Cosentino's Ristorante

After a beautiful Thanksgiving with family we opted to skip the leftovers and go out for dinner on Black Friday. We made a great choice! Billy Cosentino greets and seats you with a smile. The staff are friendly and the food was fabulous! The calamari was spicy, eggplant Parmesan filling, the haddock Alaska was a nice light bite, and the chicken piccata perfection. I strongly recommend this restaurant any time of year.

The wait staff made me feel so special, very attentive, courteous, hardly had to ask for anything because they already knew what I may need before it got too low, I.e. bread, drinks, water, coffee. The prices weren’t that bad either. The food was absolutely amazing, the music was spot on & not too loud. Very upscale without the turned up noses and high prices. I will be a repeat customer!!!!

My partner and I came here for a Valentine's weekend dinner. We got the fried calamari and whipped ricotta with tomatoes and garlic on top for appetizers. Both of those were absolutely fantastic. My partner got the braised short rib with mashed potatoes and a lobster tail. I got the lobster ravioli (they were heart shaped!) with vodka sauce. Both of us really enjoyed our meals. I had gotten a smoked bourbon old fashioned. It was very strong and the fruit was not muddled so I was not very satisfied with it. But our amazing waitress, Sheila, was able to give me an amazing recommendation of the Love Potion and I really enjoyed it. She was very kind and did an amazing job taking care of us. I would highly recommend you come here and we'll be back when we're in the area again!

My wife and I enjoyed a lovely evening dining together at this establishment. From the start, the staff was friendly and courteous. They also assisted us with finding various businesses throughout Geneva. The food was spectacular! The portions were large. The seafood was prepared perfectly, upscale food with a relaxing atmosphere. I highly recommend this Italian restaurant when visiting Geneva.

Really good Italian good. I had the rigatoni bolognese and it was excellent. My husband gets the manicotti and he loved it. Our server Sophia was wonderful. We will be back.

My GF and I came to Seneca for a weekend of wine tasting. Our Airbnb host recommended Cosantino's and I'm glad they did. We ordered the calamari and it was hand down the best I ever had. Light, crispy, little bit of heat. The garlic aioli and light tomato sauce was full of flavor. I ordered seafood caprese and she ordered veal francaise and a nice bottle of Cab Franc. Huge portions and well presented. Reasonably priced too.

When deciding on a place to eat the next night when our friends arrived we were so impressed that we went back. Night 2 I had the Chicken Parm, she had the Eggplant Parm, our friends had Stuffed Salmon and Fettuccine Alfredo. Oh and we had the Calamari again. Big portions yet again left no room for dessert.

If I'm splitting hairs the only complaint I have is soft room temperature bread served with hard cold butter. No biggie but warmed bread or bread served with olive oil with herbs would be a nice touch.

We drive to the fingerlakes 4-5 times a year. Cosantino's will now be our "Go-To".

Every time we come to the Finger Lakes we stop here for dinner and are never disappointed! The Chicken Parm is SO good and they give you enough food that you have leftovers that are easily another whole meal. The staff are really friendly and the atmosphere is cozy and welcoming! Definitely recommend if you love Italian food!

Visited on Wednesday "Steak Night" - 12oz New York Strip, baked potato and a salad for $17. Not the best steak I ever had, but definitely a good one. Cooked perfectly for me. My better half had the haddock, also cooked perfectly. Our sever was great, friendly and very attentive. The only negative thing was we had to wait awhile to be seated.

I had my Christmas party at the restaurant and it was great. The food was delicious and the service was great as well. This was the second time I had my Christmas party here and look forward to next year's party.

Great food. Any time we in wine country we stop here for dinner. Wish I lived closer if I did we would go once a week. Keep up the great work. Very friendly wait staff.

Excellent food and really reasonable prices. A bottle of wine a craft beer and two entrees was under$80. The server was pleasant and the bartender was super friendly.

This is a must visit restaurant. The food is absolutely delicious. It takes a little more time but that is only because it is made fresh. Quality takes time. I’ve been here twice in a few days and have not been disappointed at all. I will be back.

LVCFH team and families from PA truly enjoy our dining experience in this wonderful restaurant! They accommodated our large group once again for a spectacular meal! We appreciate you and can’t wait to see you again next year!

We recently had a family get together at Cosentino's and it was my first time there. How did I not know about this place for all the years I've lived here? First, it's a beautiful restaurant. My brother had made reservations and there was about a 5 minute wait to be seated. I'm really picky with food but I found lots of things on their menu that looked so good. I went with the Chicken Piccata and it was delicious! The best I've ever had. Everyone in our party enjoyed their meals. The salads and fresh bread they served was also so good. Our server was very friendly and attentive. I thought their prices were in line with other similar restaurants. I'm craving their chicken piccata so I will need to make another trip there real soon.

We are staying one night in Geneva, NY and decided on Italian. Cosentino’s was the perfect choice!

The service was great. Our server was bright, polite and happy. Drinks and food were both served in an appropriate amount of time.

Our food was excellent. The menu had very interesting choices for both appetizers and entrees.

We split the stuffed pepper appetizer. It was perfectly spicy and plenty for two. The sauce was delicious with bread.

Our entree was chicken piccata with a few twists. First, the chicken was boneless skinless thighs and instead of pasta, it was polenta.

It was one of the top three Italian meals we’ve ever enjoyed. The sharpness of the sauce was delicate but sassy. It had a wonderful creaminess. Large green olives, red pepper, artichokes and capers were all happy accents. The thighs were large and meaty, cooked perfectly. The only improvement I’d suggest is a creamier polenta, it was just a tad mealy but no point deduction!!

We would definitely eat here again.

We were visiting from Florida to see my brother. He wanted to go there. It was so good. Plenty of food. Waitress was very personable, and right there when we needed something. I tried other places during my stay and nothing compared to Cosentino's.

The server was great. She kept checking us to see if we needed anything or if the food was OK. I highly recommend making reservations. The food was delicious, and you get a lot of food for your money. Nice, family atmosphere. Will definitely be going again!! I highly recommend for anybody looking for a nice restaurant to eat a great meal!

Me and my friend visited this restaurant when drove from WatkinGlen to Rochester for dinner..Though we weren’t had an active reservation, owner was so kind and arranged table for us. Our table#1. Server Juo was awesome and humble. Food was delicious..Chicken Picatta was simply lovely…We definitely recommend this place to ItalianCuisine like ra and lovers.

Appetizer of calamari was delicious, very tender. Chicken parm was also nice and tender and the red sauce hearty, thick and delicious. Seafood Caprese was very good. Shrimp, scallops, lagostinos in a very light tomato broth with fresh mozzarella. Seafood was cooked to perfection not overcooked or undercooked. Dessert was creme brulee which again was very good, traditional dish. Excellent service.

This was my first time here, but I will definitely be going back! The service was excellent, and the food was even better. The ingredients seemed fresh. I'm no food critic, but the flavors were amazing! I experienced flavor combinations and textures that I never have before - in a good way! They offer a wine list and other drinks. The tables were candle-lit. There's an outdoor dining area that I intend to try in the near future. It was very clean. The customers were pretty loud, so that made hearing my date a little difficult. However, it wasn't a rowdy type of loud. It was just people actually talking to each other and enjoying a good meal. I didn't see one cell phone out the whole time we were there. I was too full for after-dinner coffee and dessert, but I plan on going back just for that. This was a great place for a date. I highly recommend Cosentino's!