The Original Bizzarro Famous New York Pizza

Had delivery. Originally from NY so was a little skeptic, but definitely did not disappoint! Pizza was on point and so good! Antipasto was good as well. Nothing like ordering a large pizza and having it arrive in 2 boxes (4 slices per box)

This is the best place to get pizza by the beach! You really can’t beat this location; right off 192 at the boardwalk. They offer free parking for this business specifically along the front entrance. You can eat in their outdoor seating area with a view of the ocean. They offer indoor seating as well. They have a variety of food options besides pizza, like pasta dishes, seafood, hot and cold subs, salads, and a even have a gluten free crust for pizzas. You can get beer and wine here as well. If you’re visiting the Indialantic, you have to try The Original Bizzarro’s.

About as close to a NY Pizza that I have found here in Brevard County.

Prices are very fair, the Pizza was delicious! Service was great. Sorry I didn't get here sooner, but I will be back...

10/19
Great visit, Great Pie, I wish they were closer to my home, but absolutely worth the ride!

This pizza is SO GOOD. I'm a pizza fanatic, and it made my top 5 list.

The crust was crispy and delicious, the sauce was homemade and wasn't too chunky or thickly spread, the cheese was gooey, and the sausage was cut in thin slices so it wasn't overwhelming. Bonus points for not adding the seedy fennel to the sausage. On top of that, they give you herbs, parmesan, AND red pepper flakes for the perfect flavor trio.

Last, but not least, the service was insanely fast, and everyone was so polite. I ordered up at the counter, and it felt like I got my pizza 10 minutes later. Then, to further add to the wonderful experience, it's RIGHT next to the beach.

Notable mention: We traveled 1.5 hours from Daytona Beach purely for this pizza place (recommended by my coworker), and we were not disappointed.

Absolutely amazing food, atmosphere, and especially people. The employees and owner are so great. 100/10

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I grew up coming here for the last 30 years and have never had a bad experience. It’s my favorite pizza spot in all Florida. The pizza comes out bubbling hot and always, always good. My all time favorite is the stuffed spinach slices, I’ve never had this anywhere else before. The calzones are so good and always filling. Can’t go wrong pairing this delicious pizza with Coke products or their beer selections. This is a cash only establishment* I haven’t spent much time in NYC but it’s better than what I’ve had there in a limited way.

By far one of our favorite places to eat when in town! Amazing New York style pizza with a super laid back feel! Staff are hard workers and so helpful. Be ready to order when you get to the counter and bring your cash 😆 We’ve never had a bad experience! Just be prepared for limited parking/seating if you go at peak times.

Best pizza in Melbourne and I dare say in the entire state if FL hands down. Truly NY style pizza. If at least 3 people jusf get a large pie, its more cost effective and it comes out fresh. A large pepperoni pie is $21 The garlic knots are also amazing. Very busy and its CASH ONLY so remember that before you walk in the door but they do have an ATM machine. A MUST visit.

Absolutely love this place! It’s a little hectic walking in the door and trying to order when “call ins” come to pick up cause those people don’t think they have to wait. The food is always amazing and staff was friendly also.

Their veggie pizza is the best pizza they have! Their cheese pizza is good too.
I get the veggie pizza and Their pineapple caribe is my usual order.

This is a cash only place. The pizza was delicious. The garlic knots were great, but they are dense, so you don't need many.

Definitely recommend. You can get by the slice and they have lots of good options. It was definitely popular and busy. They had a lot of pasta and sandwich options ... We may have to go back to try the other menu choices.

Today I went to Bizzarro’s for the second time because I had such a great first time experience. I ordered pepperoni pizza this time and was surprised how delicious it tasted. The menu has a variety of pizzas and toppings, everything sounds so good. I really wish Bizzaro’s would open a location in my area so my friends and family could experience how great the pizza is. Highly recommend this place to anyone who likes a pizza.

The pizza is so good!!!!!! The parking can be a little crazy because the parking lot is small. Sometimes there is a lot of parking and others you have to circle around a few times for a spot. The service is great and the food is always fresh. I have only had the pizza because we love it so much! They only take cash so please bring cash or you will have to use the ATM. The pizza slices are huge and they have the perfect amount of sauce, not too saucy but not too little sauce. They have inside and outside covered seating, inside can be a little hot because of the pizza ovens. Highly recommend!

Haven't been here in years. Came back home visiting family and brought my daughter and godson here for a slice. The nostalgia was very rich. Great service, great pizza, and an awesome time✊🏾

SIX STARS ☆☆☆☆☆☆

Best restaurant ever! I have been going here since it first opened, Frankie was always so nice and had an efficiently run restaurant. Now, every time it's Angelo working, he's maintaining that same level of quality. I can't recommend any other place for pizza because it's literally so much better than everywhere else that it's in its own category. I just went in there tonight and even though it was rainy and they were short staffed it was amazing service and as high quality as ever. That's definitely one of the signs of an awesome, professionally run business.

P.S. they have the best white pizza I have ever had, especially in the few states I havr previously lived in. I'm eating a slice literally as I type lolol. WHY DO OTHER PLACES USE ALFREDO FOR THE SAUCE?! I'm adding an extra ☆ for the white pizza!

As a native of Long Island now living in the Midwest, this place is a breath of fresh air. If you’re craving a New York slice like I always am, this is your place! Just order, sit down, and they will come bring the food to you!

When you’re allergic to dairy and still crave a Bizzaro pizza slice, that says a lot! Right off the beach on A1A, this place gets packed, and rightly so. Best NY pizza I’ve ever tasted not in NY. May even be better than that! My husband is a big eater and thought he could finish off two calzone-type slices. He was wrong, but a very happy man.

Best pizza ever had in Florida, just remember cash only, no plastic used here. Had the Sicilian pizza pie, outstanding

First off only cash so be prepared.
I had the the stuff meat pizza. I had only 1 piece and that was plenty. They do pit plenty of meat and cheese in that one piece. Nice blind of meats. Very flavorful. My wife had the white pizza. Again one piece was plenty. Nice blend
Of cheese and garlic flavor. Do yourself a favor and stop in and get some.

It's a real New York style pizza that accepts cash only. Easy to order a single slice and take a seat inside or outside. They deliver it to your table. Parking can be hard to find. I like the Greek slice.