Shtayburne Farm Creamery

Wow, we loved this place. The best cheese and ice cream in the same place? Flights to pick all the flavors you want? An idyllic tour of the grounds? Sounds too good to be true, but Shtayburne makes it happen.

We took the farm tour, which included cheese and ice cream tasting. Very nice owners and the farm staff are kind. The cheese and ice cream are very tasty. Highly recommended for families with young kids.

My husband and I enjoyed hearing about the raising of the cows and cheese and ice cream production. Then we had the “tasting” of cheese and ice cream which were exceptional. We will definitely be back!!

What a fun idea! My husband and I enjoyed this stop, it is a beautiful farm property with an amazing view. A small shop, order at the counter, choose from a variety of ice cream and cheeses. The house made cheddar was my favorite cheese and the peanut butter ice cream was amazing! Nice staff and fun to eat in the yard with kittens.

Delicious and refreshing! Such interesting flavors of ice cream- I got a flight so I could sample several! The cheeses are also quite delicious- the kids’ favorites were the pizza cheddar and the blueberry Monterey Jack. Loved the view as well!

Ice cream flights? Amazing. Cheese flights? Stupendous. The opportunity to mix & match the two?Such a unique experience! The shop offers some local goods and whatever you enjoyed you can buy a full pint (or block, for cheese) to-go. Good for the whole family.

Such a simple, wonderful place. A tiny storefront with provisions and a tasting menu- pick 4, 8, or 12 things to try (you can choose from homemade ice cream or cheeses) and they prepare everything on a tasting board. Affordable with generous portions. They have indoor seating and several options for outdoor seating. I enjoyed a picnic table under an umbrella with a cat who clearly loved cheese as much as I do. The shop had drinks, crackers, and other items to complement your tasting- they even had gluten free options! Highly recommend.

Some of the best cheese and ice cream I’ve ever had. Staff was also super friendly, and you can go pet the cows as well, which is always a win in my book. This is a great spot

Voted the most MEMORABLE stop on our tasting tour of the FLX by our group. This stop was recommended by our driver, and was absolutely awesome! "Flights" of cheese and ice cream??? Perfect stop to break up the adult tasting tour we were on. Everyone loved this place. Highly recommended!

My family and I had a fantastic time on the tour of Shtayburne Farms! Lorin was super informative, and everyone (toddler through grandparents) enjoyed meeting the cows and calves, learning about cheese making, and sampling the delicious cheese and ice cream. Many said it was the highlight of our week in the finger lakes!

We did the cheese and ice cream flight and my goodness! It was such a nice break from just wine. I wish we would have brought a cooler to take home some of the cheese because every single one we tried was amazing .

We were very intrigued by this place for their cheese and ice cream flight. Nice break up from visiting all the wineries nearby.

Delicious cheese and ice cream. I had a raspberry ice cream sandwich and it was so good. Also bought blueberry cheese, a must try! They have ice cream and cheese flights you can try. The view is beautiful if you sit outside.

AMAZING.
We had an ice cream and cheese flight. All of the cheese was delicious, they had some interesting flavours including chocolate covered quark which was great. The ice cream was some of the best we've ever had, and they had fun flavours too. Super creamy, flavourful, and fresh tasting. The kettle corn flavour is a masterpiece. We went back for seconds of it.

There's also sweet little farm cats roaming around, and a machine inside that dispenses treats for them! Shake the cup and they'll come running.

The cheese and ice cream flight is amazing; everything we tried was so tasty. Highly recommend the Peanut Butter explosion and the Berry Swirl.

I had the most wonderful experience. I learned quite a bit about how dairy farm operates. I even had a change to pet a baby calf. The ice cream and cheese tasting was great. Very fresh and flavorful and lot of variety to choose from. Everyone I encountered was friendly and professional. I highly recommend visiting and enjoying the treats this place offers."

We had a great time visiting Shtayburne Farm! It turns out the family is from the same area as us so it was cool to learn the connections! We did the tour for our friends Bachelorette party and it was awesome. Following the tour, we added on the cheese flight and then also purchased ice cream cones. The cheese portions were generous and the cheese was AMAZING! The ice cream was also soooo good! Throughout the rest of our trip we saw Shtayburne farm cheese at all of our favorite wineries. We all hope to go back.

So happy we stopped here for the cheese and ice cream flight on our vacation in the Fingerlakes. The flight was phenomenal, loved the cheese and ice cream was excellent. Our group consensus was that ice cream far surpassed another local, highly rated ice cream spot in the area. Would love to come back and check out the cheese making process next time. If you’re looking for really delicious ice cream this is the place!

Even on a rainy day this was a great stop. The flight of cheese and ice cream was delicious. The cheese curds were so good we bought two packs to bring to a friend in Buffalo, but we ate them haha.

LOVE this place! Such a nice view. We really enjoy the cheese and ice cream flights!

They have a great variety of cheeses available. Their ice creams are a very good assortment and rich flavors!