Vito & Michael's Pizzeria

First time to the area and this place came highly recommended by several people so we decided to give it a try. Baked ziti and pizza was terrific. Service was great! Bonus....you can dine in until 2am.

When we first arrived the male workers weren’t welcoming but Bella turned it all around for us! She was absolutely amazing! Her food recommendations did not disappoint! The pizza was amazing, although it could’ve used a little more sauce for my liking. We also took some tiramisu to go and it was delicious! Can’t wait to visit when we come back into town!

I love New York style pizza and found it while visiting St. Pete's Beach at Vito and Michael's Pizzeria. We ordered the garbage pizza and the white pizza. Both were good, but the garbage pizza was by far the better. You can tell they use good ingredients because the pizzas were full of flavor. And the staff were very friendly. If you want great pizza check out this spot. You will not be disappointed.

Had an amazing experience at this pizzeria.
I grew up in Chicago and am a food critic and I’ve open up a pizza restaurant in Tampa and let me tell you. This pizza is spot on. The dough is amazing, and the pizza is fantastic. Came in for a last night pizza after traveling all the way from Jacksonville, FL. I will be coming back here. This is the place if you want a friendly environment with great staff and awesome service. If you want good authentic pizza this is the spot. Look no further

Delicious pizza! Thin crust or thick. You decide.
Comes with salad and some focaccia

Vito and Michael's offers a lot of choices in a small location. Nestled in a small strip mall on Blind Pass, Vito and Michael's has an old school pizzeria atmosphere.

The food is delicious and the prices won't break the bank going out for a wonderful meal. Salads, sandwiches, pizza and Italian dishes are all on the menu and will leave you satisfied with something leftover for lunch tomorrow!

Open late night (for togo orders from 11pm to 2 or 3am) Vito and Michael's has fabulous food for you, day or night.

Parking is a little tight but you can manage. Great for an after work get together, family dinner or my favorite is later at night with my cabaret entertainer friend Fiona and I sitting in the back enjoying a delicious meal and having time to talk the night away while our server provides top notch service every time we are there.

Enjoy! Mange! Mange!

Excellent food, , large portions. Service was also good even though he was the only one. Would recommend. My husband had pizza, we had cheesy bread, I had a calzone. Also, there was complementary salad and basket of bread🍕👍

We come to Treasure Island regularly. We tried several pizza restaurants but we never ordered twice from any of them ... until now! Vito & Micheal's Pizzeria is by far the best pizza in the area hands down! We had the Garbage Pizza (not sure I like the name buy hey I'm 60 haha) and the chicken wings. Both Delicious!

If you’re looking for excellent fresh pizza on Saint Pete Beach among all the other ones that are so close but this one is the best! Maybe that’s why they’ve been in business for over 30 years. Yes they have beer and wine and open late! 2pm

If you're ever in the St Pete Beach area and in the mood for some amazing Italian food. Then Vito & Michael is definitely one of the places to visit. I absolutely can not get enough of the homemade lasagne. My wife loves the baked ziti. Huge portions and great price. Even better is that they are open late night. So, if you're hungry after a night out. Stop in. You won't be disappointed

This cozy pizza cafe is open until 2am, which is quite impressive! When I arrived at midnight, I was almost falling asleep, but the staff was friendly, cheerful, and extremely helpful. The pizza was simply delicious and exactly what I needed. The lady who served us was an absolute delight, and even took the time to explain the red tide phenomenon that was causing us to cough. Overall, it was a lovely experience, and we are grateful that they were open late to provide us with the sustenance we needed.

Great Pizza and love the cozy restaurant. They have great lunch deals, and they sell pizza by the slice 😋.
The service and the atmosphere were great. The family enjoyed it, we will always come back with family and friends.
Thank you for your hospitality ❤.

I was having a hard time finding good pizza by the slice in St Petersburg or St Pete Beach. A Google search revealed Vito and Michael's and I'm so glad I made the trip from downtown! Two large specialty slices and a soda was only 8.55 and both the "Temptation" and "Garbage" slices were great, especially the meat forward "Garbage".

Authentic Italian foods. Simple but well balanced seasonings and flavors. We tried a number of items and ALL exceeded our expectations. We have truly found the place for real food at a great value.

I consistently have great experiences here. Love the pizza. Slight sweet sauce and a light, crispy crust. My go to is a medium or large cheese pie

I was with 6 other women and our Free Beach Ride driver suggested us go here to eat. Everyone was completely happy and satisfied with the food and service. Tara was our server and she was great! We all agreed this was the best food we ate for the 5 days we were there. We will come back. Also, they have a great menu selection. I'm ready to try more things.

Phenomenal experience. Our server is from the Boston area and made the experience amazing! Great food, great food. Will definitely be back.

We ordered take out for a large gathering and they did an excellent job providing trays of lasagna and all the extras(good bread & salad). Would totally recommend!

I keep coming back for over 20 years i tried others but they are not as phenomenal as this Pizza. Its always freshly made and it just melts in your mouth its delicious!!! The staff is excellent always smiling and glad to see you. Thanks xoxo

Order everything - it's all so good. Second experience eating here, both times did not disappoint. Friendly and helpful service on the phone when ordering. Delicious amazingly authentic and fresh Italian food.