Pizza Katerina

The pizza was delicious! All the things below do not detract enough to not leave a 5 star review.

If you plan on eating there, there's not much room. It's kind of an awkward setup. There's no menus or signs about options or prices or anything like that. You can scan a QR code to go to their website to see what they offer. And it seems like a dining area is kind of an afterthought for them. They don't have plates or silverware or anything like that. Your pizza comes in a box if you're dining there. They have odd soda choices, which are sangria, orange, or grapefruit. No Coke, no Pepsi, no root beer or anything you might expect to find at a restaurant. So kind of a quirky place. But man do they know how to make a good NY style pizza! It was so good, I devoured half the pizza. The crust was just the right chewy/crispy balance.

I would definitely go back if I am in the area again!

The BEST pizza I have had in such a long time. Quality chewy perfectly cooked crust, savory nicely seasoned sauce, top tier ingredients. I get olives, pineapple (don't judge), and veggie pepperoni. Also, the owner is a gem of a person. Highly recommend. Lastly, get a loaf of their garlic herb bread, its delicious.

Our first trip was very memorable. Mel was very hospitable us. We just moved to the area and she made us feel right at home. The pizza was top notch, made with high quality ingredients without compromise. It's a must try for anyone. We are going there tonight for the second time.

Hands down top of the line pizza! They do everything from scratch! I now have a new favorite pizza place that knocks all other places out of the picture! Thank you for such great pizza and a very reasonable price!

I've been wanting to try Pizza Katerina since they opened and a bit embarrassed to say we just now got a chance! It's instantly added to our favorites list!! The pepperoni stuffed garlic knots were to die for. Sooo good! Fresh ingredients .. delicious crust. We did delivery and everything was seamless. ❤

Came from out of town to visit family. Katrina's came highly recommended, and they did not disappoint! Three pizzas, all were unique and delicious. Great experience, highly recommend!

I moved to Michigan from Philadelphia and this pizza is hands down the best in the Kalamazoo area and the closest I have found to true East coast style crust and sauce. AMAZING! Love the specialty pies as well, barbeque in particular. Also the garlic knots are my favorite!

We stopped in this weekend for the 1st time. Very tasty pizza. Owner was super friendly and had obvious love of her craft. Crust tasted great and toppings were high quality. Will come again.

Amazing pizza and customer service. We love their regular and gluten free pizzas. We really appreciate the vegan meat and cheese options as well.

OMG!!!
So many vegan options.
Doughs are vegan.
Sauces are vegan.
Violife vegan cheese or our favorite Miyokos vegan mozzarella. Water and Wheat vegan sausage and vegan chicken.
4 different vegan ice creams, oat milk based so easy on your tummy.
Kinda wish I hadn’t found out about this place, going to be tough controlling myself.
Also everything was delicious, obviously from scratch dough and sauces. Great service.

By far the best little pizza parlor to come across! The owners are lovely people and the pizza was absolutely delicious! Unique flavors and everything made from scratch with local ingredients. They even had a little play pizza parlor set-up for the kids to keep entertained while we waited! Very highly recommend and we will be back!

First time eating here and definitely will not be the last. The food was fantastic and the owners, family and staff were so friendly and very welcoming. Best pizza we have had in a very long time.

Decided to try this place tonight based on all the glowing reviews and they did not disappoint! Pizza is amazing, thinner hand tossed crust, great sauce. The service is also stellar, some of the best I’ve had anywhere. Everyone was so friendly and helpful when we said it was our first time, taking the time to go over the menu and their specials. As we ate, they made sure to ask what we thought, and we noticed that a ton of people coming in were regulars. Highly, highly recommend this one!

What an amazing find. The staff was very welcoming. It was my 1st time there and they made you feel like family. Fresh ingredients they even grow their own mushrooms!!!
One thing I truly love is that they were warm and welcoming one of the family members even shared a slice of their Pizza which I ended up ordering later on during my trip to Michigan.
I love that they have seasonal specialty pizzas which are very unique blend of flavors that I never thought I would try on a pizza.
Also create your own pizza which is always fun which I made my own and it came out delicious.
This is one place I do miss now that I'm back home in Connecticut. And I wish them only happiness and success in the future and I hope that I come back to the area and have more pizza!!

A really wonderful little pizza joint. I tried it for the first time today because of the reviews. I ordered the lunch special which was a really value for the money. I am not a small guy, and it was very filling to me. The pizza was fantastic and fresh. The fresh made dough is what I think really makes a difference here. I believe it was the owner who helped me, and she was extremely friendly and kind. If I lived closer I would visit all the time. Highly recommend!

I told the owner I'd leave a review after trying their pizza so here it is. My first time ordering from Pizza Katerina since reading so many posts on Facebook about this place. I was not disappointed. I stopped in and did an order at the counter as I wanted to go to Walmart to get some things first, so I figured an in person order would buy me some time.

I was greeted by the owner and she told me about their fresh made dough and I had asked about the Thai pizza and was interested to know more about the Red Curry sauce that they use on the Pizza. The owner grabbed some from a little bottle, put a small sample on a knife and let me taste it. It was amazingly delicious. So I ordered the Thai Pie with added smoked chicken and total came to $23 and some change. Well worth every penny.

Staff was very friendly and this place was hopping busy with plenty of pizzas in the warmer waiting to get picked up and plenty of customers inside waiting to order and picking up. When I picked up the pie and took it home I was impressed with the amount of toppings on the pie, but my favorite part of this pizza is by far the chewy, doughy crust. Soooo good. The crust is super thick where it's supposed to and thinner on the area where the toppings go, but I really enjoyed how good it was. The toppings were fresh, plentiful and tasted amazing in combination with each other. I've never tried a Thai Pizza but it was definitely worth it.

If you're looking to help out a small, locally owned business and help out the employees who were working there, give this place a try. If you love chewy, delicious crust, you'll def like your experience here. I'm going to try to order a different pizza on my next visit, but I hope the owners remember me when they see me again. I was wearing the white Marine Hat.

Holy toppings!!! We ordered the pesto pizza today, and everything in the description is on there in high quantity. This pizza was very savory. The crust was light and fluffy. The focaccia bread was delicious too! They threw in some cookies for Valentine’s Day - very sweet of them!

This is for you Josie(best customer service!)! The pizza and the knots were Awesome! The Atmosphere was even better, the BOMB!! We will be eating here often!

We got Pizza Katerina for the first time at a winery tonight, never heard of it before but 10/10 would recommend!! We purchased 3 kinds: BBQ, Fig/Pear, & 1 take n’bake Margarita (pictured) - all 3 were a hit. Can’t wait to order again!!

I’m picky and watch my calories so rarely eat pizza. Had a super long work week and was craving the margherita pizza. It’s out of season but when my husband called they still made me my favorite and apologized for it not being perfect. It was absolutely delicious and amazing. Thank you!!!