Tony's Pizzeria

Everything I have ordered has always been delicious. Very reasonable prices. Also must try and eggplant parmesan dinner. Fish and fries is delicious also!

Had a fantastic Stromboli! It was made fresh right there. I ordered a small but I could have (should’ve, but didn’t) split it with another. So good!

My Mom and I tried this place and we were so happy to have found a real Italian sub and pizza shop again. We did not have a place we loved for awhile and we will definitely be going back. Hot fresh calzone oozing with ricotta and my chicken parm sub was the fresh old school cornmeal bread. Nobody does it like this anymore.

Antipasta salad and a couple slices always satisfies! The homemade tiramisu is bangin'!

Love this place! Only place to get pizza in Middletown. The cheese steaks are great as well. I think they make their own bread and it’s sooooo good

Best pizza in town!! We picked this spot on a whim when we first moved to Middletown in 2019 after moving all day. We’ve tried every other pizza shop in town over the past few years and nothing compares. Also the best customer service out of every place in town! Never get a bad meal from Tony’s!

I live in Middletown and I am so happy we found Tony's pizzeria.
Service was great, food was ready within the time they said, and it is pretty darn tasty. Definitely sizes that leave you with leftovers.
My go to sub and pizza place!!

The cheesesteak and fries were really good and the staff were kind! I’ll definitely be back.

Very good food, had me an Italian sub toasted , the sub was nice and warm to my liking, and a slice of buffalo chicken pizza . Will recommend for quick bite to eat

I've been in the area for several weeks for training. I've eaten here on several occasions and have always really enjoyed my meal. The staff is very friendly and the food is great! Keep up the good work guys.

Hubby and I went there tonight for dinner. Very nice people that work there, absolutely delicious food and very huge portions. Huge huge portions. We got a gift card for my brother for his 50th birthday because that’s his favorite pizza joint. I see why. That place is awesome. Hubby and I are going to go back once a month or so, we live in Palmyra. Great job Tony and family 💖🥳👍🏼🙏🏼 Your girlfriend was very nice and sweet and kind! And prices are great as well.

These guys just stole my business from any other pizza joint in town. Anyone rating this place less than 5 stars doesn't know what real Italian food is. Meat Stromoli was AMAZING! Homemade sub rolls are huge, perfectly baked. Possibly the best veal parmesan sub I've ever eaten, not processed. Breaded mushrooms, cooked to perfection. I won't order from anyone else from here on out. I would have payed double for the quality of food I just got. 10/10 hands down
Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere

Best pizzeria I've ever been too best choice for specialty pizza and more!

Love this place and love the owner. She is the most down to earth person. Always polite and the food is great. They usually know what I am gonna order unless I switch it up. Please keep doing amazing . Your forever customer.

This has been my go-to pizza place in Middletown since 2019. It's 2023, and that hasn't changed. The sub rolls are fresh, soft, and delicious, and they for SURE don't skimp on the meat. I've had most all of their specialty slices, and they've all been stellar. I recently had them provide pizzas for a pizza party at my warehouse, and it was a smash hit. If you're anywhere near Middletown and looking for good Italian, you'll want to head to Tony's!

The best spicy chicken caesar wrapped ever. Never disappointed!!

I was here a few times a week for nearly 2 years, back in 2019-2020 for lunch, as I worked nearby. The folks inside are always pleasurable, the place has always been clean, and the food delicious. I recently started coming back as I'm working nearby again, and I have to say I've missed it.

Can't go wrong with any of the pizzas I've tried, and they've got the best french fries east of the Mississippi =)

Have to say I'm shocked to read some of these 1-star reviews, given that I've been in there ~100 times and have never had anything but a smile on my face when I leave.

Service was fast, everyone was kind, absolutely fantastic chicken cheese steak!!! The extremely large car memorbilia collection is fun to look at while you wait/eat

If you are looking for authentic Italian pizza, step right inside and you will see Tony hard at work making the best pizza that I’ve ever had. When you take the first bite, you will experience the crispy crust that only comes from someone who knows how to make good pizza. A single slice of pizza is very large compared to any other pizza shop around. I enjoyed the friendly family atmosphere and will continue to stop in for an amazing slice of pizza!

I have been to many pizza shops.. this is on my top 3 now. By far the best crust I've had. Only thing I suggest Is change up the decor.. bit odd walking in and seeing toys everywhere.