Cayuga Lake Creamery at The Dewitt Mall

Ice cream is creamy and delicious. The place is cutely decorated. I also love that there are tables to sit on

The absolute BEST ice cream I’ve ever had hands down. I went here many times when I was a student in Ithaca. I live in NYC now, but I still dream about this ice cream..

Forgot my wallet and I had to run across to get it, I come back fifteen minutes until closing and they still have it for me! And holy motherload the hot fudge was generous, which I liked!

Delicious cones and ice cream with splendid service!

Great ice cream, creamy and many flavors. Recommend!!

Stopped here with a large church group on Sunday. Ice cream was delicious. Cayuga Lake Creamery offers some unique flavors that aren't even listed on their website. ;)

I would definitely recommend stopping by if you're looking for some tasty ice cream.

Friendly and courteous staff. Offer samples. Seating available inside and outside. Traditional and unique flavors.

Great old school ice cream. Big servings, creamy, lovely. Nice patio out back to enjoy it on.

Apart from Cornell dairy bar, this is one of my most favorite local ice cream shops in Ithaca! My experience at Purity was average and kinda lost faith in humanity after several ppl recommended Sweet Melissa’s ice cream. But this place again restored my faith in local ice cream shops. Went twice within a week, loved both flavors I tried (coconut almond fudge and berries jubilee). The place is so nice and the staff are great. Helped my friend with their choice of vegan icecream, queried about their concern for cross contamination! So helpful and respectful to the customers!
Update: I visited again recently and the ice cream fell off my hand while paying the bill. The staffs were so nice that they immediately offered me a replacement! Really love how helpful and cooperating they are 💛

This is probably one of the best ice cream shops in Ithaca (better than Purity and Sweet Melissa’s, maybe even Cornell Dairy). Ice cream is very creamy, and there are a lot of interesting flavors to try. I regret not signing up for the Scoop rewards because I’ve already been here 3 times.

Flavors I enjoyed: blueberry cheesecake, busy bee/coffee, cherry jubilee, seneca salt

This place is absolutely amazing! Where should I start!! Ok first of all they were closed but they opened the doors for us to come in and order!!! My son has growing pains and his knees were killing him but he had to make it there for the ice cream that we heard was the best!!! So thank you very much for serving him his favorite ice cream!! Second, the ice cream is outrageous! We’ve been on vacation all week eating ice cream every night and this was the best ice cream event!! Fresh and creamy!! So upset I don’t live here to have it all the time!!!

This ice cream shop smells amazing and has tasty ice cream! They also have seating! Do recommend!

Cute little local ice cream shop with delicious flavors. They'll pack pints to go for you, and they'll do a really good job getting as much ice cream in there as possible.

Where else can you get jalapeño ice cream. It was good.

Yum. Great outdoor patio too!

Yummy and valuable! There are real pistachios inside!

Best ice cream in town. Amazing flavors w quality ingredients and homemade waffle cones even a waffle dish! I only wish they were open Monday’s and Tuesday’s.

Delicious flavors and the gelato is very very very creamy! Definitely made fresh in the house with excellent dairy!

awesome ! waffle cones are amazing, ice cream flavors are unique and i've yet to try one i didn't like. staff is always very helpful as well :)

This is the best ice cream in Ithaca! It’s rich and creamy. Too bad I didn’t take a photo. I will definitely be back!

Fantastic vegan options. The NSA-FF chocolate (no sugar added fat free) was particularly great. Dark chocolate.