Croton Bay Trading Post

Since the new owners took over the food is way better. I complained once about black/burnt cornmeal on the pizza and many, many pizzas later, never saw the black cornmeal again!!! Love all the different options too. Ohh and the delivery option is fantastic. Every driver has been super nice. Very happy they are in our community.

Great multi purpose shop. Live bait (worms/minnows), tackle, also have a convenience store and fresh cook food. Very friendly and helpful people!

Awsome place to rest ur legs from a long drive. The Trading Post is very clean and have very friendly staff.

Danielle & Buds crew at the Croton Bay Trading Post did an outstanding job with a fantastico a pizza a pie!!! Topped off after that with great Hudsonville Ice cream, FYI-Mint Chocolate and Butter Pecan. Very fare pricing! They also have flurries and shakes
They will deliver to a reasonable area for $3. They also have very cheap gas. And a deck that with a couple of tables overlooks the Muskegon River and Croton Dam. This little country shop isn't big, but it's a good old-fashioned country store. It has live bait, fishing tackle, a small grocery isle and a well-stocked fridge. The whole crew was so nice!

Their pizzas are awesome! And their ice cream is great! Everyone loves coming there by boat to grab a quick treat.

Visiting family for Fathers Day weekend and ordered 3 pizzas from here last night for the 1st time. It was hands down some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!! Very fresh ingredients, the crust was so buttery and crispy and the pizza was loaded with soo much cheese… heaven in my mouth. AND they delivered to my FIL who lives in the middle of nowhere! I can’t wait to order from here again

this is another wuststops for me theyhave amazing staff an owner that Atmore thangappy to assist you in whatever they can and if your hungry thryhave a great lunch or dinner menu. made to your liking

Great food, everything from Pizza to subs and even ice cream shop in the back. Right on the river.
-UPDATE- 03/02/22
New owners are nice and friendly, and there take with the pizza’s are amazing. Fresh ingredients, crust cook to perfection. I was literally blowed away by it. And usually I don’t praise like this but when it’s due, it’s due. Keep it up.

OMG!!! The Apple Pie Pizza is delicious 😋 and the subs were just as good. Way to go Ladies 💜

Great pizza & subs! Friendly staff and yummy ice cream.

Best pizza for a dam low price. We honestly only get pizza from the Post. Tried the overpriced pizza at another area gas station, had to throw away leftovers because we are dedicated Trading Post brats. You can get $2.00 pizza by the slice at the Post. Most of the time it is fresh. If not, I have been told "No charge". Their competition charges $2.50.

Great one stop shop for your fishing needs. Especially after you lose your lure below the dam! Friendly staff, good bait, and killer service! Good sandwiches too!

Best pizza place around.
I order think crust veggie pizza almost every time.
The staff is as nice as can be
Oh just thinking about pizza from there gets me every time.

I love the Trading Post. They can get very busy sometimes but that's no fault of their own!

If you want a great pizza this is the place to go in Croton. The staff is very friendly and the pizza, subs and all there food is great. They even have anchovies if you like them like I do.

I love this store. they have your normal gas station items as well as great food, ice cream, and fishing stuff, which is great for those that are on the pond and need something. the drive up docks are very convinient. prices a little high, but no higher than the other stores in croton.

Best pizza in Newaygo county. I’m never disappointed! Good selection of liquor, beer, and fishing stuff. Locally owned

Access from the water or road. Some fishing stuff and live bait. Hot pizza always ready. Snack food for your day trips on the water.

Grew up going here and have always liked their staff and the small town feel! They also have great food!

Great people, great pizza and kettlecorn !
Plus you can get there from croton pond !