They have the bake right, the crust usually is just hot and almost crisp on the bottom, with a great chew, while the sauce and toppings do their job. Leftovers, if any, heat well in the toaster oven to crisp the bottom, or in the microwave for a good chew.

Ordered a large pizza tonight with sausage pepper onion and banana peppers. Pizza was awesome. Driver that delivered was excellent. And super prompt. Extremely good job. Thank you. From Dan Currier

My life was saved by their boneless Buffalo wings. Blew my darn socks off. Delivery man couldn’t have been nicer. We also forgot to add something and they made it happen bb. 🙏 cool with horses.

First time ordering here as I pet sit and sometimes order in when I’m at clients houses. Fast service and really good food, wings were perfect and pizza is pretty great too. My delivery driver was wonderful. I’ll be ordering from here again.

The mild wings are hands down the best wings I've ever had. Pizza is great, garlic knots are good. We order every Friday and it never disappoints.

Great that Jay is back. Fantastic thin crust with a sauce that complements the toppings. A hardy antipasto salad.

Looking for a quick lunch around Greenwich, NY? Stop in at Jay's Pizza. I recently stopped in here for the first time to have lunch with my sister and was quite pleased. After ordering a large American Mix Sub we sat down at one of their tables. My sandwich was ready in just a few minutes and the man behind the counter brought it right to the table on a plate. Excellent service. This sub was delicious and humongous. I grabbed a couple of the fried green beans my sister had ordered as well and they were also quite tasty.

Was in the area for work and stopped in. By far the best Buffalo chicken pizza I have ever had. They even have their own blue cheese which, is delicious 😋
Thank you for the Slice 🍕

Pizza orders always ready in 20 min, REALLY good sausage (made in house maybe?) and a perfect amount of pizza sauce every time. We love Jay's!

We ordered 2 large pizzas one cheese and one ham and bacon and a side order if garlic knots. Very happy with the order, pizza was delicious and so were thr knots. Definitely will be back for my pizza needs!

For a small place in upstate NY, this is some of the best pizza I’ve had ANYWHERE. We had their wings too, perfectly crispy and sauced. Highly recommend! Plenty of parking, modern interior and an absolute hidden gem!

It's always hot, fresh and ready to go when they say it will be. Using their website to order is so convenient!

We are from Virginia and will drive back for the pizza!
Everything on the menu was delicious and we tried five different dishes. Great service, pleasant experience all thanks!!!!!

The blue cheese and wings are one of my favorites

Stopped in here after getting a new car up the road. The burger was so much better than I thought a pizzeria burger WOULD be. Tasted so good I even put in an extra order so my fiance could try. Would absolutely come back again.

One of the best NYC style pizza places around this area. Picked up a nice pepperoni pie. The crust was a flavorful canvas for the flavorful sauce, which wasn't overloaded, the savory cheese which wasn't too salty and the pepperoni which was perfectly crispy. The pepperoni had started to cup and crisp up on the edges and was the best version of pepperoni on a pizza. Will return again for this glorious pie!

We really like Jay’s pizza. Most of the time the quality of the food is very good, sometimes it is a little over cooked... but it is always the best pizza in town.

I’ll still give 5 stars because employees come and go but, our only complaint is the young fella at the counter. Let’s just say he is NOT exactly a ray of sunshine. I get that working at a pizza shop might not be your dream job, but fake it. He always seems irritated and often has snotty/rude tone. AND it’s not like I caught him on a bad day. It is every time. He’s definitely not the type of guy you want as the face of your business.