The Red Pepperoni

I wish I could give more stars. It’s December 23rd and all the employees are smiling, cheerful and happy to serve you. The food was fantastic, the restaurant is clean and everything was absolutely perfect. We will definitely return when we are back in the area.

Good little place, friendly staff, spots on multiple TV. We had a large pepperoni with extra cheese and it was good. This was our second visit and will be back when in the area.

2/19/2024
I believe this is our 3rd time. She had a Calzon and I had a Sicilian 6" pizza. They were both great. We will be back.

First time consumer. Small restaurant with quirky atmosphere. Friendly staff that will give recommendations to top choices! Outdoor seating available based on weather. Limited parking but worth the stop! Adequate available choice options on the menu to choose from! Overall a great experience! Would recommend!

The food was so delicious. Ordered bread sticks and a Hawaiian pie. Hands down one of the best pizza places we've ate at so far. We will be back really soon

Super cool restaurant in an old car garage. Great food, lots of menu options, and big portions. The calzone was killer! I've never seen so many calzone options! This is a great place to stop after a long day of hiking at Clifty Falls State Park.

Very busy place. One seat left…Service to our table was immediate and drinks and order taken promptly. Awesome pizza. BBQ chicken w jalapeños added and personal size with pepperoni and mushrooms. Madison Indiana is a great place to visit. Near the River and almost all of the town is painted nicely.

Searching for a place that has a spot for your pups to hang out? This is it! After hiking at Clifty Falls we decided food was very much needed. The dogs hung outside with us while we enjoyed our delicious pizza. The service was wonderful and the pizza came out fast and hot.

We stopped by here for the second time and it was FANTASTIC! Rachel provided quick friendly service and terrific pizza!! We got the Thai Chicken pizza and the Sicilian Calzone… perfection!!

We were on a tight timeline and they still accommodated us.

If you want amazing pasta, top notch customer service and some fantastic pizza definitely come here! Our waitresses were so kind and chatty and showed off a perfect example of what great customer service is. My fiance said the Beer options were up to his picky standards and the food Definitely satisfied my pregnancy cravings!! The pasta was leagues above any pasta I've had in town and the starters were absolutely perfect. I'll absolutely be coming back!

I'm never disappointed! Great pizza! The salads are plentiful and delicious. Can't turn down the tasty breadsticks and nacho cheese either. 😋 Very clean, and the servers are very observant and help each other out. I had two separate waitresses filling drinks the day I went.

First time visiting. I can see why this place gets such good reviews. It's a great place to eat in Madison. The service is great and the pizza is even better. They have a huge selection of craft beers. I would totally recommend The Red Pepperoni to anyone. They have indoor and outdoor seating. Ada availability. It's right in town if you want to explore after and just down the road from the state park. My only complaint is the limited parking.

Excellent pizza with tasty ingredients. The bread sticks were puping hot and perfectly baked. The salad was good, but nothing special. The ingredients were fresh. Parking can be a challenge during peek times. The atmosphere is cozy and similar to a small sports bar. We loved it.

Great pizza, small location. The pizza here was really good, not so fancy that my kids didn't want to try it, but better than basic pizza. Worth the stop in.

I stopped in at lunchtime for my first time here. I got a calzone, and chose the specialty Bonsai Chicken with a side of teriyaki sauce. Despite being very busy the service was quick and attentive. The food came out in a timely manner, the portion was generous, and the quality was great. The restaurant has a nice atmosphere and ambience, and I will gladly visit again if in the area!

Food was excellent- Gluten free options! Fast service even though it was packed.
Waitresses are friendly but no-nonsense and to the point.

Fries taste like real potatoes
Ranch tastes like homemade ranch

the menu described my cider as a "surreal" blend of fruits...and when that first taste hit my tongue, I swear I saw heaven.

My husband and I stopped by here for the first time, everyone was so friendly! We ordered the MacDaddy Pizza and added mushrooms and spinach, it was delicious!

Really enjoyed our trip to Madison and this place for lunch. Lots of pizza and Italian options. Friendly staff. Good prices.

Easily the best calzones around! We come from Cincinnati as often as we can just for their amazing food. Service is always friendly and fast.

Visited Madison today to do some shopping. The res pepperoni was recommended to us by some friends who own one of the local shop. We had the Thai chicken, BBQ Chicken and the Sicilian. Everything was amazing. Well worth the drive and the 5 star rating!! If you're here please give this establish your time!!!

Outstanding! Our group visited with our two dogs and sat in the patio on a beautiful day. We ordered two Calzones and they were sooooo goooood! Thank you Red Pepperoni for great prices,great food, and allowing our pets to dine with us! We'll be back....