L Pizza Plus

Very nice lady at the counter, Friendly Greeting when I walked in. I was buying pizza for 15 people. She suggested the Big Bertha and offered to have it delivered, or would take it out to my car for me. Pizza was very good and found the workers to be friendly.

The New Yorker ( bacon, pepperoni, and green peppers), Italian hoagie w/works ( small ), Steak & Cheese hoagie ( large ) and Fries with cheddar & bacon.
Everything was very delicious, and fresh! Tasted fabulous 👌

Haven't ordered from here in years and I have been missing out. My 🍕 was awesome! Bacon, pepperoni, mild pepper rings, sausage and ham. I highly recommend.

This was our first time ordering here and it was a very positive experience. Prices were very reasonable and a great deal. Pizza was big with lots of toppings and tasted great. Will definitely be ordering again! Also huge selection on menu

The food here is great. They have some killer deals too. I have ordered the pizza, bread sticks, and wedges and liked them all.

Showed up earlier this evening at closing time, and they were more than happy to still take my order. The Italian hoagie was toasted and fantastic. And the New York style pizza was great (Pepperoni, Mushroom, Green Peppers, and Meatball) . They even sprinkle parmesan cheese on the pizza before closing the box. It's the little things and attention to detail that makes places like this that much better. If you find yourself in the area, do stop in for a pie. Terrific service, delicious food, and great value. Fat kid tested, fat kid approved...

The Owner stopped by personnelly to fix a small mistake on an order. Great service!! Great pizza!!

I just got carryout. So, I couldn't say about the atmosphere. I don't think there is a dining room. However, the pizza was out of this world. Will definitely go back to try other food items.

Good here is ALWAYS on point snd never disappoints
Wings and pizza are a favorite go to along with snow fries

Fried appetizers are also excellent and are always hot on arrival. Delivery has always been much quicker than quoted or expected and in the many times we’ve had delivery have never had an issue with orders or driver.

Excellent local pizzeria that you absolutely should patronize!

The best pizza and customer service in the butler area hands down. Hats off to everyone that works hard to make such tasty pizzas at Pizza Plus! Keep it up!

We get the grand daddy pizza and cheesy bread sticks usually a couple times a week... And we LOVE them!! Not only is the food delicious, but the service is great and they are always fast!!! Our favorite pizza place in Butler for sure!!!

I’ve been going to this place for as long as I can remember. It started when my mom worked late on Fridays and dad had to make dinner so, naturally we got pizza and we never stopped that tradition to this day. Even now that me and my sister are in college we try to order from them. They’re an amazing group of people that try there hardest to make great pizza and they never disappoint. At this point they’re family.

After moving to Butler 3 yrs. ago, I was looking for a place with great Pizza and we Pizza Plus. They have different types of crust, endless toppings, appetizers, and even Italian Dinner selections, but I have to say that they probably have some of the Best Stromboli's and Calzones around. They are reasonably priced and the extra large will feed at least 2 people or make 2 meals. My daughter recently ordered an Italian Wedgie and son-in-law ordered a Hot Sausage Hoagie and they were both exceptional size and tasted great. If ever in the area and looking for a great casual meal, I definitely say to give them a try. The only downfall is they are not open on Monday or Tuesday, like many restaurants in the Butler Area and Monday always seems to be the night I want an easy dinner option. Give them a try and I am sure you will be pleasantly satisfied.

This is the best pizza that I have had by far. An older gentleman delivered my order today, he saw that I had dogs (crazy barking dogs) and he gave them some pup sticks, which are their most favorite treats.

Man, it is so hard to find a GOOD local pizza shop and I can say is that I did.
Had a half Italian baked hoagie. Very good bread and all the usual fixings.
Also had a small pepperoni pizza. And that was very good too. A good sauce and cheese.
The dough spot on
While I am working in the area I'll make sure to get back here a couple more times.
A very good find.
And yea,the folks there were pretty cool too.
Butler's lucky to have an awesome pizza spot.

I cried when this place got sold and cried when they reopen. My all time favorite place for pizza and that's coming from someone who went to grimeos in NYC. Top notch would give more stars if I could. Keep up the amazing work guys🤙

We ordered pizza for a 12:45 pm pick up and it was just coming out of the oven at 12:44 - meaning our pizza was fresh, hot and ready when it was supposed to be! The employees were super-friendly as well!
Well done!

Small hole in the wall with phenomenal pizza. The Sicilian style was so light and not bready. The sauce is divine!!! The service and the people are top notch and do their job well and work like a well oiled machine.

My favorite pizza place in town. Delivery drivers are friendly in a professional way and always courteous. Food is consistently fresh, hot and high quality.

I stood there, patiently waiting for my Cajun Wings to be completed. The older man, in his 60's greeted me with a smile among the moving pieces of oven doors opening, fridges closing, customers calling, drivers collecting orders... I sat there and watched a Symphony performed by 7 or 9 people...

I heard the names of Pizza being called, "Big Daddy, Pepperoni, Cheese... a few minutes more." I watched the 1/2 Sausage and 1/2 Pepperoni being slathered with love and a secret sauce that I wanted a cup to drink. They were moving in a syncopated rhythm that was created by silent noise of hungry families in Butler.

I have yet to taste one of these delicious pizza... much to my chagrin, I ordered a salad and wings (delicious)...But watching the magic Pizza Plus creates was worth more than 5 stars... I learned to order the pizza and skip the salad...

Thanks for creating an enchanting moment on a cold Friday in Butler.

A forever Customer....