Park Street Pizza

Amazing food! They've really got it all figured out! We have a build your own pizza and Italian salads. They were both amazing! The sauce was amazing! The salad dressing was soooo good! The crispy peperoni on the salad was a great combo! Next time we're back in town we'll definitely be going back!

Oh my gosh we were blown away. The atmosphere and vibes were phenomenal, the margherita pizza with fresh pesto from first bite to crust were in my top 5 pizzas I have ever had. We got the Italian salad and it was so fresh and delicious with the dressing. We are talking about coming here when we visit next! Absolutely incredibly run place. Beautiful bathroom and decor with fresh green plants along counter by cashiers.

This is our second experience at Park Street Pizza and it was wonderful! We stayed in Berlin and checked in on a Sunday. We asked at our hotel recommendations for dinner. She gave us the name of a couple pizza places but highly recommended Park Street Pizza. She said it was a little more of a drive but definitely worth it. She couldn't have been more right! We had the Modern Margarita Pizza and the Primo Pepperoni one. They were delicious! My husband said it is the best pizza he had ever ate! We also tried the Italian salad .......absolutely delicious! I recommend the blackberry balsamic dressing!! We have been coming to amish country for years but only have been to Park Street Pizza twice. It is now a must on our list of places to eat while we are there!

This place is a gem!!! I was staying at a local hotel and ordered food for pick-up. When I discovered my license plate had been lost or stolen, I called the store to inform them I couldn’t pick up my order, and they so kindly offered to deliver it to my hotel. Outstanding customer service!!! And the food was delicious.

The pizza was really good . The staff were all very friendly , and the restaurant itself was very clean and tidy . Will definitely be back.

We ordered pizza online to go and it was exceptional!! Fresh ingredients and high quality!!!

We are are very seldom disappointed when choosing ParkStreet Pizza. Tonight we had Park Street salads and they are great!! The Calzone was really good too!!

Pizza was Phenomenal! very very happy with what we ordered.

We visited for the first time yesterday and we have to say we ate the best pizza that we probably ever had!! By far the best gluten free crust ever!! Thank you for the special handling of my food to make sure it was safe for me. My husband had the regular thicker crust pepperoni pizza and he loved it. Will definitely be coming back!

The first time here won't be the last. Has got to be the best pizza 🍕 around. I wish we had one near us. Friendly staff and clean inside. Had the Primo Pepperoni, outstanding, and also the boneless wings in smokey mustard were very good and plentiful. I can't wait to come back on our next visit.

Best business and place to eat. Whenever I come to visit Ohio(I'm from Niagara Falls NY) I always make an attempt to come to Park Street for their yummy food! This time I got to share the visit with my husband and kids. They loved it and keep talking about it. We all highly recommend. 😊❤

This place was so amazing! We came here cuz it was one of the only places open on Sunday. And it did not disappoint!! Everything was amazing! If you are in town definitely try it ! We got buffalo boneless wing and BBQ bone in wings . And the modern Margherita pizza. And let me tell you this is prob in my top 3 all time favorite pizzas I have ever had !!! Definitely will come here again when in the area.

Excellent pizza! Highly recommend. Wonderful staff and eco friendly. Vegan options too.

Best pizza I’ve ever had in Ohio!!! Fresh, hot and just so delicious. Service was warm and friendly!

These guys were a lifesaver for me! I'm at a work conference 10 minutes down the road and recently went plant based. The event I'm had only had salads as an option and it wasn't enough substance for me. I was able to build my own plant based pizza for pick-up and it was delicious! Most of the people looked at my pizza and thought it looked better than the other pizza they were eating. Thank you Park Street!

If you're in Sugarcreek, Park Street Pizza is a MUST. The southwest rolls are my favorite, and the park street bread sticks are also fantastic. They have gluten free and vegan options too, there's really something for everyone!

Pizza is always amazing. Boneless wings are spectacular! Their salads are always fresh and delicious. The last time we stopped in we had a group of 13. Even with such a large party the service was excellent. All the pizzas were hot. We will definitely be there again soon.

My wife and I absolutely loved this place. It's one of the best pizza places I've been to in a long time and it's different than anything else in the Ohio region area. The staff is definitely super cool and the interior looks very modern makes you feel like you're in a big city somewhere. Pizza itself is amazing!

First time being here - was a Friday evening and the place was busy but it seemed like each customer was treated with attention and care. The employees seemed to really enjoy working there and with each other. The food was amazing. We had the southwest rolls for appetizer and colossal Italian pizza. Absolutely amazing. The ingredients were all fresh. You need to get the “Chad cookie” for dessert! I started talking with one of the employees who treated each customer with such care and learned that when was the owners’ son. It is evident he and others take pride in their restaurant. This is a place that you feel good about spending your money and leave feeling good about what you ate and the experience.

Great pizza!
You may have to wait in line, but it will be worth it. The Rustic Chicken Pesto is an awesome pizza and Lucy is an awesome server!
10/10 want to do it again!