Red Tomato Pizzeria

Got individual 8 slices pizza, delicious. People are very friendly and quick.
The place is busy , people are in and out all the time.

Nice vibe.
You can also eat in if you’ll like

haven't been back in over a decade and this pizza still stands up next to sally's in new haven as my favorite pizza. the crust is as thin and crispy, without sacrificing any structural integrity to hold up whilst eating, with the perfect amount of chew that deteriorates with a perfect
mini burned spots that just burst the umami of the sauce as you eat it. nice to know that something that set such an impression on me when i lived a stones throw away throughout high school hasn't changed at all. also i don't remember them having baklava 15 years ago but needless to say it was masterfully made and i would implore anyone with a sweet tooth to try it, it's not overly moist like some baklava and the nuts were evenly spread making for a nice bite every time.

This has always been my Favorite Pizza on the Shoreline. Worth the Drive--although they don't deliver. BEST pizza sauce & crust-Ever. Their crust has a taste like no other!
Dined-in recently for lunch after a few yrs of only doing Pick-up; Service was quick! Younger Waiter/Cook was super nice. I ordered lasagna & a white clams casino pizza, which I now know a white pie is also great.
☆If you haven't been, you must try!

Thank you a great small cheese pizza hits the spot. Order from them twice was not disappointed

Best New Haven style pizza on the shoreline. In the winter time I go for the sausage and mushroom pie. In the summer months when the tomatoes are fresh I hopped 4 the margarita. And Any time and all the time the Clams Casino White is to die for. Fresh shucked clams!

I'm sorry it's taken me so long to get to this review, but better later than never I suppose! Every Friday night is pizza night for my family, and we always have it delivered from Red Tomato, not just because they are super close to us geographically, but because we absolutely love their pies.
I have to say, they've never let us down, and our kids only ever want pizza from Red Tomato. Seriously, it has to be Red Tomato or no go for them, lol.
The delivery is always super easy, and pleasant. We love you guys!

Beautiful and mouth watery pizzas but the wait is something else. Overall good pizza.

Red Tomato never disappoints. My daughter took me here recently for my birthday. Friendly service and amazing pizza!

Best pizza in Madison. This is New Haven style pizza- thin crust, nice and salty and not too much sauce. Their sausage is locally made. They also stock Foxon Park Cola. Must pay cash- charge extra for credit cards.

This place serves a phenomenal white pizza. The delivery is extremely fast service, they are very friendly and cordial whether you eat in or get delivery they are flexible and work with you and they do everything they can to make your experience a pleasant one. I have yet to have bad experience there!

Our family has been coming here for YEARS, we absolutely love this place. The pizza is fantastic and the staff is always incredibly friendly. It's a little off the beaten path and pretty small once you're inside, but I have never had to wait more than 10mins (and we usually come with quite a large crew). This is the number one spot for us to go to when we visit CT!

I was born in New Haven near Wooster Street and Pepe's pizza before moving to Guilford 40 years ago. The red tomato is by far among the best best pizza you'll get anywhere. We love the house special!

I love this place. I've moved but it was fun to visit family and get some pies to go. BTW they have gluten free pizza that's my favorite!

The best pizza in all of ct. perfect balance of crust and toppings, the crust is still crispy even in the middle of the pizza. (Most places overdo cheese and sauce so the crust and overall pizza is soggy in the center) but not Red Tomato. Never dissapoints

Best pizza ever... we go weekly. Service is very goood and the wait staff is very quick to greet us and seat us and take our orders. Just wish they had delivery. I would recommend them to everyone.

Great pizza, especially when eaten right there. Not fancy but good service and we loved the pizza. Recent visit - new owners that are keeping up the tradition. Still great pizza.

We came in about 20 minutes prior to closing time, and everyone was still super kind, and they didn't attempt to rush us at all. The portions were huge, and the food was delicious. Excellent experience.

Was just there 6/29/2021 ... Had 3 different pies sit down menu... And what a place great service amazing pizza ... For real guys stop by give them a chance you will not ever be disappointed...btw service amazing

Very fast delivery and nice staff! I order from here often, and love it! Very good pizza too of course!

It was the best pizza I've ever eaten