Good Ol' Wishy's

Nestled in the heart of Croghan, New York, Good Ol' Wishy's is a delightful throwback to the days of old-fashioned soda fountains and country stores. This charming establishment seamlessly combines the nostalgia of a bygone era with the comforts of a contemporary cafe, making it a unique and inviting destination for locals and visitors alike.

Upon arriving at Good Ol' Wishy's, the first thing that catches your eye is the comfortable seating area out front. Adorned with umbrellas for shade, it provides a welcoming spot to relax and soak in the small-town atmosphere. The rustic charm extends beyond the seating area, with the country store built into the restaurant. Here, patrons can peruse and purchase the best local honey and browse a selection of appealing apparel.

Venturing inside, we found ourselves greeted by the warmth of Good Ol' Wishy's interior. The spacious layout accommodates a variety of seating options, ensuring there's a perfect spot for everyone. The expansive table where we enjoyed our ice cream sundaes was a noteworthy highlight – it's not every day you come across such a generously sized communal space. Whether seated at the cafe bar or a table within the establishment, there's ample room to savor the experience.

The star of the show at Good Ol' Wishy's is undoubtedly the ice cream sundaes. Crafted with care and creativity, these indulgent treats delighted our taste buds. The cafe workers, who exuded a genuine friendliness, were instrumental in making our sundae selections an enjoyable process. Their helpfulness and eagerness to ensure our satisfaction added an extra layer of warmth to the dining experience.

The cafe's commitment to cleanliness and organization was evident throughout our visit. The spacious and spotless bathroom was a testament to their attention to detail. Every corner of Good Ol' Wishy's appeared thoughtfully arranged, contributing to a welcoming and comfortable ambiance. It's clear that the staff takes pride in maintaining a tidy and well-organized environment, enhancing the overall dining experience.

One cannot discuss Good Ol' Wishy's without acknowledging its dual identity as a soda fountain cafe and a country store. The integration of these two elements creates a unique synergy, allowing patrons to enjoy more than just a meal. The country store provides an opportunity to bring a piece of Croghan home, whether in the form of local honey or stylish apparel. It's a thoughtful touch that adds depth to the overall experience.

The cafe's commitment to showcasing and supporting local products is commendable. The availability of the best local honey not only enhances the menu but also contributes to the community's economic well-being. This emphasis on local sourcing adds an extra layer of authenticity to Good Ol' Wishy's, making it a culinary destination that goes beyond mere indulgence.

Good Ol' Wishy's strikes a harmonious balance between old-fashioned charm and contemporary appeal. The blend of comfortable seating, delectable sundaes, and a well-curated country store makes it a versatile establishment suitable for various occasions. Whether you're seeking a cozy spot to unwind with friends, a family-friendly venue for a sweet treat, or a place to explore local products, Good Ol' Wishy's has you covered.

In conclusion, Good Ol' Wishy's in Croghan, NY, is a gem of a restaurant that transports patrons to a simpler time while offering modern comforts. From the inviting front seating to the delightful ice cream sundaes and the well-stocked country store, every aspect of the establishment is thoughtfully designed to create a memorable and enjoyable experience. The friendly cafe workers, commitment to cleanliness, and emphasis on local products further elevate Good Ol' Wishy's, making it a must-visit destination for those seeking a taste of nostalgia in a quaint and welcoming setting.

The cuties store with older decorations. Now let me tell yall about the ice cream... you can get most flavors with lots and I mean lots of differently delicious flavors like deep sea to name one of many and u can get any flavor in a milkshake. The price was very good for the taste and charm of the place. Bonus if u need your bike repaired while u eat ice cream they do that too.
Lovely place. 20 out of 10 recommend

Best place in Lewis County for ice cream in my opinion. Over 40 flavors of hard ice cream, old fashioned floats, soft ice cream, and other treats! Plus just sitting at the ice cream/soda bar makes for a whole experience.

We took my 91 year old mom there for a old fashioned root beer icecream float it was excellent. It brought back memories of going to the icecream parlors in the 60's. Great look with the parlor stools. Girl that is served us was very nice.

Absolutely recommend Wishy's to everyone, young and old! If I lived closer, I'd be in there every day. Old school ice cream parlor with tons of vintage charm and delicious ice cream in every flavor you can imagine. Fair warning... the portions are HUGE. I MEAN HUGE! Very well priced and I was warned to get a small (I never get a small LOL) and even I couldn't finish it, it had to of been close to a quart of ice cream! The cannoli was out of this world and so was the coconut, 2 HUGE scoops in a small. Crazy delicious. Everyone working there was so nice as well! We go for ice cream alot, all over the place, and this is my far my favorite in NYS. 🥰

A classic ice cream parlor with bar stools and everything. I just wish this pandemic wasn't going on so I could walk around inside! Ice cream and service were great and the person was friendly and answered all my questions. I also appreciate that they asked everyone to wear masks, even though I was the only (aside from staff) wearing one. Will definitely visit again next time I'm in town.

This is a great place to visit! Good service and the ice cream is good.

Wishy’s is a staple in our summer experience every year! Wonderful old fashioned ice cream shop with many flavors, friendly service, and charm.

* bring cash
* servings are HUGE
* stay for checkers

Very good ice cream. Huge serving size

Large selection of ice creams. Start with a small to get a sense of the sizes are. Can't decide? Choose a flight sampler!

Great place, but you should be warned... After you stop here the first time, it's almost impossible to drive past without stopping again. Great selection, great ice cream, great service, and calming atmosphere...

Great icecream, cool old timey shop. Good prices.

This place is awesome. Huge portions. I'd give it a sixth star if they carried a no sugar added ice cream. They used to but don't anymore.

Love this place. Great little place to get your favorite ice cream. Has old ice cream parlor feel. Staff was very friendly.

A great place to stop on a summer day, whether you're driving through or on a bike ride along 812. It's a unique experience, with a large interior "bar" seating area. This place is a Croghan gem.

Great place, good ice cream. Lots of choices and a great old time feel.

Wishys has the best ice cream! We come every summer and always stop at wishys!

Ordered at a window outdoor , open for COVID 6/7/20. Cotton candy and blackberry cheesecake ice creams were great!

Wow, this place is fantastic! Worth stopping in every time you pass it. Loads of delicious ice cream and treats from a truly local stop.

Good ice cream and a very friendly staff