Elizabeth's Pizza & Restaurant

First time at Elizabeth's and was very impressed. The staff was friendly and accommodating. Orders are taken at the kitchen counter, but when we arrived, we were not yet sure what we wanted to order. So the wait staff offered us extra menus to look at and said we could sit down and take our time. We ordered the Deluxe and Vegetarian. I asked if I could substitute the eggplant on the Vegetarian with spinach, and they said I could. The pizzas are thin Brooklyn style. The Deluxe was delicious. They add basil to the pizza which added a nice pep to the pizza. The veggie was very good as well. Both were very cheesy. There is also a bar and dessert / coffee shop attached where you can order alcohol. So if you like beer with your pizza, it is convenient. Definitely recommend.

This pizza was THE BEST PIZZA i have ever tasted in my life woahhh it was FRESH right crunch perfect crust TEN OUT OF TEN (i was also high sooo lol)

I’m am very happy with this place! Tonight was my husbands and I first night trying this place.The pizza was cooked to perfection! The garlic knots are amazing!!!! Most of all they have amazing customer service. If you are thinking of getting food here you will not be sorry.

The Elizabeth Pizza on Skibo has the best pasta! Better than Carabas and most definitely better than the Elizabeth Pizza on Hope Mills Road. You can tell the chef takes alot of care into his cooking here. Lots of flavor! If you want a nice Latte and dessert the connected Cafe at Dolce Aroma is amazing! They will not disappoint!!

Absolutely the best pizza in town! Highly recommended if you want to try an authentic Italian pizza. Great job Tony

Oh my, this is the best pizza in town, bar none! The service is excellent especially compared to the volume of people that they serve. Tony, the owner is there every day, making sure the quality, cleanliness and service is at it's best. I have tried everything on the menu here, that is how often I visit and reflects how tasty everything is. My favorite choices include just a plain cheese pizza and a side of zucchini sticks! As I am writing this, I can't stop thinking about it and I am going to order a to go now! Enjoy.

Thus was our first time here and I can wait to take my kids next time. The food was really good and hot and fresh. Our server was friendly and attentive.
It was an overall great experience and I can wait to go back.

Great food, large portions, and good prices! Our server was very attentive, accommodating, and took great care of us. Will definitely be back!

Great pizza, strange place to eat in , nobody was eating in and one side of the restaurant was stacked with pizza boxes. But, will return when I get a chance.

We love Elizabeth’s pizza! It’s the only place in Fayetteville we get our Italian fix from.

Nothing fancy about the restaurant itself. But grown up in New England, this is the type and taste of pizza I'm used to and love.

Moved to Florence SC from CT. Been here for 2yrs now and I often travel between the Carolinas. Pizza is my #1 All Time Favorite food. Coming from the home of Pepe's, Modern and Grand Apizza of New Haven. I find it tough to find pizza I enjoy here (And I have given quite a few different places a try....)Until today! I just happen to be staying at the hotel across from the plaza and came to buy some yarn from JoAnn Fabrics. Searched for take out near me not even sure what I had a taste for. Elizabeth's came up in my search and being a pizza lover how could I refuse?!
The cheese is perfect, the sauce is perfect and the only I would do differently is request my crust well done.
The store was clean and the staff was also very friendly. If you are anywhere near the Fayetteville area I promise you it's worth the drive. Very delicious and overall satisfied 😁

Delicious pasta with gluten free options. Great service. Would definitely recommend.

Great place to eat service is great and staff is friendly. Had the Hot Sausage and pepper sandwich it was delicious. Shout to Maria great job!

I’ve heard great things about their pizza, but never tried it until this past week. We didn’t have any idea how massive their pizzas were so we ordered 3 larges and a side salad. They must’ve thought we were having a small get together or something lol.

The restaurant was spotless and so pretty on the inside. Definitely haven’t seen anything like it before in Fayetteville. The man working the counter/phones, Giuseppe, was very polite and professional.

The pizza was so good. The best hands down in Fayetteville. Plus, for the amount of food you get it’s pretty reasonable. Will definitely be regulars here

I love the lunch special, pizza is always fantastic!

Have always loved this place. First off, all Elizabeth Pizza locations are the CLEANEST restaurant you will ever find. Spotless. I have been in the back of most in Fayetteville and they are all clean as a whistle. The calzone and house salad we just split were spectacular. Ingredients and recipes matter. The food here is just awesome.

We ordered takeout. The lady who answered the phone was very prompt and polite. Pickup was easy. The food was AMAZING. I don't think I'll ever go to Carrabas or Olive Garden again!! Portions were perfect and prices are fair. Can't believe I have not tried this place sooner!

Ordered on a Saturday around 4 pm. Estimated time for pick up was 45 mins and it was accurate! Pizza was delicious! Fresh ingredients an the crust was perfection! Medium was huge and for the price you can’t beat it!

The cheese and grease that drips off of the slices are what is best about Elizabeth's. You can tell the ingredients are fresh and they always have your pizza ready for pick up when you get there. The big slices make it feel like true New York style! Even keeps in your fridge for awhile!