Tonino's Pizza

This place is probably the closest thing to a NYC slice! For the New Yorkers who get it, you know what I’m talking about. It doesn’t matter if you local or visiting,Don’t hesitate to go, you won’t regret it! A plain slice will do it every time if you like your pizza like this! Service is quick & they’re super nice & you’ll crave it over & over just like I did!

I moved to PA from Central NJ about two years ago and have been looking for a good pizza place since. I tried a few in East Stroudsburg that made me pretty sick, so I didn’t have high hopes. But not only does the pizza smell so good it tastes so good! The crust is crispy and the sauce has a nice flavor to it! Very happy I ordered from here, if you’re looking for good pizza in the Stroudsburg area that’s comparable to NJ/NY pizza I’d definitely recommend Tonino’s!

I moved to Pennsylvania a little over a year ago and in that time I have tried so many Pizzerias, looking for a place that would even compare or rival NJ pizza..... Well here it is.
The dough is near perfect, the sauce is also very good and just the right amount of cheese.

Called ahead and placed our order, told it would be ready in 20 minutes. Arrived 20 minutes later and order was ready. The girl who took my order over the phone was extremely friendly and when I arrived to pick up order she was just as pleasant in person.
Have to give the chef a Hugh shout out as the food was absolutely 💯 delicious and hot. I live in NYC and dined at many fine Italian restaurants and have to rate this Toninos right up there as far as food quality.
The others might be ahead as far as looks and locations, but this small place in the Poconos should hold there heads high as far as how delicious their dishes are.
Will always go back here anytime I visit the Poconos.

My favorite Italian place in the whole Poconos, NEPA, LV area. Excellent service, good prices, and even great gluten free options in both pizza and pasta. What more could you ask for??

Insanely good pizza. I have a dairy allergy but I ordered the Crispino pizza with no cheese and it was so flavorful I didn't miss the cheese at all. The garlic olive oil is just *chefs kiss*.

Just had a pizza. Food & service were excellent! Atmosphere is nothing fancy; it's a pizzaria.

Food was terrific! I had chicken bacon ranch pizza with 2 stuffed garlic knots, omg, YUMMY! Gentleman behind the counter was courteous. Will go again. Highly recommend 👌

Love the pizza here and staff very nice chicken bacon my absolute favorite

OMG OMG THIS PLACE AND THE FOOD WAS SO DELICIOUS AND AMAZING I DEFINITELY WOULD RECOMMEND THEIR FOOD. WE HAD THE STROMBOLI!!!

Reg pizza joint with the best Buffalo chicken pizza around. We live about 1.5hrs away and only go that way 4x a yr for the outlets and shopping but always end the day there. The leftover pizza makes the car smell delicious on the ride home.

I have just moved to the area and have found this is a wonderful place!!! The 🍆 Parm I had was fabulous and the "small" calzone my sister ordered was the size of a small house. We had delivery and the food was delivered all intact, packaged separately (important to those of us who don't like our food to touch) and in recyclable packaging.

Love it. Will be our regular.

Very big surprise! We normally just pick up pizza and cheese steak but we decided to sit and have dinner. Much to our surprise it was wonderful! I had chicken Alfredo and the sauce was out of this world. And the portions were huge! Husband had garlic shrimp and he too was pleasantly surprised. Go, take a seat and enjoy!

We love the crispini pizza and sausage and pepper hero!

I've ordered from Tonino's a number of times. The food is delicious and the staff is very friendly. One day, I made an online order and showed up early to learn they were out of an appetizer I ordered. The staff offered to replace the app with another one from the menu and then threw in some extra garlic knots.

Another day, I went in to pick up a pizza. The staff was cleaning and sweeping. The gentleman with the broom, went behind the counter and washed his hands for at least two minutes, and apologized for taking so long, simply to hand me a box with a pizza. That is excellent sanitary procedure! Very clean! Thank you!

They're always fast and friendly; and their food tastes amazing!
When I want a great pizza in the Poconos- Toninos (or Nino's as my kids call it) is the only place I'll go!
Great crust, the sauce is on point and the toppings are SO fresh! I'll recommend them every time!

Reminds me of my favorite pizza place back home down the mountain. I love the sauce. Anyone who doesn't is stupid its the best pizza I've had up here hands down. Very excited to order again today

This is my go to for Italian take out. More important tan the good food...we love how they treat you. Best customer service in the area hands down. The chicken fantasy dinner is a favorite. We order our pizza on the well done/crispy side and they always cook it just right. Love this place, love these people. Support local businesses....go local!

Best Pizza in the Poconos! The pizza, garlic knots, and wings were the best we've ever had! Great family business. Our only regret is we are from Florida and it will be a long time before we get to have it again... Have a slice for the Greene family when you visit.

The dinners are outstanding, the garlic knots are the best in town, everything else is great too. They've been a part of our Valentine's day family tradition of Italian food and chocolate covered strawberries for years and years and they're not even aware of it. Our favorite is eggplant rollattini but everything we order is always top notch. Give them a try, you should not be disappointed.