Nutmeg's Cafe

This was one of my favorite restaurant in Sebring. Such a great menu and so many options I live a Keto lifestyle and had delicious menu choices which is rare!

First time here and I can't wait to go back! The chicken salad croissant was absolutely delicious!!! I can't believe I have been living in Sebring for 4 years and never been here... My new fav spot. Can't wait to try other things on the menu.

My daughter (who lives in Sebring) brought me here for lunch. The place was absolutely adorable with great food, pleasant atmosphere & sweet/kind service. I would definitely go more if I lived here! But alas, Pittsburgh, PA is my home 🥰

Nutmeg’s Cafe and Sebring diner are the two contenders for the best restaurants in Sebring, Fl. I believe Nutmeg’s edges out in front due to the menu variety. The Italian wedding soup we had (soup of the day) was unbelievable and set the tone for the rest of the lunch. The chicken bacon ranch wrap was so good as well. I am a sucker for cake balls and they were better than the major coffee chain’s. The old school/house renovated to be a cafe really set the mood as well. Fantastic place to stop by on the way through Sebring.

Wonderful. 1st time there. My husband and daughter both got paninis which they enjoyed. My daughter loved her side of pasta salad and my husband liked his potato salad as well. I had a Buddha bowl. They were kind enough to replace the kale with extra lettuce instead, and the raspberry dressing for lime cilantro which was very, very good. My bowl was HUGE! and absolutely delicious! We haven't eaten them yet, but did buy key lime cupcakes for later; I'm sure they will be awesome as well! Unsweetened ice tea was good and fresh as well. We will go back for sure~

I love Nutmegs! My go-to place for reasonably priced fresh organic food, homemade soups, Buddha Bowls & sandwiches. On the other hand, their cupcakes are a beautiful sweet delight! There's couches & comfy chairs for a nice relaxing atmosphere. Thank you Nutmegs!

We just moved to Sebring and went with 4 friends to try out Nutmeg's. From the very beginning, all 5 of us knew this was our kind of place! Both the owner and the employees were attentive and personal from the minute we entered. We all ordered something different. Different, yet delicious, is what you should expect at Nutmeg's. If you want standard tasty fare, go anywhere. But if you want unique and delicious food with wonderful variety - Nutmeg's is your place! We just retired, and love to play table games - How surprised we were to find a selection of table games for loan! I asked the owner, "Do people really come in here and play games?" YES THEY DO! You bet we'll be going back. And it was quiet enough to carry on a conversation for five retirees!

Highly recommend the blackened shrimp wrap. IT'S DELICIOUS! Everything was delightful!

Oh this little gem of a place ♥ I had the honey peanut butter grilled panini and it was so delish, paired with thier homemade cheeseburger soup was awesome but wait don't forget the cupcakes or cupcake pops these will blow your mind🤯

A mom and pop place serving a pretty decent lunch made with fresh ingredients. Will return to make my way through the rest of the menu.

The food is fabulous!!!! Definitely will be back !! Very convenient location. Friendly staff. If your in the area absolutely give it a try !

I love the quaint, bohemian atmosphere of this spot right off of US27. I ordered the special: A blackened shrimp wrap with a side of the fresh fruit ( grapes, strawberries, watermelon, blueberries, and pineapple). The food was excellent, and the staff are super friendly. I also tried the Passion hot tea which was delightful. I’ll definitely come back!

Sandwiches are amazing, chicken pot pie soup was a little on the salty but taste very good. Love the decor with the mix n match tables and chairs and the wall decor, also the leave without eating a cupcake 🧁 😋

A lovely restaurant! The atmosphere was nice and the food was amazing! Will visit again many times :)

What a gem. Homemade deliciousness. A must try! You won't be sorry.
Very clean.

Attentive staff, excellent food that's fresh and made to order. Top that off with really good coffee and you've got a place that's a perfect spot for a quick bite or a relaxing meal.

Great Casseroles & Salads & Treats

Their casseroles are awesome! We only get them twice a month (they offer them for presale twice a week) but they give us a bit of breathing room on busy evenings or just when we'd rather enjoy each other's company than cook and clean.

From macaroons to a Pear & Bacon Salad, their dine-im options are excellent as well.

Amazing food and staff! My picky daughter only wanted turkey and bread on her panini and they made it happen even though it was not on their menu! My chicken and spinach panini was delicious as always!!

Food was very tasty. Staff was friendly and helpful. They gave great suggestions. The inside of the cafe was very clean and comfortable. I would highly recommend it.

Absolutely delicious!!! We ordered the chicken with spinach sandwich along with a Reuben… so tasty!!! We absolutely, positively will be back!!