Mrs Yoders Kitchen

Amazing home cooked buffet. Tender pot roast, perfectly seasoned noodles, great service. And tempting desserts. Tables not crowded together. Can't be beat.

We had this place recommended to us by the hotel front desk person in millersburg. Glad I listened because it was absolutely delicious. This is real, country, home cooking. The dinner rolls are perfect, the fried chicken was perfect. The pot roast was perfect. All of it was SO GOOD. We got the buffet, which I recommend. Also, the cherry pie and peanut butter cream pie especially were heavenly. Such a great experience.

Delicious down home Amish/Midwestern food. The buffet was well stocked and fresh due to the constant turnover. The meatloaf in my opinion was the shining star here - juicy and flavorful. Staff was kind. The pie slices looked MASSIVE.

Really good, homemade food here. The chicken didn't have the thick coating as they had 15 years ago. Maybe they're cutting corners to get the food out faster. But, the coating they had was really good. We tried the meatballs that were made with local beef(Amish). They were in a sweet sauce. (Maybe grape jelly sauce). The cabbage casserole was amazing. Cabbage, onion, bacon in a creamy sauce with a cheese topping. The bacon and potato soup was seasoned just right. Fresh made whole wheat rolls were brought to us. Excellent buffet with a drink for $17. Reasonable price.

Don't let the simple interior fool you! You can choose between a full lunch and dinner menu, or check out the warm and cold buffet bars (which have many of the same menu items if you're a bigger eater). The chicken was juicy and delicious, the fried mushrooms were crispy on the outside and flavorful on the inside, and the green beans were both seasoned well and do not squeak in your mouth while chewing. I visited when the restaurant was at half capacity during lunch hours, and I was waited on immediately with friendly service throughout. If you're in Amish Country, this is a definite stop to make!

We had a nice lunch there today. The meatloaf was probably the best I've ever had.

Excellent food and service. We had the buffet which was included in our winter package from Dutch Host Inn as a dinner option. Love the food quality!

This was our last stop on a 3 day tour of Amishland. We saved it to last so we could savor a final dose of Amish comfort food.
Mrs Yoder's is not the typical pseudo-Amish industrial eatery. The clientel were mostly working folks on lunch breaks.
As with most Amish style places, Mrs Yoder's has a full menu but features a salad and lunch buffet. It was smaller than the industrial places but had the key food items. And the food was excellent. A little bland for some, but I really liked it. Our server kept our drinks filled. We actually chatted with other diners as we ate.
I really liked Mrs Yoder's. The food was good and it felt authentic, not mass feeding the masses on an industrial scale.

Such a great place to experience yummy Amish food. You know it's good when you notice many Amish families in the restaurant as patrons. The staff is amazing and very attentive. We got the buffet and so grateful we took a piece of peach cream pie, to go. Make sure you get dessert, especially if they have the peach cream pie... best dessert I have ever experienced!

The food was delicious we had the Buffet and it was great 👍

My wife and me went for dinner during our trip to Ohio Amish Country. Service was fast and friendly and prices are reasonable. The food was very good. If you are in the area, we strongly recommend you go to Mrs. Yoder's.

Loved eating here! Authentic Amish foods on a buffet. The fried chicken was the best I've ever had. And the homemade noodles were so yummy! While we were eating, there were more local Amish families coming in to eat as well, they know what's good! Stop at Mrs. Yoder's kitchen if you are ever in the area! And when you are done, take a drive down the road to pick up some good cheeses and see some pretty creations!

I’ve had many outstanding meals. Hands down Mrs. Yoders Kitchen can equal or surpass them. The chicken fried was perfect. Love cabbage so cabbage casserole was a must try and it was my favorite. The boiled eggs in beat juice or banana pepper juice were irresistible. That said grape and ground cherry pie were amazing firsts in my life.

Amazing food in a home cooked style. I would much rather support a business like this than a larger chain buffet. It's one of my favorite stops in the area.

I am so impressed with this restaurant. I loved every single thing I ordered, which consisted of hot chocolate, steamed broccoli, curly fries, fried chicken, and cherry pie. They must have some sort of enchantment they put on their food because it was the best hot chocolate, fried chicken, and cherry pie I had ever tasted. It was heavenly. 12/10, if you aren’t going here you’re missing out.

Very good food. I ate a meal at the communal/locals table and was glad I did. Try the specials!

This is the best chicken my wife and I have ever had. The buffet was extremely clean and well supplied with delicious food. The wait was only 5 - 10 minutes and the service and the waitress were outstanding. I would highly recommend this a must go to restaurant when you are visiting the area or just passing through. Would have had dessert but not enough room.

Best fried chicken I've ever had! Everything, really, is excellent. I always get the buffet, it is SO good. Mashed potatoes & gravy, meatloaf, pork chops, stuffing, cabbage casserole, mac & cheese, soups, extensive salad bar; and the list goes on. The service is great as well. Definitely worth the trip.

The chicken and noodle and mash potatoes we’re absolutely delicious the dinner rolls were delicious too I love this place I recommend this restaurant to any traveler out there who likes to travel through amish country and who are hungry

Yummy 😋 get chicken mash potatoes noodles and corn n salad