Nonna Lisa's Italian Restaurant

Nonna Lisa’s is a unique dining experience.

We stopped by to get a bite to eat after a long day. It was a bit late when we got in. The staff was very nice and helpful. The wait for the food was minimal/appropriate for pizza.

We really enjoyed the gluten-free pizza with sausage and spinach as well as a cheese pizza for our kids. There was also some interesting beverages. My wife enjoyed a cherry wine.

As you can tell from some of the pictures, there’s quite the decorations… Animals, Christmas trees, Christmas, lights, etc.

Food was great. It's pricey but you get more than enough. Having testicles looming everywhere sure is a...thing but you should be focused on your companions and the food. Staff was polite and efficient, kept our drinks full and served promptly.

It's a very cool restaurant. Our server was excellent and the food was great. My wife had a problem with her meal but it was rectified. So not a problem. It's a little pricey but the portions are huge so it understandable.

Was here on family vacation, whatever we ordered was delicious. Even the breadsticks were freshly made. My fav was Chicken Alfredo Pasta. Would definitely recommend. Love from India 🙏🏻

Wow! What a place! Stephanie and Carrie were absolutely amazing- catered to us in every way! Husband got to watch the USA vs Panama game and they brought our wine tasting and beer tasting flights to where he was even though it was not in the winery or brewery area. AMAZING customer service! Not to mention great wine!! Highly recommended, family dinning!

Great food and atmosphere here. Staff were very nice.

Atmosphere is top-shelf. Food is great and they even let us make a white sauce pizza with Alfredo, chicken, pineapple and "bacon." Peaceful and quite the experience. Got this one saved to my UP/LP Hit List. Yum yum.

One of the best Italian restaurants we've been too. Pizza is super delicious with the best quality meat toppings. What we love the most is the seafood portofino pasta, one of the best pastas we've ever had. I have never been a fan of the mussels but I became a convert with their succulent and juicy blue mussels. The scallops were perfectly cooked. We'd love to eat there again if we ever go back to Mackinaw City.

First and foremost the food we got was amazing! We had to go back a second time. For appetizers we had Bruschetta, we created our own pizza with our fav toppings and got the Steak Gorgonzola Alfredo (the reason we went back twice). The steak was extremely delicious and the sauce didn’t taste like a regular Alfredo sauce, it was creamier and cheesier. The decor definitely doesn’t scream Italian, it was all taxidermy but it was pretty and I actually enjoyed snapping a few pictures of it. The staff was very friendly and quick. Would definitely go back when I visit again.

This place was amazing! The people who waited on us were Stephenie and Carrie, they really were on it made the whole experience very special we loved this place and definitely recommend it! Food was great, drinks were great and service was top notch!!!!!

Food was delicious...my husband and I are visiting from Florida. This is our first time in this town and state, we came to this restaurant and really enjoyed our meal except for the deep fried breadstick. Will diffently come back, soon!

One of the amazing dining Options in a tourist destination like this... There are plenty of entree options that you have starting from Pizzas to Pastas to Lasagna. Their pizza along with the Bruschetta bread was really delicious.
The service was prompt and very good. What's most amazing is the ambience of this place which sets it really apart from other restaurants. There is plenty of seating available and a really nice fireplace to sit next to.
Perfect restaurant to dine with for family, couples or friends!!!

We picked up our pizza to take back to hotel and I have to say, the inside of this place is the coolest!!! Anyway, we got wood fired chicken spinach Alfredo pizza. . . . . I can't even!!! THE BEST IVE EVER HAD. Hands down. We had it 2 nights in a row, dayuuuum!!!

My brother and I rolled into Mackinaw City late and hungry. Nonna Lisa's was pretty much the only place open. We ordered pizza that was made exactly the way we asked and it was absolutely delicious!

We ordered an appetizer of bruschetta which was also delicious, but way more than we could eat.

I ordered a garden salad and let me tell you, that was THE best salad I'd ever eaten. This was almost 11 o'clock at night and this salad was 100% fresh! All of the vegetables were ripe and freshly sliced. Nonna Lisa's gets five stars from me on the salad alone, but everything was amazing.

The wait staff was clearly very busy, but they were still friendly and funny and the decor here is really something to see!

Five stars all day long! I can't wait to go back and take my wife to Nonna Lisa's!

Great place. Beautiful inside, very inviting and friendly atmosphere. Good waitstaff, professional and helpful. They have a couple gluten free options as well. We ordered an appetizer, two dinners a glass of wine and a beer. The cost was approximately 75$ plus tip. Worth the price as we brought home leftovers for a lunch.

Pizza was great. Customer service was even greater! Justin made sure we’re happy and satisfied. Definitely will be back and recommend this place to anyone stopping in Mackinaw City.

Dinner was absolutely fantastic. The service was friendly and helpful as well. The pricing was medium to high, but the portion sizes were really big, which was nice. Glad we chose to have dinner here.

Our server David was awesome!!! Our drinks were never empty and he had a contagious happy and uplifting personality.

Great place to get Italian food excellent lasagna and pizza

4th time being there. Everytime more than I can eat, you may look at the prices and say no, but I ordered lasagna and ate it in restaurant then 2 more times at home. The price is worth the quality and portions.