Bethel Bakery

The best burnt almond cupcakes and more! I stop by this bakery often when I am in the area since we live an hour away. It is always a treat! I bring trays of assorted cupcakes to friends from this place and they love it. 😃

I LOVE bethel bakery!!! They always do such a fantastic job with our cakes 🎂 I had one made back in 2021 for my grandmas birthday and it turned out beautifully! I recently placed an order for my daughters 7th birthday and it was so beautiful and so yummy! You guys rock! 🩷🩷🩷

Got the most beautiful summer cake for a late birthday family get together. It was fresh and moist and so beautiful! We also got the chocolate drop cookies for the first time! They are absolutely sinful but delicious!! They will be a go to of sorts now!! Another trip got my boys bday cake!! Great decorating skill!! We loved it!! And its delicious as well!!

We had a chocolate cake with caramel buttercream as our wedding cake, and we were absolutely thrilled with the outcome!! The service was outstanding and they did a wonderful job placing the flowers we gave them on our cake. Totally recommend Bethel Bakery!!

Super friendly customer service. Clean and big open area. Huge array of cookies and cakes. Tastes amazing, great prices. Highly recommend.

We loved how they did the cake tasting - they gave us cupcakes in each flavor as well as each flavor of filling to try different combinations. We ended up choosing the lemon cake with European Raspberry and mango fillings because they were delicious and our favorite. We then sent them reference photos of our ideas for the cake and they crushed it! I almost cried seeing the cake on the wedding day as it was absolutely perfect. Please go to Bethel for your baked goods needs! They are wonderful, professional, and so talented - and also delicious!

We used Bethel Bakery as our cake vendor for our wedding! The entire process, with Jess, was seemless. She brought our vision to life in cake form, in an affordable manor! Jess is the best cake designer we know!

We had Bethel Bakery make our wedding cake, and we couldn't have been happier with the service. Their at home tasting option was the nicest that we tried, the person who did our online consultation was great to work with, and everything was delicious!

Unfortunately, we did have an issue with the cake itself. It arrived...basically in pieces. The delivery driver was in tears. Thankfully, our coordinator was able to largely salvage it, and Bethel Bakery, to their credit, could not have handled the mistake any better. They assured us that the cake and delivery charge would be free, and immediately followed up with an email the first thing the next morning, telling us to give them a call whenever it was convenient for us.

When we called they were VERY apologetic, offered to make us a free anniversary cake, and even said they could decorate a fake cake, take it to our venue the next time they were there, and get pictures for us so that we could see what it should have looked like. We declined the fake cake photoshoot, but we were very impressed by the offer.

Sometimes, accidents happen. What makes all the difference is how the company addresses the mistake. Bethel Bakery immediately took responsibility, and then went above and beyond to try to make things right. We truly appreciated their dedication to customer satisfaction, and we would not hesitate to use again for future cakes.

We purchased our wedding cake, cupcakes, and cookies here. Everything was amazing and totally worth the price. The employees are very friendly and helped us a lot when we were deciding on cake design and size. Would definitely recommend!

My wife and I recently tied the knot, and we had the pleasure of partnering with Bethel Bakery for our wedding cake. From the moment we walked into their shop, we knew we were in for a treat. The entire experience, from consultations to the final product, was truly exceptional. Our cake was FABULOUS and most importantly, delicious!!!! Look no further from wedding cakes to even amazing cookies for your cookie table, Bethel Bakery knows what they are doing and you will be in such great hands!

Wowza!!! This place is AMAZING!
I had to come here for work reasons and I’m not sorry I did. Mandy was wonderful. All of the staff was very friendly. I will be coming back here quite often! 😍

As always my phone service and visit there was A+. Love their baked goods and have a wide and wonderful selection of everything. That is amazing given it was the day before Christmas Eve. Our entire extended family is always so very with orders we place. This time I walked in with only hopes they had something left. Again, not surprisingly, they still had a wide selection for me to choose from. The service has never been less the quick and pleasant

A very nice place to go in Bethel Park. You will always encounter a nice group of customers there and an even nicer group of workers. My friend, Josh, worked there and said it was an amazing work environment. The goods there are very good. Personally, my favorite item is the cluster of cinnamon rolls. One of the best bakeries i've ever been too. I have been going there ever since I was very young and the quality has not changed ever since. Kudos to Bethel Bakery. Truly a Five-star-worthy bakery.

We ordered cupcakes and a smash cake for my daughters spring/bunny themed birthday party and everyone loved them! The icing is fluffy and not too sweet and the cupcakes were super soft. Bethel bakery is such a gem in our community- so blessed to have them!!

Wonderful experience above and beyond, we got such a wonderful cake for our sons first birthday 🎂

Since I can't leave another review I'll edit my first one: Bethel Bakery did it again! They made a wonderful 1st birthday cake amd smash cake for my daughter and it was exactly as I envisioned it. And it was delicious! Thank you for making our kids first birthdays special, Bethel bakery!!!

We used Bethel Bakery for our wedding cake + some cookies. We had a great experience with them from beginning to end. We were able to pick up samples of icings and cakes to try at home, then discuss with a member of their wedding team via Zoom the next day. We picked yellow cake with vanilla and cookies and cream fillings, and it was SO good. We had so many people comment on how much they liked the cake (and we loved it, as well). For display, we got a two-tier wedding cake. We had the Bethel Bakery team decorate it simply with a spatula to smooth down the sides and a bead border. We had our planner add flowers at the venue. We got two back-up cakes to make sure all the guests could be served. Their serving estimates were pretty spot-on. We only ended up with about half a cake to take home (which is not a problem - more cake for us). I picked up our cake and delivered it to our caterer the day before our wedding. Everything was packaged well and easy to transport. Every interaction I had with their team members was great, very friendly and helpful. Now that I've gotten a taste, I will definitely be coming back for more whenever we need baked goods!

We got our wedding cake and cookies from Bethel. The staff was very attentive from the beginning. We had a tye dye wedding reception and wanted a perfect cake to match. They did a beautiful job and the cake was delicious. We went with the white cake and raspberry filling. The cookies were also a huge hit. Thank you so much Bethel Bakery!

Placed an order for a birthday cake last week. Hunter did an amazing job helping me pick out the cake and flavors. Trust the experts! Looking forward to trying the blueberry buttercream!

This was such an amazing bakery, so full of delicious sweets. If you are a last minute person & need a tasteful and beautifully decorated bakery item, this is your go to place! Guests will never know that you didn’t preorder something 😉

We had a lovely experience at Bethel Bakery’s Wedding Cake Shop. The inside feels like the wedding area of Disney’s Grand Floridian Resort & Spa. Samantha is fantastic to work with. At our tasting we loved the European Raspberry filling and the cherry mousse.