Broadway Bagels

Bagels still warm whenever I go in. I favor the Jalapeno n Cheddar bagel. they also have Fresh Chocolate Chip cookies that are soft and delicious!
Stop by and give them a try!
They also make an Awesome Sandwich!!!

Iv gotten food from there multiple times but someone else always picked it up and brought it to my house. On January 1st I was happy to know they were open and went there myself, I left there in great spirits because of the guys that were working they need more people pleasers like these guys EVERYWHERE! as for the food That speaks for itself! Happy New Year!

Delicious bagels, friendly service, but there are no tables to eat. Perfect for quick to go orders. Broadway Bagel Shop is a breakfast paradise!

Ran 22 miles to Parlin from Princeton, threw up in a Knights of Columbus parking lot and went to the bay. Capped off the experience with possibly the best toasted everything bagel with cream cheese in a Prius. They also filled up my water bottle for me which was very nice of them.
10/10 would recommend.

Great lunch spot. I had many sandwiches and bagels from this place, and they were consistently good. The sandwiches could be a little overloaded, but that's what makes it a great sandwich and a great deal. The employees are friendly and they remember your order if you are a regular. Definitely recommend.

Great bagels and friendly wonderful staff.

Friendly staff and a lot of great options at this bagel store. Had a poppy bagel with scallion cream cheese this morning and it was delicious. They have some new breakfast sandwiches like pork roll, sausage, egg and cheese with hash browns on a roll, definitely going to try that next time.

My family eats here at least once per week. Servers are friendly. Food is fresh but the Bagels are OUTSTANDING! Relatives who visit us come here first before arriving at my house. Proud customer since 2002. Love this place!

New to town & our teenagers are OBSESSED with the French Toast Bagel & chocolate chip cookies, which will now be called “The Family Cookie” because it tastes like it was made in a loving kitchen 🫶🏽💕

Oh yeah look at this baby half a sub a little over eight bucks but it's loaded!

Best place in South Amboy and I'd say the best bagels in the entire country, yes even NYC! Get there early and get them freshly warm out the oven. I'd recommend an Everything pork roll egg and cheese.

Recently moved to the area and this was the first food place I tried here. Food was great! A little messy but tasted good lol. The man who took my order at the door was sweet and was patient with me not talking loud enough through my mask. I plan to go back soon!

Porkroll, Egg and Cheese are Delicious.. so is the crumb cake. The bagels are fresh and they have the best coffee..

I drive 20 min,having several other bagel shops within 5 min of me, just to eat their sausage egg and cheese.Its that good.Extremely friendly staff as well

Been going to this place since it opened. Staff is always friendly. Great to go early and get them when they are still hot.

Best bagels I've had and I worked in NYC for 30 years. Tuna is solid white no chunk light.

Always fast and friendly service. Best Bagels around

The girls behind the counter were excellent give them a $5 tip. They made me feel so good

Their bagels with egg, butter and ketchup is amazing. I go there every week!!! Love their brownies!!!

Now called Gems Bagels still the best bagels, period. Always great service.