Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs

Oh my! Size matters 🤣😂
I ordered a whole tukey bacon sandwich. 🙈

Got home, opened the bag, and -
Hello come in Tokyo! It was huge and super yummmm 😋

I could only eat half 🙄 - but now I have another meal 👍

Atmosphere - it's cute inside. I love the cow art. 👍

Service - I was looking over the menu on the wall, trying to find (The One) lol.
The young lady that took our order rushed us to order. 😳👎
The young man brought our 'Togo' order out to us - that was very kind 👍

The food is worth a return visit.
Thank you Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs!

I always get the Italian Combo Sandwich when I go to Papa Kelsey’s. I always get the 16” whole size. I normally split it when another person. It might not fill you both up completely, but it’s enough to get you both to your next meal. If you were to try to eat the whole sandwich yourself, you probably wouldn’t have to eat again for the rest of the day. The sandwich is delicious and full of meat and if you split it, it’s inexpensive. I’ve been getting these subs here for a long time and the quality has always been the same. Their oven baked sandwiches are some of the best around. The sandwich will come with a small bag of lays potato chips. The inside of the restaurant looks sharp and has a nice modern look to it. I’ll recommend Papa Kelsey’s any day.

Delicious food, friendly staff, comfortable dining experience .. our first time here was all very positive!! We thoroughly enjoyed our meal and plan to return soon !!

First time here! The dining area was very clean and the staff were friendly. We had 8 of us and the food was done very timely.

This the 6" Malibu Chicken with chips. It was yummy!

Always yummy. We love their sandwiches and pizza. The large sandwich is big enough to feed 2 adults. They cut it into 4 squares. The employees are also very nice.

amazing owners and amazing food! much love for my first time going, I’ll definitely come back!

This is a great place to eat. We love the steak and everything sandwich. We always get great service. It is very clean every time we go there. Best place in Buhl.

Will order the wrangler every time!!!! Also wonderful customer service!!!

Theu have the best bread....dough....OMG!!!

Their subs are unbelievably good!! I'm a regular! I have had them screw up orders before, but they’re very accommodating and willing to right the wrong. So worth going!

I love the pizza and the Italian Sub. I recommend you give them a try. Yummiest

We usually order pizza to go but today we ordered sandwiches. They were great and filling. The employees are friendly and kind. The Restaurant is clean and inviting

Really good pizza,perfectly cook crust.
Highly recommended for an amazing pizza!

Wonderful food. Great specials

Yummy food, local in Buhl. Really big portions, and polite and kind employees. Nice to have a neighborhood pizza and Sub place. Oh and I could live off their parmesan cheese sticks. 😀 Now if they only had Diet Coke. 😘

Papa Kelseys never disappoints. We have gone to 4. Always very good.

They make good sandwiches, salads and fries! The young man who was helping us was super nice! We enjoyed our visit!

Great food sadly only one girl working but wow she was working hard to get everyones order out!!! Very impressed with America she is a very hard worker and has extremely good customer service skill for a young woman!!

Great food, service with a smile, clean and fun place to sit for lunch... the salad was notably above the norm... very good!

Their whole menu contains very tasty offerings. I have never had any bad food there, be it dine in or take out.