O'Donnell's Pub

I cannot say enough about O’Donnell’s!
The food is delicious and the service is fantastic. We have two light eaters, so we decided to split a kids meal. Jamie knew this, cut the burger in half, and sent it out on two separate plates. The staff is always attentive to our needs and go above and beyond. We love O’Donnell’s!

PS - Do yourself a favor and start with the cheese sticks!

One of the best sweet potato fries we’ve ever had in a while. A cozy Irish pub in the middle of Conneslville with an incredible menu and a friendly staff. Five stars to the cook who prepared a gluten free pasta for my wife without being it in their menu—we provided the pasta and they made it. I had the glazed salmon and it was tasty as I expected.

We're riding the GAP. We ate on the deck watching the train switch yard. Service was very good. We had the deviled eggs, perogies, pork shank, salmon salad and steak dishes. Everyone was very pleased with the food. The deviled eggs are a must!

We had a fantastic time eating and drinking in the cozy front room of this pub restaurant. Angela was our awesomeserver. Her recommendations were spot on. I got the pork loin and it was every good as she said.
My friends Delmonico steak was delicious and cooked the way he loves it. I took one star off for atmosphere because the back room is definitely not as pleasant as the front/ bar.
The lights are brighter, also a bit noisy and doesn't have the same cozy vibe.
We walked over from the Comfort Inn, while cycling the GAP Trail. Highly recommend!

Came here most recently on my birthday and have eaten here about a dozen times, and I can say with full honesty: I have never had a bad experience here. The food is exceptional, especially the braised pork shank (image attached). I'd be hard-pressed to think of a bad thing to say about this place. 5/5 .... only because I can't give 6/5

This place is a real gem. The prices are reasonable and the food was fantastic. We had the pork shank, pasta alfredo, double pub burger, and filet tips with gorgonzola alfredo and all of them were absolutely 5 stars. If we're in the area again there is a 100% chance that we'll go back!

The CSX guy recommended this place since it was within walking distance for us, and man I'm glad I listened! I sat at the bar and the bartender was very engaging, attentive and informative. I got the Reuben and it did not disappoint! Check it out if you want a quiet place with great food!

Had dinner here while passing through town. Fantastic burgers, great staff, and classic pub atmosphere. Highly recommend.

What a nice restaurant here in Connellsville tucked away off the main drag. Food selections are great, try the pulled pork taco starter!! Great atmosphere, super clean. Friendly staff and free WiFi.

What an awesome place! The staff was very welcoming as if we were in their own home. The food was just as amazing! Great experience and can't wait to return next year!

I had a long and soaking ride on the GAP in the rain for 60 miles. I was given O'Donnell's Pub as a recommendation from the host of the B&B I was staying in. Man, were they right! I sat at the bar and the bartender, Lexi, was super sweet! I asked for her recommendation, and she (plus the servers) all said the filet special. It was incredible! Mushrooms and caramelized onions over a beautiful Pittsburgh rare filet! Top 2 I have ever had, crushed the chop houses like Mortons and Capitol Grill. I got the Chocolate Ganache Cheesecake to go. It is homemade and was to die for!

Possibly some of the best dinner food in connellsville. Everything was solid, down to the side of asparagus. Love this place. 🥰

Great food and good service and tge atmosphere is very nice!

Stopped on a whim on our way back from Ohioplye. Great service and food at a good price. Will definitely go back when in the area

Super good meal and Sue was amazing! Definitely a hidden gem!

Great food and competitive prices! We eat there often, and 4 out of 5 times no issues. Sometimes wait times are a little excessive.(45minutes+) Overall great place, though

The food is every bit of five stars if you're in the area I recommend this place with my whole heart. Awesome atmosphere and the wait was non-existent.

On a short trip and stayed in Connellsville, PA. Hotel recommended O’Donnell’s for dinner. We had a large group (8) and were seated promptly. Service was amazing, the food was incredible!!! I had the pork shank, fell off the bone, tender, juicy, decadent! Mashed potatoes were impeccable! Highly recommend! Everyone’s food came out at the same time, everything was hot and presentation was top notch!

This place really belongs in the Hamptons, the presentation of the food is beautiful and the menu is also, but it is so delicious. They wonderful staff is so fast and efficient, and they have a full bar to accommodate anyone. If you are in Connersville you must stop. You will not be disappointed. They are 5 star

This place is awesome! The service phenomenal! The food is great! The desserts are the best! Definitely the place to stop in Connelsville!