GELATOLICIOUS

This has easily become my favorite ice cream place in Columbus. Technically it's not ice cream, it's Gelato. They have an amazing chart explaining the difference.
The hazelnut chocolate is spectacular. The pure hazelnut is delicious. Caramel cookie, banana, buckeye, you name it, they nailed it. Everything I have had has been amazing.

Super friendly and accommodating staff, quick service, and old ice cream shoppe charm.

If you want a crazy good ice cream, go there.

My wife took me there and it was worth every $ spent. It's a bit pricey and taste amazing. If you like quality over quantity then try it out. Will definitely be back.

The BEST, most authentic, and delicious gelatos you can find in Ohio are right here in the Columbus area! They are made with love and the best ingredients. They are all absolutely fantastic! You must go and experience the true taste of Italy. Your life will be forever changed! I highly recommend these gelatos!

They have the best gelato I've ever had (even when I got to travel outside the US!). Owner and staff are super friendly, they have lots of flavors, and I finally figured out that they are open much later than the Pancake House. Highly recommend.

Hidden gem … I love gelato and this place hits the spot. They have some really good flavors that I wanted to try all of them. Service was great and patient.

We got the 3 flavor medium size for $6 : amaretto , blueberry , and mango. All so good and not all sugary. The gelato shop is connected to the pancake house . Just wished they were open late on summer days liz

Will soon come back .

Hidden gem for sure!! Delicious gelato, many flavors to choose from. I had Buckeye and loved it! Can get 2 flavors in a small which is nice. Staff was friendly.

Wow is that delicious! As good as we had in Italy. Very rich, we enjoyed the buckeye and banana caramel and will be back to try more. Thank you for leaving masking choice up to the customer!

Every flavor I've tried has been amazing. It's great that they let you sample the flavors, there are so many to choose from. We watched them making more while we were there. Excellent quality.

Delicious gelato! The employee who helped me was very considerate and answers any and all questions I had. Even got to sample some ❤

The person at the counter is so sweet! She was very kind and wonderful to us. The gelato of course is quite fantastic! Texture just right and plenty of fun flavors. The vanilla is VERY tasty if you like classic options. So worth it, there should be a line out the door

Whoa. Amazing handmade gelato and sorbet. We stopped in 20 minutes before closing but the owner took the time to describe each of the flavors offered and his story of how he learned to make gelato. It was fantastic -- the had pistachio and amaretto were to die for.

Delicious gelato. Employees are friendly and helpful. Their waffle cones are also fresh and tasty, and usually I am not a waffle cone fan.

Amazing place! Tried for the first time and absolutely loved it. The owner was very kind and the flavors are delicious

If you like to taste authentic Italian ice cream, this is the place to be. They make all their Gelato from very selected ingredients, most of them coming directly from Italy. Every flavor we tasted was just terrific.

Love their gelato...got the cappuccino to go.

Fantastic Gelato, would recommend to anyone. No alcohol in them either, which was surprising. Also the individual who makes them is Italian so it super authentic. What a great hidden gem!

Best gelato ever! And specially the service… the lady that was at the counter was just so sweet and nice!

Super friendly service and absolutely fantastic gelato! Found this place on Google Maps when searching for dessert places with good reviews. I'm glad I took a chance on it.

Jeni's and Graeter's are good, but Gelatolicious would be my first choice. Flavors are SO intense, they definitely do not skimp on ingredients.

If you’re in the area, GO HERE! The gelato is amazing and we have always had friendly service.