Mike's Pizza & Steakhouse

I had an amazing Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo!! Super fast and great service even though they were busy. Obviously scratch made. I’ll be back next time I’m in town. Can’t wait to try the pizza it looked good going past. Shaun was a perfect server.

Went in fairly early for supper. Told to sit where we wanted. Brewed a fresh pot of coffee for us. Waiter was great. Food out quickly and it was awesome. Artichoke and shrimp pizza. Mozzarella sticks were great too. Always a homerun....

Had sangerias - so delicious! Tenderloin and fries were absolutely perfect. Table had steak sandwiches and bacon cheeseburger, all was excellent. Waitress was very busy but handled the crowd like an expert. Thanks for making my first trip to Mike's a delight. Should've taken better pictures. 😄 Highly recommend.

I've tried the calzone a couple times, and it was very good both times. The waitress was friendly and attentive. The cheeseburger was reported to be good by my lunch companion, too. The building is a former Mexican restaurant, so it isn't elegant dining, but if you're hungry in Ottumwa, give Mike's a try.

Great food! Our first time there, but we are definitely going back.
Pizza it's amazing and their fettuccine Alfredo was delicious.
Great and fast service.

A Slice of Iowa's Finest: An Ode to Pizza
For pizza aficionados in Iowa, an exquisite slice is a rare jewel. Unfortunately, the state's pizza landscape is littered with pies that are overly salty, lack freshness, or simply miss the mark when it comes to the authentic pizza experience. The search for that perfect balance of flavorsome sauce, well-proportioned toppings, and a crust that's just right can seem like a never-ending journey. Yet, amid this landscape, Mike's Pizza and Steakhouse shines as a beacon of hope, consistently delivering pizzas that not only satisfy the palate but also capture the heart.
As I stepped into the restaurant, I was immediately greeted by the tantalizing aroma of baking dough and melted cheese – a scent that was as comforting as a warm blanket on a cold winter's night.
Each pizza at Mike's Pizza and Steakhouse is a symphony of flavors, harmoniously working together to create a gustatory masterpiece. The crust strikes a delicate balance between crispy and chewy, and as for the toppings – well, let's just say they're generous enough to make a decade-long feud between pineapple and non-pineapple pizza lovers look like a light disagreement. The cheese is as rich and indulgent as a billionaire on a shopping spree, and the sauce – oh, the sauce! It's a tomato-based love letter to anyone who appreciates the finer things in life.
The pepperoni slice I tried was a Wall Street tycoon - bold, confident, and packing a flavorful punch. The veggie option was like a well-traveled scholar, offering a delightful array of international flavors. And let's not forget the Margarita, a minimalist marvel, proving there's beauty in simplicity.
In conclusion, Mike's Pizza and steakhouse lives up to the hype. It's a place where the pizza is so good, you'll want to write sonnets about it. But be warned, once you've had a taste, you might find yourself permanently relocating to Iowa. Pizza lovers, let the pilgrimage begin!

The locals suggested this place to me. It's close to, if not, the best pizza I've ever eaten. Mike got it right. The crust was so perfect. I was very impressed. The Greek salad was spot on too. If I could give 6 stars, I would. I met Mike, he had an Italian accent. And I had such a good experience, I bought a Mike's Pizza T-shirt from him, so I could remember it.

They have really good pizza. Really enjoyed the Mike's special pizza. The mama mia is also very good but was a tad bit too spicy for me. Would get some pizza from here again!

I googled "best pizza in Ottumwa" and Mike's popped up as #1 on 3 or 4 sites. And they were RIGHT! This calzone I just had was absolutely delicious! Fresh, delicious crust, wonderful flavors. All around a top-notch meal. I will *definitely* eat here again the next time I'm in town.

Fantastic lil place, excellent food, got the mama Mia and it was the perfect amount of spice, wife had the Greek and I think I gotta try that next, and our waiter Sean knocked it out of the park with suggestions and service. Definitely our new main spot

Such a Very Satisfying & Delicious Menu. Great Staff (Especially Chloe!). Clean & Modern Interior. This Is 1 Of My Top 3 Iowa Restaurants

Our 1st time there & our steaks were cooked to perfection. Our meals were good. Service was good. Definitely will go back.

We ordered the house pizza and it was very good. Our waitress Rachel was excellent! We will definitely eat here again. 😋

Very good! My husband had the spaghetti and I had the ribeye (forgot to take a picture) great food great service.

Love this place! This is the best pizza in Ottumwa. The best pizza I've had in my entire life. There can be a wait so get there early. It's well worth the wait!

Enjoyed the Spicy Honey Pepperoni Pizza.
Nice Atmosphere for Family or a Date Night.

Calzone Momma Mia! Wow! Delicious with a kick. The food here is very good. The pricing is affordable and the service was exceptional. I will definitely put this on my list of places to eat, when I’m in town. Thank you for the great service and great food.

Food was delicious. The lady that served us was wonderful!

I had the best chef salad I have eaten, the last time I had the best chef salad was when I was a kid, server was very friendly, definitely will be going back

Always good food and service. I would have taken pictures and added them but we were hungry and forgot. Maybe next time. The wife had the steak sandwich with fries and I had the lasagna with Xtra bread sticks. Soooooo good!!!!!