Andy's Pizza

Don't let the outside fool you. We passed this place by many times and now regret it as it's the freshest and best-tasting pizza!!

I had the lasagne and it had multiple layers of goodness and it's amazing! The portions are huge and my husband asked at least 3 times if his was a small pizza it was so big. I did steal a piece or two of his pizza and it had great flavors and the perfect crispy crust. So much so that driving home tonight I was thinking oh we should get pizza again. I got home and my husband says hey wanna get pizza again from Andy's tonight? So guess where we are headed.

I will update if tonight is just as impressive.

Okay update, we were running late and didn't want to roll in 30 mins before closing for dinner. So I picked up the Pizza to go. So I can't fairly rate our 2nd Pizza since I had a long drive home. Just means we need a 3rd Pizza. 😉

3rd pizza in a week, that's really embarrassing but it's so good. We did dine in and it was amazing! I wonder if they have frequent buyer discounts? 😆 this time we got a large supreme.

My local go to, great food for great prices. Always beyond satisfied, you get exactly what you expect to get, never disappointed. And it doesn’t cost $30 to feed 1 person!

Andy’s is great. Foods good and they have good delivery service. It’s a good pizza shop and the world needs more good pizza shops man. A lot of places just aren’t good and they do to much. Never been an issue with Andy’s.

Stopped for lunch while riding our bikes in the area. Pizza was phenomenal! Fresh ingredients, loaded with toppings, tasty dough and sauce. Will definitely recommend this place to my bike friends!
Also, our server was great, very friendly and helpful. TWO THUMBS UP !!!

I stopped in today at lunchtime. That was my first time ever being there and I ordered one slice of pizza. They made a whole pizza just for that one slice. And I have to say that was the best damn pizza I’ve had. I’ve had a lot of pizza and none of it comes close to that.

Andy and his family have had the best N.Y. style pizza in the area since I can remember them being at Brothers. I live in California now and miss having this pizza, and nothing out here comes close. The chef salad with house dressing is another one of my favorites, and you can't go wrong with the Andy's cut sub!

We drive from Sheperdstown to Charles town to get pizza for my grandson. It’s the only pizza he will eat other than Matchbox.

Awesome food!! Great service!! Will be back when we come back to West Virginia. Bread sticks are wonderful. Pizza delicious. Wings awesome. Fried mushrooms excellent! Double Cheeseburger amazing! Try it out won't be disappointed.

Had the White garlic pizza 😋 was very good.. definitely will come back again

I'm glad we tried Andy's. We're in town for a wedding and I did some Google searches to find good pepperoni rolls. All reviews led us here. The best. Hands down. The service was beyond anything I could have expected. The food, hands down, 5 stars.

We have tried all the pizza places around here. They are consistently great.

I absolutely love Andy's the food is great pizza is always cooked. chicken fingers are amazing and the prices are very reasonable for what you get. One of my favorite places to go when we don't feel like cooking on the weekend.

We've dined in and ordered pickup. The food is delicious and the staff has been nothing short of fantastic. Recently we had an issue with an order on a very busy night, called to express our concern, and our issue was handled promptly with top tier customer service. Top to bottom this is a fine establishment and in my opinion the best pizza in the area. Thank you and keep up the great work!

Great service, fast delivery, and the best cheese steak I have found in the area. The owner also supports the community, therefore we support him! The staff here is super friendly!

I'm a tough pizza critic, but Andy's Pizza makes the best tasting pizza you're going to eat anywhere -- period. Fermented dough? Who goes to that length anymore? Virtually no establishment, but Andy's does so and you can taste the difference. Their sauce is the best with just the right level. I asked for our pizza extra thin, they did so perfectly. It's hard to beat their quality. Best not only in WV, but at the national level.

OMG! This was my first time trying Andy's pizza, and it's the BEST I've had since moving here. It's identical to Giacomo's Pizza in Falls Church, from the mid 1970s to 1980s at Loemans Plaza.
The crust is what makes or breaks a pizza, and Andy's has it in spades!!
The sauce is exquisite... the toppings sublime... Ohhhh mannnn... they have a customer for life in our family!
They were so nice, as I called in a 2 pizza order 25 minutes before closing and no problem! Other places around here don't answer their phone 30 minutes before they close
I highly recommend!!

Great pizza, tastes way better than Dominos.

I have great service and the food is excellent. My family orders from Andy's at least one time a week.

Other ratings say that the crust is delicious and guess what, they are right! Really good!

Hands down best pizza around. Try it with extra sauce! Great service, friendly owner, somewhere you’ll want to go every week. We’ve liked everything we had on all our visits. This is our new go to and drive 30 mins because it’s worth it.