Captains Amish Store

Alot of cool stuff! It's bigger than it looks when you get inside. You can find just about anything you want in there.

I love this place. Always great stuff to look through. Love the sweet lady that works there.

Only thing Amish is the name.

Charged half price for hitting my head!

On a road trip to New Albany for a wedding, along Hwy 45 we stopped to look at a really cute food and flea market something we like to do. Help support local businesses while traveling through our state. Soon entering they had really nice cute exterior rocking chairs. One I was really interested in purchasing so I sat in it to try it out. It was more of an antique older chair. I’m small and only weigh 100lbs. The back of the leg broke which caused me to fall back, hit my head on metal grocery carts behind the chairs, hit my arm on this large wooden desk, scratched my leg on the chair, as well as my skirt flying up. As soon as this happened the employees rushes out rips the tag off of the chair and said “looks like you got yourself a chair.” Not at any point was she concerned about my well-being, there were no signs that we saw of on the property that said “no sitting on chairs” which will have one think that they are alright with you sitting in the chairs and can support average weights. We proceed to spend the next 45 minutes in the store in which we all purchased something of $20 or more. At checkout she rang me up for half price of the chair for being broke and claimed she was being nice… they obviously aren’t nice enough to be concerned enough for their customers well being by putting unchecked broken chairs in the front of their store and selling for high prices $70. Which couldn’t even support a small weight. It’s a chair, I understand the “break it you buy it” but I should have been able to sit in it before buying without it breaking. Anyone could have came along to try the chair out, what if it had been an elderly person and not me. Or my pregnant friend with me could have took the fall. I’m sure the lady wouldn’t have been overly rude then. If your going to put a price tag on a usable item it should be previously inspected and removed from a sitting area. There was also a camera which will clearly would show there was no horse play. It’s also not worth the stop if your looking for fresh real Amish products and not Amish employed. They were all imported from out of town, kept in a freezer or molding on the shelf. We had no where to fit the chair, as we are traveling out of town. The women didn’t even remove the chair from the front porch so be cautious when visiting you may be the next to fall!

This is NOT an Amish market. It’s hot and stinks like old musty houses. They have a few items that they have bought from the Amish and are reselling but using that to lure you in. This is just a flea market