Penn Street Pizza

I'm new to the area and Google does not have my address pin right!! It is very confusing to get to me. The driver was so friendly, patient and kind trying to find me. The food is perfect!

Best Food in Town!! Try their barbecue chicken wings OMG! So good!

It was my first time ordering and the food was so good! I am definitely ordering again!

This place is AWESOME, despite the bad reviews. Yes it can take 45 mins for a carryout order, but come on, they have two single brick ovens! Brick oven pizza is so much better then all the other chain pizzas. Pizza is pizza, nothing to go writing home about. The wedges although, are fantastic and the best wedge I've had around! Best part of the place is the service. Perhaps some of the best service around town, can really tell pride is put into their work. I have been coming here for many years and will continue to do so, unless something drastically changes!

The best pizza we ever had in Butler!! The pizza was so delicious and with so many flavor could choose that we even visited the pizza shop twice in the same day! Guy who awnsered the phone was so kind and his voice was hot(kinda got me wet).Delivery boy was kinda cute, just wish i asked for those digits.

Got take out. Saw good reviews so decided to try it. Got pepperoni pizza and a steak and cheese wedge. We enjoyed both. I will be back.

Always great pizza and hoagies. Everything is handmade with quality ingredients from what I have tried. I order here regularly because I've come to expect carefully made and neatly crafted food for what I'd consider to be low prices, especially compared to what you get at chain restaurants. You're not paying for the name or a fancy lobby. That guy who gave 1 star because of a single hair seems unreasonable and must have had a bad day but the idea that domino's runs a cleaner establishment is laughable.

This, to me is this best pizza in the town of Butler. Locally owned, great toppings, and not too much doughy crust at the best price. The only pizza I've ever eaten without leaving crust on my plate.

Favorite pizza in town (ask for the fresh dough). Excellent nachos. Can't beat the wedgies. Haven't tried the gyro but my mom says she like them.

I tried the Fox's after they opened up in town shortly after PSP separated from the brand and I gotta say, Penn Street Pizza still wins.

My wife doesn't like PSP but she's wrong.

Always good food and reasonable prices

Amazing service and great food. The BBC wedgie and the nachos are by far the best in town! Love me some Penn Street Pizza! Plus Al is a pretty cool dude as well. Don't forget you can dine in! This is a Butler tradition!

First time we have tried Penn Street Pizza and we will NEVER get pizza or wings anywhere else. Garlic wings and barbecue were phenomenal and the pizza was amazing, done perfectly with loads of toppings. Staff and delivery driver very nice, Delivered exactly when they said. Great place, keep up the good work

Looking for pizza deals and wondering why you never see 50% off coupons for here? Consistency.

Why is dinner time hour to hour and half for delivery? Again consistency, no order is rushed to cut corners.

Make the time, order from a true local.

I ordered a pizza because I love foxes but I was afraid with the name change the pizzas would change. My pizza came quick and was perfect the best I've ever had, was hot and the driver was very nice. It was so good I called to thank them. They probably don't get calls for good only bad but this PIZZA WAS PERFECT THANK YOU ..." WEST PENN PIZZA"

Best beef bacon and ranch wedges& Taco pizza in this town!!! We get take out. It's probably a good thing we don't get delivery at our place though LoL I'd be ordering too much LoL

amazing! very clean, delicious food, kind employees and owner! best local pizza shop!

Love the place - our go to pizza shop!! They have excellent hoagies, wedgies, wings and appetizers. Have he best of both types of pizzas: the traditional shell pizza (I hear its their #1 seller) and their hand tossed fresh dough (my favorite). Their stromboli's are delicous and an amazing deal for the price - largest ones I've ever seen in Butler. Oh yea, don't forget the amazing taco pizza - I have several relatives that moved out of town and when they come to visit they make a point to get one while they're here!

Been eating Alan's pizza since I was like 2.. I never get tired of it. Best Salads and wedges around.

Every time I order I get great fast service. The food that I've ordered has been very good. No complaints here. Allen you're doing a great job.

Absolutely love their pizza. Owner is always extremely kind and the pizza is always hot and fresh.