Dutch Haven Shoo-Fly Pie Bakery

If you never tried Shoo-fly pie or a long time fan of Shoo-fly pie this is the place to get it. Their pie is excellent and made with real ingredients. They will offer you a sample of Shoo-fly pie that will make you want to buy a whole one. It is worth the stop.

We were welcomed with a smiling face and a delicious sample of shoofly pie! The Pecan pie we decided on was delicious.

This is one place you’ll want to stop while traveling Route 30 east. You can’t miss this iconic bakery known for its windmill shaped roof. It also has the best shoo-fly pie! When I arrived I was instantly greeted with a warm, freshly baked sample of the pie. They also have a nice selection of cookies, jams and jellies , and souvenirs.

As soon as I walked in I was greeted with an offer to taste their homemade shoofly pie which I happily accepted. This pie is so delicious there are no words to describe it. They have a variety of pies for sale including blueberry and peach and more. Dutch Haven is definitely a place to visit to purchase collectible-type items and souvenirs. I have to mention the amazing woodworking items that you can find here; benches, bird houses, cabinets, and rocking chairs, etc. all of which are locally crafted. Dutch Haven is easily accessible, located on Route 30 in Lancaster County, and worth the trip to buy their delicious pies!

Their Shoo-Fly pies are their No# 1 pies and their Pecan pies are their No# 2 top selling pies. I got a Shoo-Fly, Cherry and Chocolate Pecan pies. They were all delicious, and the Chocolate Pecan pie is my favorite. The store is unique. Majority of the store is filled with merchandise/souvenirs, and the pie counter is in the back where the register is. A couple of years later, I returned and got another chocolate pecan pie, and I also got a peach pie and root beer. The root beer was somewhat flat, and the peach pie reminded me of canned peaches in gelatin. It is definitely not my favorite. I baked the peach pie hoping the gelatin would melt, but it didn't seem to change much. While eating the pie, my stomach started feeling some discomfort and hours later, I got real sick. I'm not sure if it was the peach pie, but not taking any changes, I threw it out. I had the root beer the night before, and another glass while eating the peach pie. Not sure what happened. I will stick to the shoo-fly and chocolate pecan pies.

They don't have just shoo-fly pies, they have a lot of cool little things. Everything from little trinkets to furniture. If you want to try their pies, they do give free samples. They also have homemade root beer. The prices are a bit expensive probably because some things are handmade. It's definitely worth checking out if you're looking to buy a souvenir.

Awesome place for pies, we bought several, nice people too, and an awesome buffet restaurant next door, if your lookin for anything Amish this is a good place to stop

The best shoo fly pie I ever had! Thankfully they reopened after closing for a while! Get there before they sell the property and close down again!

Friendly staff, greeted as soon as I walked in. Got a free sample of their shoefly pie, probably the best thing I've had in a long while. Bought two full pies right after. Quick easy in and out, highly recommend them.

When going home, have to stop at the Windmill and get a shoe fly pie...and a few whoppie pies! So good! Still gives samples if you've never tried it!

We love this old place. The first place I have to visit when comming to Lancaster. Free Shoo Fly Pie, wounderful windmill building and childhood memories from 60 years ago. Pick up a Shoo Fly pie on the way out the door. I had to take my grandson here.

Nice place. if you like shoofly pie you will never find a better pie from what you will get here I almost guarantee it. Also there soft pretzels are kicking

Homemade furniture and some unique / homemade gifts mixed with your standard type souvenirs and gifts you would normally see. The best part is the homemade shoefly pies and assorted pastries! Also stronger than normal root beer :-) if the big windmill doesn't grab your attention as you're driving by then you need to turn around and go in and try some of the shoe fly pie!

Such a cool place. Many souvenirs to choose from. The Shoo-Fly pie and homemade root beer is a must try

Awesome. Beautiful Amish made souvenirs. Nice place. Great shoe fly pie. Must visit. People very nice and treat you nice.thank you for the great experience. We love our souvenirs

Interesting place. The pie is good! Lots of other goodies and souvenirs too. Check them out!

Tried Shoo Fly pie for the first time, and was a unique taste and experience! Glad we stopped, and the gentleman who waited on us was absolutely lovely!

5 Stars for the Shoo-fly pie. First time we ever had it and it was delicious. Yum.

They have homemade root beer and sweet butters, and the people that work there are super friendly and hospitality..

They were very friendly and had samples waiting as soon as we walked it. The pie is awesome!