Top Hat Two - Pizza King

I grew up on the pizza here during the 70's thru the 90's. What a thrill to be back in area in 2024 and find the location is still open and is just as amazing now as it was then. Yes it was $34 for a 16 inch pizza, but that fed 4 of us, worth every single penny - man the toppings are piled high and cooked to perfection. There is no comparison to their pepperoni, sausage, and oh my, that crust!

Maybe I am biased. I grew up in this town. However, every time I return, my first thought for food is this place. I have no complaints. The multiple pizza places from the other city I live in does not compare to this place. I have never had any issues with the food or service. Top Hat Two has just amazing pizza.

Clearly the best Pizza King in New Castle. Always great, fresh and delicious. While they are human, in all the pizzas I’ve purchased there, I’ve only had one slightly burnt which they remade without hesitation. Keep up the great pizzas.

Top Hat Two is what pizza King used to be before covid!!!!!! We drive 15 miles to get pizza there, instead of the pizza king in our town less than a mile from my home. Quality matters and if you're wanting a Legitimate Pizza King pizza, this is the place!!!!!!

I get pizza from here AT LEAST once a month. In the last year I've had one relatively sub-par pizza. Perhaps it was a trainee, don't care cuz EVERY OTHER TIME it's been amazing! If you've never been a trainee - you shouldn't be allowed to leave a review.....When people leave bad reviews look at two things, the number of times they've reviewed, and their grammar. Also, take into consideration, they could perhaps be a disgruntled ex-employee seeking childish revenge. And, ya'll know, it's the pissed off Karen's leaving reviews - it's rarely the satisfied customers.

Lucky enough to enjoy this pizza often when I’m in New Castle. It’s perfect every time! Best Pizza King around!

Phenomenal pizza especially for the area, fantastic service, and in a time crunch because it was a last minute dinner for the family! Highly recommended. 5 stars!

Great food! I’ve been a pizza king fan since a kid. Can’t wait to order from here again.

I live out of state so first time coming here. The pizza is like none other that I've had. Amazing! They don't skimp on toppings at all. We got the Royal Feast and WOW!!! I wish we had one of these back home!

The best pizza !! Service was excellent! Highly recommend!!

We will ALWAYS choose Top Hat Two as our first choice for take-out pizza!

Holy heck I'm from Texas and that's a lot of meat on that Za. Every inch is covered and then covered again for good measure. The crust was quite nice. Indiana was way to cold but the pizza was hot and tasty.

This is the best quality PK pizza. They don't short you on toppings, service is always friendly. My family and friends all know this is where you get your carry out. Oven baked goodness.

Best Damn Pizza on Planet Earth!

Pizza from Top Hat Two has always been excellent! I have been going there for over 20 years. Got a pizza this past weekend...still excellent as always! Always very pleased with the quality pizza, and the friendly service from the staff. Well done!

Great pizzas and awesome employees.

It's a take-out only place. Pizza King is spread throughout Indiana. It's more costly than chain pizza restaurants. <

Best Pizza King in Henry, Hancock and Madison County! Pizza Kings slogan is "good to the edge" and this place truly follows that! Very generous with toppings! 5 Stars!

Extremely delicious pizza

The best pizza king I've had, in 2 counties. Drive through window was hard to find at first, and the alley is nothing but potholes...but it's worth bottoming out.