Mr. G’s Pizzeria

Vinny is the nicest guy, super friendly and welcoming of everyone. He makes killer pizza. The Roman Empire slice is the best for carnivores. There are plenty of options for all! If you haven't visited them, you're missing out! When a place makes a banger regular slice, you know they are 🔥!

Came all the way from Connecticut for a event and seen MR. G’s pizza and I wanted to try the the pizza is amazing one of the best pizza I’ve had from New York if your ever in Long Island stop by and try them

A Lindenhurst staple. Right in the heart of the village, and a fantastic taste every time. Has never let me down.

One of the best pizzerias in the area. Friendly staff and food always tastes good.

Really good.
No idea why but this pizza reheats really well in the oven.

Vinny is awesome. Great pizza, knots, pasta dishes and heroes.

Mr. G is a very friendly owner who serves tasty pizza. I always enjoy the very large cheese slices with a side of blue cheese. The Mr. G's Special Hero (cold) is also a must try.

If you can't get to Brooklyn, this is about as close as you can get to authentic BK pizza. Great staff, right off the train. Near walking distance to 2 theaters. Excellent service. Reasonable prices. Can't get much better!

I had a dinner party tonight. I order Sicilian pies from Mr G. My company couldn't stop bragging about the taste, the freshness, the mushrooms, sausage, etc . I just want to thank Vinny for all he did to make my dinner party night a special and successful one with all my friends. Another fantastic job done by Mr G's Pizza

I stayed in the neighborhood as a tourist. Before arriving in New York, I scoped out what to eat. Everyone recommended Joe's pizza in the city. Of course, I tried the pizza from Joe's that everyone likes, but however, the pizza from Mr. G was much better

Best prices I’ve ever seen, Will go to always!

Good real Italian food, ordered online, fast ready for pickup, like the oversized 24" pizza slices, my favorite pepperoni, fresh crust and garlic knots as well.

Mr.G's has and always will be my favorite pizzeria, for the last 20 years of my life. I'm a Lindenhurst native who moved to Commack in 2014 and consistently went out of my way to go visit my favorite pizzeria. I moved to Colorado last March and will always make sure I visit Vinny for a slice of pizza, some garlic knots, and a root beer.

Miss you Vinny & gang. Hope all is well! Cant wait to come back home and visit my favorite pizzeria again

Always friendly when I call. New to the area and they gave me free knots for my first order. The food was ready on time and DELICIOUS!! This will be my new spot for sure! The sauce is SO good and the crust is perfect. Couldnt be happier to have found this place!

I'm writing this review the day after ordering a variety of food. I forced myself to stop eating so I can have it again as left overs. Simply amazing. Hands down the best Alla vodka sauce I've had. I even dipped the pizza in it !! Now I need to try an Alla vodka slice of pizza.. I can only imagine!! Wow thanks for such a great dish

Best in town! Love ordering from here. Quality food, great portions, and Vinny, the owner is super kind.

I’m not sure what’s better, the taste of the food or the customer service. We always walk out of there with a smile on our face, in a better mood than when we walked in! We always go for the specialty slices, which are delicious!!! Mr. G’s is the best pizza place in town!!

Best Italian food, when I come back from SC to visit family, I have to stop at Mr G's The owner Vinnie is the the best. I would highly recommend and when you stop in tell Vinnie that John sent you.

The cheese pie at Mr. G's is my favorite on the island. I've been ordering from Vinny for years and have never been disappointed. once i brought my girlfriend, now my wife, to order a takeout pie and walked up slightly after close and he was locking the door, he promptly unlocked it and asked what he could make for me. Lifetime patron.

Always a good thing when you have an Italian pizzeria close by, I travel to Brazil often and I Crave a good Slice ! and a Big one might I say.