Pappy's Pizza & Subs

Take out only. The best white pizza I’ve ever had. Been ordering it for about 6 years now, no need to deviate. It is special. No other place makes it like they do. Will miss it (I am moving away). Do yourself a favor and check them out. Don’t let the “dive” exterior fool you. Their pizza is legit.

O my goodness o where have you been all life. This was by far the best takeout food in my 52 years on this planet. I got the Italian hoagie and my wife got chicken bacon ranch and she loved it. Cudos to this place for excellent food and the lady who took my call and the delivery lady was awesome

We ordered a taco pizza and it is amazing! Delivery was on time and the pizza was hot. We will definitely order this again❤

Top notch, home town pizza shop for many years. We've been regular customers for many years.
Very friendly service. Usually your order is done on time or sooner. Only had to wait a bit longer than specified time twice over all of the years because they were not happy with the quality of the pizza and was making a fresh one.
Most other shops would just dump a bit more cheese on it to hide their mistake.

Women owned and operated! They not only delivered great pizza and wings; they delivered awesome service too. The food was soooo good and the atmosphere is so nostalgic to a classic pizza shop!

I had an Italian Hogie. I got the large. Plenty of meat and 3 kinds of cheese. I could only eat half of it. It was heated slowly in a large oven. Delicious. Nice people there and they deliver. I have not tried the pizza, but plan to soon.

My only regret is not getting wings. Very timely delivery, delicious pizza, priced well. I highly recommend above other pizza shops in our area.

This is my new favorite pizza place! Wonderfully friendly service. Great white pizza. Reasonable prices for such tasty food. Would recommend!

We love there pizza and everything they are great people and for the price of a 30 cut pizza you cant beat it by the time you would buy a pizza for 5.00 and how many would you have to buy to equal that and its only 16.99 for it. We love ordering from there

Only place we get our pizza from. Get 2 & 3 topping pizza specials everyday!

I ordered a white pizza and a grilled chicken salad. Both were fantastic!!

Pappy's has made the most phenomenal white pizza for decades! This is the best pizza shop in the Fay-West region, hands down!

Got pizza and a ham hoagie. Both were delicious. Pappy's has the best prices around town

Best Taco Pizza in the world. Seriously though, I travel all across the country and no one else can touch their Taco Pizza. I also love the Italian hoagie.

Pizza was really good. Prices are reasonable. Glad we stopped here for the first time. We will definitely be back!

The pizza is always great. Have never been disappointed!

Great pie great service

First time trying this pizza. Was very good! Can't wait to try other things from this place

Staff always so nice especially the lady who runs it. It's clean there & pizza, etc yummy & fresh

Everything we have ever ordered is very good.And,when they give you a time to pick up you’re order, or if it’s being delivered they are always on time.