Italian Carry Out

Simply put - everything is great!
My favorite meal in town is the Flying Squirrel sub. First - all subs are made with Ithaca bakery bread and they're frankly the best sub rolls I've ever had. The Squirrel specifically is a a Philly cheese sub and a Buffalo chicken sub on one roll. (I also recommend adding bacon). They have several wing sauce options to pick from, but I love their traditional 'hot'.

They also make some really great pizzas and they have a ton of options for them. Wings are fantastic and lots of options. Employees are always friendly and helpful. To boot, they have free delivery to the Ithaca area!

Oh yeah - the I in ICO, they have fantastic Italian options and easily the best sauce in town. Highly recommend the raviolis' and an order of the giant meatball.

The Cornell Hockey Association ordered cheese lasagna, and chicken & broccoli casserole for 100 guests for our Afterglow after the game against Quinnipiac .
The food was excellent and it was a pleasure to work with the ICO employees. I totally recommend them for your carryout needs!

A little bit of a wait. Full 30 minutes or so. But I got free slice of pizza as they were closing and only 2 left to choose from. Ordered chicken sandwich. With the pizza, saved half for the next day, which was still good! Also enjoyed some garlic knots with Marinara. The food was delicious! If I lived local, I would be back there again this weekend.

Double dough, pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, probably the BEST pizza we have ever had from Italian Carry Out. Full of toppings, cooked just the way we asked for it to be. Outstanding! Excellent job Jim!! Thank you Tyler and the whole gang. KUDOS

Loved the lasagna and the pizza was good too. The pizza portion, 2 slices and a drink for $5, was huge. The Greek salad with feta and olives was fresh and tasty. I'd be glad to order any time we are back in Ithaca.

If I could give this business and family 10 stars I would. Their chicken wing pizza is out of this world! Their salads are fresh and they use kalamata olives in their Greek salad, unlike other pizzerias whose salads are usually disgusting, and the grilled chicken is really juicy too! Their home made blue cheese is to die for, and I usually am not even into blue cheese but I’ve ordered pints of this stuff. Their fish sandwich is delicious, and their home made meatball sub is mouthwatering! I love this place and everyone I know does too. They’ve been a true staple to the community and a mom and pop shop doesn’t get better than this! Thank you to the Salino family for everything you do for this community and always being the top choice for what you offer!

Best pizza in the region by far! They’re also the go to option for wings, bomb hot subs, crazy chicken parms, and killer salads. If you’ve never had ICO order it NOW and get extra blue cheese, thank me later!

Best pizza and wings in the Ithaca area!! Great customer service also.

Simply the best pizza! And amazing people!!!

Used to be able to dine in..now only take out..food great..as usual!

Coming to ICO for 30 years when I visit Ithica. Same great food as ever.

Is there a sixth star? The "squirrel" pizza with their homemade blue cheese dressing has become my favorite pizza around. Great food and staff!

Gotta eat a great chicken Parm sub at least once a week.

Beyond fantastic! Food was delicious, very large portions, staff was friendly and prompt! Meatballs the size of my fist! Will definitely be back and would highly recommend!

The staff here are some of the most genuinely warm people, making their service next level and “at home”. Quality of product is outstanding, with all we ordered fantastic. The crust, cheese and sauce ratio was perfect. I applaud mangement and the team who works there. Not many establishment take pride like this where it is reflected at all levels.

I asked for a pizza recommendation, and two folks sent me here. Glad I listened. The pie was very good and the price was reasonable.

Love ICO!! We probably get take out from here every week. Friendly staff. The food is always fresh, made to order, and so delicious! Everything we try, we love. They also use wonderful local bread for their subs! The online ordering system is user friendly and allows you to select the options you want and/or add a note for a more specific request. They also have an active social media presence, which is great to keep customers posted on important info. If you haven't tried ICO, you should! 😊

Best pizza and wings in the Ithaca area by far. Never disappoints!

This is by far the best pizza in town. Nothing beats their pizza with the sauce on top of the cheese! The wings are to die for. Order the wings with Golden Sauce, and get the homemade bleu cheese to dip em in! Can't beat it, I promise you.

But in reality the best part about this place is they are a local family-run business. These guys mean so much to our community. They are always taking part in local benefits and always donating their food and time to local causes. You don't see the chain pizza places taking part in our community like these guys.

We need more businesses like this in our neighborhood. Thanks for being here guys and keeping me fed. Best pizza place in town!!!

The lasagna was terrific. Very good portion size. Super friendly staff. I didn't realize they closed at 9pm when I called to order pickup at 8:52pm. They were exceedingly polite and accommodating. Definitely a 5-star experience all around. Will certainly be back.