Muscarella's Cafe Italia

A Nice fine dining experience with large helpings that tends to be packed during the weekends. Easy to pass up on the strip in downtown Jamestown, PA, this is a spot you wouldn't want to miss on any special occasion. Be prepared to spend a few bills because the food can be quite expensive. The bar is tight, but has a wide selection of local beers and fine wines. The dining area is much more spacious and has a more romantic feel with the lighting, table settings and large booths. Overall, I would consider it one of the higher rated places to eat in Mercer county.

We love this place, went here for my hubby's birthday, and as usual we were not disappointed. The food was wonderful, the cocktails were well made, and the calamari appetizer was perfection. We had probably a 40-minute wait from arrival to being seated, but once we had a table, service happened quickly. Our waitress had another grab our drink order since she was busy at the moment, but everything came out at very reasonable times.

This is probably one of the best Italian restaurants iv ever been to. The food was amazing. The atmosphere was great. I was visiting from New York and I gotta say it's almost worth the drive just to have a meal at this place.

I’ve been wanting to try this place, it’s a pretty big place. Good atmosphere. Will our waiter was great. I ordered the Trio - Lasagna, chicken parm and Alfredo. The chicken was a little dry but good, I really enjoyed the Alfredo, the lasagna was filling. Of course I brought food home, because the portions are pretty big. The table had the zucchini and calamari, which I’m not a fan of calamari, but I did taste it and it was delicious. The garlic cheese bread was cheesy and garlicky PERFECT! The wedding soup was yummy
I wanted cheese cake and they were sold out.

This is our go-to place for anything! Birthday, anniversary, or just a night away from cooking! The menu has a great selection, and we live for the weekly menu items. Love the cozy feel of the inside restaurant. Indoor patio is ok, but you don't get the old school italian feel. Food is and who doesn't love free bread and oil dip?! Definitely need to check this little gem!

This restaurant has an exquisite, elegant decor and has very good food! They have inside and outside enclosed patio seating with great staff, food, and fine Italian foods!

They have numerous pasta's along with a Chef specialty dishes and steak!

They get a lot of business and make sure you make reservations as they get filled up quickly!

Elizabeth was incredible, attentive service while also allowing us to have space while we dined. Do wish we were given crayons for our paper table cover (though I’m sure we would have been given drawing implements had we asked).
The prices were very reasonable for the portions, including drinks.

I would definitely come back, once again Elizabeth was a joy to have as a waitress!

Oh my word. All I have to say is GO! I had the wedding soup which was amazing. I got the mushroom pasta on their lunch menu, and all I can say is it is absolutely delicious. Pasta is cooked to perfection al dente. The flavor is just amazing. I love the bread for dipping in oil too. I’m sad I live an hour away.

The food is very good. I usually get take out for guest I have.. I am also partial to the food because my nephew is a chef at Muscarellas. I also appreciate how the Patton family has given back to our community.. Thanks guys ..

Great food and survice. Warm family style atmosphere. The restaurant had several levels to accommodate a variety of needs. I had a steak that was offered for my group's party, and it was perfect. They had a variety of settings from a bar like atmosphere downstairs to casual dining on the 1st floor to a banquet hall upstairs.

My husband, my son and I went here and the food was amazing, the service was excellent and the whole restaurant was fantastic. Kind of crowded when we went but still an amazing experience and will definitely be returning for our anniversary.

Three Cheese Baked Ziti was solid 4/5. Great portion size, flavor and the server was great. I also had the Calamari & Zucchini as an appetizer. I would give that a 3/5, it was good, but not spectacular. Thank you.

We usually go here once a year for a special occasion and it never disappoints. The food is always delicious and there are so many options to choose from. They have the best cannoli around; it is a must-have! You will not be disappointed and it may be the best thing that has ever happened to you.

This was my first time here, the food was exceptional good, the interior is very elegant, it is much larger inside than what you see on the outside. I will definitely be returning to this restaurant. The pasta and sauce were as good as homemade.go see for yourself.

It is always a great experience going to Muscarella's. We had intended to go to a different restaurant initially, but decided on Muscarella's. The only negative for the night was the wait, and that was our fault for not calling ahead.
The food was great and the service was equally good. It is amazing how they do it when they are as busy as it usually is on Friday evening.
I would highly recommend Muscarella's, but make a reservation or call ahead.

I decided to try the steak vs salad tonight. Good choice! Their steaks are very tasty and combined with their sides I had a very good meal. I have not had a bad visit here. Only issue is they are so popular, it's hard to get a table or have a long wait. Make sure to do call ahead seating. Or don't so I don't have to wait as long!

Muscarella's has it all! Atmosphere, a fantastic menu and great food! We found out about Muscarella's via word of mouth from a stranger in a dept. store when asking about a good restaurant to go to for a wedding anniversary. We were surprised to get a recommendation for a restaurant that is 40 miles away from us in Sharpsville Pa.
We made the trip on a Thursday evening arriving at 6pm and had to wait about 10 minutes for a table to be ready as they were all occupied. Tip... when we left at 7 pm, about 1/3 of the tables were available so arriving a little after 6 might get you in with less or no waiting.
My wife had the Muscarella's Pasta Trio and I had the Sirloin Tips & Asiago Gnocchi.
Both meals were outstanding! The Sirloin tips were super tender and cooked to perfection. The Pasta trio was delicious!
We also had a cup of Wedding soup along with our meals, try it you will like it.
So.... Did we like Muscarella's? Absolutely! It is on the top of our favorite Restaurant list!

We always have a good meal here we drive an hour for it! Usually I stick with the lasagna and house made loose sausage but wanted to try out the butternut squash ravioli special. It was amazing. Loved the sage being sautéed with the squash. Also tried their crème brûlée for the first time it was perfect. Would also recommend their cannolis and the meat and cheese board.

OMG LAWD HAMERCY 😋😋😋 this is my husband's Hometown we are visiting from Vegas. We wanted to take my husband's friend to dinner, this is the place he chose. We will definitely return. I was so disappointed they were closed on a Monday because I had plans to come back the food was delightful the sangria was on point!!!! This was the freshest cod fish I've ever had just soft and Flaky. The mozzarella Patty was so good and the hot pepper stuffed with sausage was amazing!!! Everyone in there is friendly and welcoming. Loved our waitress Alaida

Place was packed and busy. Although incredibly busy the service was fast and food was phenomenal. One of the best dining experiences we have had in quite awhile.